AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.
Create a link to this page
Copy and paste this link tag into your Web page or blog:
Concierge Care? No Thank You.
"Concierge" care isn't unethical, but I doubt it is money well spent ("Pro & Con: Is concierge' care an ethical alternative?" March 15, 2002, p. 5).
The well to do "worried well" have more money than sense. No healthy person needs 24-hour cell phone access to a personal physician, or four 4-hour "executive physicals" a year. Smart and dedicated physicians, especially those working for themselves, always have same-day appointment for truly ill patients and patients don't pay extra.
Dr. Ira Mandel's suggestion that physicians are obligated to care for the underserved because the public pays for their education is unconvincing. The same case could be made for lawyers, who aren't known for being charitable, and who would laugh at the suggestion. Physicians can treat whomever they please!
Further, alternative "strategies for scheduling, arranging office visits" will not make up for declining reimbursement. High-end, cash-up-front procedures will for some; witness the growth of cosmetic laser surgery.
Some of us went into medicine for the sheer joy of treating patients, not to maximize our incomes. My patients have always been low to middle income, with a healthy dose of Medicaid. You can keep your concierge" care populations.
David A. Rivera, M.D.
Source: HighBeam Research, Letters.