AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Ethical concerns committee: no cause for concern.(Code of Ethics Revision Committee)

American Music Teacher

| October 01, 2005 | Luther, Sigrid; Legere, Kathleen | COPYRIGHT 2005 Music Teachers National Association, Inc. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

When the Code of Ethics Revision Committee considered the formation of an Ethical Concerns Committee (ECC), we grappled at length with the issues so clearly articulated by LeAnne Baehni-Schultz in the June/July AMT. It was well known to us that the MTNA Board of Directors had previously decided against any enforcement of ethical standards on the grounds that MTNA recommends, but does not require ethical behavior and since no process of enforcement existed at the time, complaints were basically at the local level, and the violation of ethical standards brought about its own consequences.

It was appropriate to revisit this decision as we updated the Code itself. Instructive to us were examples of ethical complaint procedures in the business world as well as in sister arts associations. We examined the requirements for due process, as outlined in the Association Law Handbook and saw them fleshed out in the documents of the National Association of Teachers of Singing (NATS), among other organizations.

Committee member and NATS Executive Director William Vessels noted that during his total 23 years on the NATS Board in various capacities, its ethics committee successfully resolved numerous complaints over the years, with only one revocation of membership.

Central to our deliberation in MTNA was the purpose of an Ethical Concerns Committee. Our goal was not to police members, but rather to assist them with ethical complaints and work with them toward solutions. We realized that several local and state affiliates had such committees in place. If these affiliates stood ready to assist members with ethical dilemmas, it seemed incongruous for the national level to take a hands-off approach largely based on the narrow concept of an ethics committee for "enforcement." And while local problems might best be solved at the local level, is it not in the spirit of MTNA to have a national resource, should local attempts fail? Another benefit of the establishment of the ECC is that it adds an additional facet to our self-regulation, decreasing the likelihood of outside regulation.

The procedures for ethical concerns, as adopted by the Board of Directors, are organized into three sections: a) Submission of a Concern; b) Ethical Concerns Committee and c) Referral to MTNA Board of Directors. Members are strongly encouraged to work out ethical problems themselves. If the involved parties cannot resolve issues, a member may report an alleged ethical infringement to the executive director, who may be able to expedite a resolution. When ethical concerns cannot be immediately resolved, the ECC will be called upon to work toward a resolution. At both of these stages, steps are prescribed to ensure communication and as much anonymity as possible. There are also provisions for the executive director or the ECC to stop the process if, for example, a resolution is not forthcoming and further intervention would not be productive. Particularly grievous offences may be ...

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Environmental and Ethical Concerns from the Consumers Point of View.
Press release article from: M2 Presswire June 6, 2007 700+ words
...Research and Markets: Environmental and Ethical Concerns from the Consumers Point of View...RDATE:07062007 Environmental and Ethical Concerns from the Consumer's Point of View...report looks at environmental and ethical concerns from the consumer's point of view...
MMA Survey: Most Religious Investors Would Consider Dumping Mutual Fund if it...
Press release article from: PR Newswire November 12, 2003 700+ words
...Investors, identifies the top five ethical concerns for U.S. religious investors...top five. The five most important ethical concerns for these investors are (in order...responding investors. Of the top five ethical concerns for all investors in 2003, four are...
Ethical concerns tax AICPA, practitioners.(American Institute of Certified...
Magazine article from: Accounting Today Hock, Sandy December 11, 1995 700+ words
WASHINGTON -- When it comes to ethical concerns, it's hard to be a tax practitioner these days...protect themselves. Friedman addressed practitioners' ethical concerns at a recent AICPA tax meeting. In his talk, he called...
ETHICAL CONCERNS AT HEART OF DISCUSSIONS ON GMO DIRECTIVE.
Newspaper article from: European Report June 19, 1999 700+ words
Ethical concerns returned to the forefront of the debate on genetic engineering when...issue discussed was whether EU Member States should take account of ethical concerns in issuing licences for the marketing of GMOs, and if so, under...
A Technology Going to the Dogs? Biotech Start-up's Pet Clone Auction Raises...
Magazine article from: BIOWORLD Today Turner, Tiffany May 22, 2008 700+ words
...enough." That spirit of profiteering is the root of many ethical concerns over the auction and pet cloning as a science. Nina Mak...like identical twins." Lanza also highlighted several ethical concerns regarding the health of cloned animals. "We've now...
ETHICAL CONCERNS ARISE FROM CAMCORDER.(Preview)
Newspaper article from: Albany Times Union (Albany, NY) August 1, 1991 700+ words
...potential for abuse exists. There are no federal or state laws specifically regulating camcorder use, but there are plenty of ethical concerns, civil rights experts say. "Our point is that if you're taping someone without their knowledge - this is different...
Environmental and Ethical Concerns From the Consumer's Point of View.
Press release article from: Business Wire June 6, 2007 700+ words
...their commitment to the environment, and to doing business in an ethical manner. This report looks at environmental and ethical concerns from the consumer's point of view. Are consumers happy to try and take these issues into consideration in their daily...
Incentives may pose ethical concerns.(News)
Magazine article from: Internal Medicine News Schneider, Mary Ellen May 15, 2007 700+ words
...the Institute for Ethics of the American Medical Association. Limited data are available about pay-for-performance ethical concerns, in part because these programs are so new and researchers need more time to study their effects, he said. The programs...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA