AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Paul Laurence Dunbar and the genres of dialect.(Essay)

African American Review

| June 22, 2007 | Cohen, Michael | COPYRIGHT 1999 African American Review. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

In a 1902 interview with the Chicago Tribune, Paul Laurence Dunbar was asked, "And when you do write have you more pleasure in negro songs or in others?" Sometimes I am fascinated by the negro song," Dunbar responded. "It carries me along-writes or sings itself. But the form is so purely lyrical that it is limited.... The negro song must be sentimental--it must be a love song or a lullaby, or a song of home longing, or something of that sort." Dunbar's interviewer then offered the opinion that "negro song.... holds something of the same relation to American poetry that Scottish songs do to English poetry.... Scottish ballads were peculiarly adapted to war themes, but the negro ballad would not be, would it?" Dunbar disagreed with this last point, noting "I have a ballad beginning, 'When they 'listed cullud soldiers an' 'Lias went to wah.' Negro songs of that sort are liable to be more mournful than stirring, perhaps, but this is not in the necessity of things. Of course, too, the negro ballad is well adapted to be narrative, but it must be simple narrative. It cannot be epic.... [W]hatever is most charming about the negro dialect is in the way of endearing words. Its genre is domestic, so to speak" (E. W. P.).

"Negro songs," according to Dunbar, could be "lyrical" and "narrative," "sentimental" and "stirring," "domestic" and "martial." Although it provides no clear definition of "negro songs," this interview still offers a fascinating insight into Dunbar's thoughts on the widely noted distinction between his dialect and non-dialect poems. Dialect poems, in Dunbar's account, were a particular poetic genre (capacious as it might be), and were not simply inflections of other standard poetic genres. According to Dunbar, "negro dialect," with its "endearing words," contributed greatly to the "lyrical" effects (sentimentalism, mournfulness, charm) for which "negro songs" were noted, so that a variety of poetic types (love songs, lullabies, songs of home longing, martial narratives) all became "negro songs" when they were written in "negro dialect." Dunbar and his interviewer compared "negro songs" to "Scottish ballads," and collapsed these two types into a third, "negro ballads." "Ballad," "song," and "dialect" were all conflated, but their shared modifier, "negro," was stabilized by the turn to Scottish balladry. In the generic hierarchy of 1902, "Scottish ballads" were the epitome of a kind of poetry understood as "popular," in the sense that they were believed to index the collective experience and identity of a people; by comparing Dunbar's dialect poems to Scottish ballads, the interview provided these poems with a similar "popular" identity.

This essay situates some of Dunbar's poems within late 19th-century debates about "popular" poetic genres, in particular popular ballads and slave spirituals; my concern is to demonstrate the relation of Dunbar's dialect poems as poems to particular histories of thought about poetic genres in the nineteenth century. Critics like William Dean Howells associated Dunbar with a notion of black "folk" and with a concept of "black vernacular dialect" that had been articulated through prior discourses on popular poetry. Although Dunbar was born after the Civil War and lived his entire life in northern cities, he became the poet of southern, rural black folk because pre-existing modes of thought about folk genres provided readers with paradigms to read him as such. Naming dialect poems as "negro ballads" condensed into a single term a train of associations--from ballad to spiritual to dialect poem--that enabled printed, aesthetic poems like Dunbar's to mediate cultural fantasies about oral pre-modern culture. Through this elision, 19th-century readers substituted abstractions of genre for persons and personal voices, so that certain kinds of poems came to stand for certain kinds of social experience. Therefore, when writers, readers, and critics of dialect poetry described dialect poems as though they were like ballads and spirituals, they did so to authenticate dialect poems as the expressions of racialized folk groups, no matter who actually wrote the poems.

"Negro ballad" is a term with many valences. Besides the contexts of popular ballads and spirituals, "negro ballad" also referred to songs of the minstrel theater, such as those by Stephen Foster. By the postbellum period (when the popularity of minstrelsy waned considerably), minstrel songs were thoroughly constituted by the deployment of racist caricatures that used conventional sets of malapropisms, misspellings, and mispronunciations to represent black speech as a degraded form of standard English; the aural conventions of minstrel speech and song worked in tandem with the visual orientation of blackface performance to produce the racial, social, and cultural politics of minstrelsy. (1) As Lisa Gitelman has argued, the aural structure of blackface intensified in the 1890s with the mass popularization of coon songs, which were sold both as sheet music and as phonograph records. In contrast to blackface minstrelsy, which was primarily a working-class cultural form, coon songs "were played in middle-class parlors, concerts, syndicated vaudeville, and the other bourgeois venues where sheet music was increasingly consumed," sites shared by late-century dialect poems (and slave spirituals); Gitelman quotes the June 1905 catalogue of Edison's phonograph company, which advertised recent recordings of a "romping coon song" and a "Negro dialect poem" by Dunbar (134-35).

Critics of Dunbar's dialect poems, particularly since the 1920s, have often read them in relation to the context of minstrelsy, (2) The context of minstrel theater and coon songs certainly contributed to the ways that readers consumed and interpreted Dunbar's dialect poems; Dunbar himself collaborated with Will Marion Cook on several minstrel productions at the turn into the twentieth century. However, minstrelsy was merely one frame of reference for readers at the time, and…

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Schulz-Beuthen: Symphony 5; Isle of the Dead; Negro Songs & Dances; Farewell...
Magazine article from: American Record Guide Bauman, Carl May 1, 2003 700+ words
...effective. It certainly suggests the fear associated with death. It develops more quickly than Rachmaninoff's piece. The Negro Songs and Dances are what is described as a "charming and unpretentious suite". These were written in 1880, long before Dvorak...
Dunbar, the originator.(Paul Laurence Dunbar)
Magazine article from: African American Review Braxton, Joanne M. June 22, 2007 700+ words
I once referred to accidental Dunbar scholar, understating the fact that I...was born in the bed with Paul Laurence Dunbar, born in the bed, as they say, the...some are born in the bed with gold, with Dunbar as a substantial part of my literary inheritance...
Dunbar Cash Vault Services & WAUSAU Sign Multi-Year Agreement for Remote...
Press release article from: PR Newswire November 2, 2006 700+ words
...MOSINEE, Wis., Nov. 2 /PRNewswire/ -- Dunbar Cash Vault Services, a division of Dunbar Armored, the nation's largest independent...offer retail merchant and bank customers of Dunbar Cash Vault Services the benefits of WAUSAU...
Dunbar Armored Selects Ultimate Software and Intersourcing for Comprehensive...
Press release article from: Business Wire September 10, 2008 700+ words
...management solutions, announced today that Dunbar Armored, Inc. is implementing UltiPro...SaaS) delivery model, Intersourcing. Dunbar Armored, one of the nation's largest...and vice president, human resources for Dunbar Armored, Inc. "We're excited about...
Dunbar hopes to ignite QB run game: Former California offensive coordinator...
Newspaper article from: Saint Paul Pioneer Press (St. Paul, MN) August 28, 2007 700+ words
...Fuller Aug. 28--A major reason Mike Dunbar left a golden opportunity at California...wanted. As Cal's offensive coordinator, Dunbar was able to make the Bears more balanced...blend the spread offense with his," said Dunbar, 58, a Tacoma, Wash., native...
Paul Laurence Dunbar: a credit to his race?
Magazine article from: African American Review Robinson, Lillian S. Robinson, Greg June 22, 2007 700+ words
...the twentieth century, Paul Laurence Dunbar's reputation shifted between that of...Much of this volatility originates in Dunbar's odd dual status as a writer and a...representation and criticism. Although Dunbar's works were known among both whites...
Dunbar the Makar.
Magazine article from: Medium Aevum Mapstone, Sally September 22, 1993 700+ words
This is the first major study of Dunbar, a poet who has attracted more attention...fantastical pieces to the petitions. Part of Dunbar's critical elusiveness lies in his difficulty...strategies highlight another problem: Dunbar's versatility. 'Dunbar speaks with...
Picturing Dunbar's lyrics.(Paul Laurence Dunbar)
Magazine article from: African American Review Sapirstein, Ray June 22, 2007 700+ words
...after his death in 1906, Paul Laurence Dunbar published six books of poetry in African...equivalent emphasis. (1) Comprising half Dunbar's output of published poetry, and among...the illustrated editions demonstrate Dunbar's substantial interaction with photography...
Paul Laurence Dunbar and the African American Elegy.
Magazine article from: African American Review Blount, Marcellus June 22, 2007 700+ words
...passing of her noblest born.--Paul Laurence Dunbar, "Frederick Douglass" 11. 1-6) Quietly, this stanza begins Paul Laurence Dunbar's long elegy for Frederick Douglass. Here, Dunbar's speaker solemnly utters sentiments that...
Karl Dunbar is the leader of the Minnesota Vikings' 'alpha males': Charged with...
News wire article from: The America's Intelligence Wire December 21, 2008 700+ words
...s Vikings defensive line coach Karl Dunbar, the man in charge of maximizing the...the right touch, on and off the field. Dunbar works largely in the shadows of coach...those around him recognize the value of Dunbar's coaching style and the trust he has...
For more facts and information, see all results

Source: HighBeam Research, Paul Laurence Dunbar and the genres of dialect.(Essay)

©2010 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved. About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA

The AccessMyLibrary advertising network includes: womensforum.com GlamFamily