Exhillaration.(The Talk of the Town)(Hillary Clinton)

The Presidential flight of Hillary Rodham Clinton, which had been aloft for nearly a year, began its descent stage on January 3, 2008, somewhere over Iowa. Five months later to the day, she piloted it to a smooth touchdown, though not without experiencing some turbulence during the final approach. First, there was her non-concession speech, delivered on the final Tuesday of the primary season; then, after a few days of cogitation, consultation, and commiseration, there was her Saturday speech. Tuesday's speech was anything but full of grace, and, on the whole, was poorly received. Saturday's was greeted rapturously, often by the same commentators. "The way to continue our fight now, to accomplish the goals for which we stand," Clinton said, "is to take our energy, our passion, our strength, and do all we can to help elect Barack Obama the next President of the United States." And she said, echoing the signature chant of the Obama campaign, "Today, I am standing with Senator Obama to say: Yes, we can!" She could scarcely have been more emphatic.

With that, the most astounding primary season in American history came to an end. It was astounding not because of the policy differences separating the competing sides (these were trivial compared with their vast reaches of agreement), or because of the turmoil of the times and the bitterness of the clash (compared with the two campaigns of the Vietnam War era, 1968 and 1972, all was calm and collegial), but because of who the candidates were--more precisely, because of what they were. The first woman and the first man of color to have a serious chance of victory contended for the right to represent America's party of progressive change in the contest for the most powerful office on earth, and they fought each other very nearly to a draw. This conspicuous, astonishing fact was not much discussed by the candidates themselves; for them, the point was to transcend "identity politics," lest they be trapped in its stereotypes. Only when compelled by the antics of the retiring minister of his church did Obama directly confront the questions of race and identity, doing so in a speech of such power and nuance that it saved his campaign. Clinton--whose "identity," after all, comprises more than half the electorate and extends, by definition, into every family on earth--treated her gender as a grace note, a significant but ultimately secondary feature, like Jimmy Carter's Southernness or Bob Dole's war wound. Only in the final appearance of her exhausting campaign did Hillary Clinton speak at length about, in her words, "what it means to be a woman running for President."

Much of what she said was phrased in such a way as to apply to Obama as well as to herself. "I am a woman and, like millions of women, I know there are still barriers and biases out there, often unconscious, and I want to build an America that respects and embraces the potential of every last one of us," she declared. "There are no acceptable limits, and there are no acceptable prejudices in the twenty-first century in our country." And, speaking of herself, Obama, and the supporters of both: "We will make history together."

In the emotional climax of her speech, she said, "Although we weren't able to shatter that highest, hardest glass ceiling this time, thanks to you it's got about eighteen million cracks in it--and the light is shining through like never before, filling us all with the hope and the sure knowledge that the path will be a little easier next time." Some people interpreted this to imply that it was her gender that denied her the prize. Only she knows whether she meant it that way, or whether that's what she believes. In such a close race, of course, almost any factor can be viewed as decisive. But it's hard to find anyone who will dispute ...