AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.
Create a link to this page
Copy and paste this link tag into your Web page or blog:
SIR: In his address to the Quadrant dinner (October 2007), Tom Switzer points to examples within the Australian economy, judiciary and media that prove "the tide is turning in Australia's culture wars", and with a notable degree of pride.
In reference to the discipline of Australian history--where "nothing better demonstrates the cultural sea change"--his argument breaks down. In 2007, it is important to recognise that by maintaining "Windschuttle's success" as a victory for the conservative front in the culture wars, Switzer (like many others) risks further trivialising the condition of the Australian discipline of history. History, objective and neutral in its goals for the pursuit of truth, should at once see beyond right and left, conservative and progressive.
One need not identify as "conservative" to agree with Windschuttle's premise that much of recent Australian historiography has been written with an exceedingly sympathetic pen. One need not identify as "conservative" to have grown bored of the recurring defeatism which peppers Australian opinions on the history of our nation (and it should be noted here that nation-state histories in themselves are becoming increasingly recognised as boring approaches). And one does not have to be "conservative" to confess a scepticism of the popular genocide thesis of Australian ...
Source: HighBeam Research, Beyond left and right.(Letters)(Letter to the editor)