LEONCAVALLO: Pagliacci.(Review)

LEONCAVALLO: Pagliacci [] Petrella; di Stefano, Protti, Alva, Sordello; Chorus and Orchestra of La Scala, Milan, Sanzogno. 1956. Notes, Italian text. MYTO MCD 012.244

This performance was captured on April 24, 1956, during what is considered by many to have been the modern golden age of singing at La Scala. This must have been an off night. Although the interpretations are zestful, most of the singing, except that of one cast member, borders on crudeness.

Giuseppe di Stefano made his official opera debut in 1946 and soon was in demand internationally. By 1956, however, his excessive spreading in the upper register had begun to take its toll. This seems to have been a period of transition, in which the tenor was extending his repertoire to embrace heavier roles. Perhaps because of this and his heavy performing schedule, some of the more climactic moments in this performance lack the expected ring and freedom. No one, however, could dispute his dramatic conviction. The intense personal grief of the famous "Vesti la giubba" is superbly done -- sincerely felt and magnificently communicated.

Clara Petrella was a La Scala regular during this period, especially known for her singing of the standard verismo repertoire, as well as a ...