AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

OPERAPOLITIK.(future of opera houses in Berlin)

The New Yorker

| December 16, 2002 | Ross, Alex | COPYRIGHT 2002 All rights reserved. Reproduced by permission of The Condé Nast Publications Inc. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

Only in Berlin would an argument over the future of three opera houses take on the dimensions of a constitutional crisis. Here is how things stand in the first days of December: the Social Democratic Party, which governs Germany with the Greens, supports a plan to unite the Staatsoper, on Unter den Linden, with the Deutsche Oper, in the west. Daniel Barenboim, the Staatsoper's music director, fiercely opposes the idea. The Christian Democratic Union, meanwhile, wants to put not only these two companies under one administration but also a third--the smaller-scale Komische Oper. Thomas Flierl, Berlin's cultural tsar, who belongs to the ex-communist Party for Democratic Socialism, has yet to commit himself one way or another. Berliners have lost all patience with this mess, but visiting Americans may be charmed by the fact that politicians here take an interest in opera at all. I realized that my sojourn in Berlin had taken me into uncharted waters when, during an intermission one evening, Professor Christoph Stolzl, the chief of the Berlin C.D.U., took me aside to talk about Arnold Schoenberg. Any right-minded American politician would sooner be photographed dangling a baby over a hotel balcony--as Michael Jackson was, in a startling contribution to the city's musical politics--than be caught dead at the opera.

In the past few months, Berlin's opera houses have maintained their place in the limelight by presenting an array of unusually outre productions. The Komische Oper led with a beery, working-class version of "The Bartered Bride," which the critic Manuel Brug described as "Schmettana instead of Smetana." The Deutsche Oper responded with a "Werther" that had Goethe's star-crossed lovers meeting in a laundromat--a mise en scene so realistic that clothes were seen tumbling in the windows of the dryers. ("Others throw bombs, I direct opera," Sebastian Baumgarten, the gifted but erratic young director, proclaimed.) The Staatsoper weighed in with a heavily congested production of Shostakovich's "The Nose," conceived by the painter Jorg Immendorff. The orchestra wore space-alien bodysuits, while singers and chorus members impersonated major players in Middle Eastern politics, from Saddam Hussein to Kofi Annan. We were even treated to a singing Osama bin Laden. The staging seemed designed to provoke a scandal, and, in anticipation of rotten tomatoes, Immendorff told Der Spiegel that he would go to the premiere dressed in "washable fabrics." But the scandal of "The Nose" was that there was no scandal; the creative team received a unanimous round of tepid applause. There was no need for Immendorff to drop by the Deutsche Oper to get his laundry done.

Does a city really need three opera houses? Probably not, but Berlin has long taken pride in its embarrassment of operatic riches. If one house closes, the city will end up with the same eminently sensible--and thus eminently predictable--arrangement that applies in New York, Paris, and London. There will be the "big" house, like the Met or Covent Garden, presenting de-luxe productions with international stars; and there will be the "alternative" house, like New York City Opera or English National Opera, staking out slightly more adventurous repertory. With three companies, you never quite know what you're going to get: perhaps a flamboyant diva performance set against a strict Brechtian concept; perhaps a cast of unknowns trapped in an avant-garde nightmare. Since all three houses are strapped for money, you tend to see fewer international stars, more hungry young singers, and, even on the lunatic fringe, better nights of theatre.

The "opera misery," as one critic has dubbed the situation, honors a long local tradition of byzantine cultural-political imbroglios. Many of the same battles were fought in the nineteen-twenties, when the Staatsoper faced competition from two new entities--the Stadtische Oper, on the site of the present Deutsche Oper, and the Kroll Oper, on the Platz der Republik. Suddenly, the city had ...

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Opera 'self-censored'.(Deutsche Oper Berlin, Idomeneo)(Brief article)
Magazine article from: Presbyterian Record November 1, 2006 700+ words
...following the decision of a Berlin opera house not to stage Mozart...artists and politicians including Berlin's governing mayor Klaus Wowereit...was to have been performed at Berlin's Deutsche Oper, Idomeneo appears in the epilogue...
The `Ring': Mad for the Myth;Deutsche Oper Berlin Brings the 16-Hour,...
Newspaper article from: The Washington Post Joseph McLellan May 28, 1989 700+ words
...punishments has been staged for the Deutsche Oper Berlin, in a set that recalls the distinctive...celebration (while its opera house in Berlin is being renovated), this "Ring...because of the competition from Berlin and the Met. This was probably...
Frances Ginzer. (Artists on Stage).(after her Covent Garden debut as Turandot,...
Magazine article from: Opera Canada So, Joseph March 22, 2003 700+ words
Fresh from her Covent Garden debut as Turandot, soprano Frances Ginzer assayed Brunnhilde in the Deutsche Oper Berlin Ring Cycle, conducted by Christian Thielemann. Ginzer is also slated to sing Brunnhilde in the Canadian Opera Company's Die...
The Presold `Ring' Cycle; Deutsche Oper Tickets Gone - 6 Months Early
Newspaper article from: The Washington Post Joseph McLellan December 20, 1988 700+ words
...tickets to the Deutsche Oper's production...the prestigious Berlin company. The same...likely that the Berlin "Ring," like...the season. The Deutsche Oper has engaged two...conducting the Deutsche Oper's orchestra and...to $30. The Berlin company's visit...
Boris Godunov (at the Deutsche Oper).
Magazine article from: Opera Canada Jochen Breiholz June 22, 1996 700+ words
IN THE NEW BORIS GODUNOV AT THE DEUTSCHE Oper, Gotz Friedrich shaped the characters thoughtfully. Thanks...the ugliest design seen on this stage for years. The first Berlin performance of George Enescu's Oedipe also suffered under...
The Wingding For the `Ring' ; The Deutsche Oper Bids Happy Trails at a Hoedown
Newspaper article from: The Washington Post Roxanne Roberts June 19, 1989 700+ words
...Greenberg and his wife, Monica, threw open the gates of their Virginia horse farm Saturday afternoon to give the Deutsche Oper Berlin a taste of the good ol' U.S. of A. Willkommen, pardners. "They wanted to do something very American so...
Video -- Verdi's Otello by Renata Tebaldi, Hans Beirer, and others with...
Magazine article from: Opera News McKee, David February 3, 1996 700+ words
...Otello Tebaldi, S. Wagner; Beirer, Dooley. Sardi; Deutsche Oper, G. Patane. Legato Classics VHS LCV-004, 147 mins...Fi mono What bids fair to be a shaky Gastspiel from the Deutsche Oper, c. 1962, proves surprisingly moving and revelatory...
Oregon Ballet Theatre. (People and Companies).(Katarina Svetlova to perform in...
Magazine article from: Dance Magazine January 1, 2003 700+ words
KATARINA SVETLOVA of Oregon Ballet Theatre will dance her first Odette/Odile in Swan Lake in January with the Deutsche Oper am Rhein in Dusseldorf, under the direction of YOURI VAMOS.
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA