AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

THE DEVIL'S ACCOUNTANT.(Noam Chomsky criticizes foreign policy)

The New Yorker

| March 31, 2003 | Macfarquhar, Larissa | COPYRIGHT 2003 All rights reserved. Reproduced by permission of The Condé Nast Publications Inc. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

On Thursday evenings at M.I.T., Noam Chomsky, one of the greatest minds of the twentieth century and one of the most reviled, teaches a class about politics. There are nearly two hundred students and not enough chairs, so latecomers sit or lie down on the floor, which gives the class the air of a teach-in. On a recent evening, the students came to hear Chomsky speak about Iraq. He sat with his arms folded, a little hunched over on his stool, and began to talk into a microphone. He was wearing what he usually wears: shirt, sweater, jeans, sneakers. His hair curled toward the middle of his neck and looked as though he didn't pay it much attention. He spoke in a quiet monotone.

"When I look at the arguments for this war, I don't see anything I could even laugh at,"he said. "You don't undertake violence on the grounds that maybe by some miracle something good will come out of it. Yes, sometimes violence does lead to good things. The Japanese bombing of Pearl Harbor led to many very good things. If you follow the trail, it led to kicking Europeans out of Asia--that saved tens of millions of lives in India alone. Do we celebrate that every year?”

Chomsky told the students that the current Administration was essentially the same as the first Bush Administration and the Reagan Administration, and therefore could not be trusted to replace a tyrant. "The first foreign leader invited to the White House by George Bush No. 1 was Mobutu, who was one of the worst gangsters in modern African history,"Chomsky said. "Another one they loved was General Suharto. His record easily compares with Saddam Hussein's. Another one they adored was Marcos of the Philippines. In every single one of these cases, the people now in Washington supported them right through their worst atrocities. Are these the people you would ask to bring freedom to Iraqis?"

A student wearing a red V-neck sweater raised his hand to ask a question. "I just was wondering whether this is really a strong argument if you are talking about the motives of the government,"he began, in a european accent.

"I'm talking about expectations,"Chomsky interrupted.

"If Saddam is a monster,"the student went on, "what does it matter, actually, who is going to get rid of him? If you look at the Second World War, the alliance with Stalin was also not a very nice thing, but it was absolutely necessary.”

"Well, let's pick a worse monster than Saddam Hussein,"Chomsky said. "Suppose we could get Saddam Hussein to conquer North Korea. Would you be in favor of it?"

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
(Saddam) Hussein versus Hitler?
Magazine article from: Esprit de Corps Taylor, S.R. April 1, 2002 700+ words
...towards Adolf Hitler's Nazi Germany: "With gutless little...keys to the world over to Saddam Hussein right now." While this...PR campaign to establish Saddam Hussein as the next tangible threat...were withdrawn in 1998, Saddam Hussein has refused to let UN weapons...
One with Nineveh and Tyre. (Saddam Hussein's and Iraq's cultural policies)
Magazine article from: National Review Gardner, James May 13, 1991 700+ words
LIKE Hitler before him, Saddam Hussein is, after his fashion, an artist and...Nebuchadnezzar was reconstructed in the era of Saddam Hussein." Nebuchadnezzar, be it remembered...any more than the art and culture of Nazi Germany c
Folie a' deux. (Saddam Hussein and George Bush; Persian Gulf War) (editorial)
Magazine article from: The Nation March 11, 1991 700+ words
...He has a crazy kind of integrity." So it seemed with Saddam Hussein. And George Bush. Until February 21, the two pit bulls...the kind of plan Henry Morgenthau Sr. once advanced for Nazi Germany: the reduction of the enemy state to a preindustrial, demilitarized...
'Hitler and Nazi Germany' and 'The Holocaust.'(two books)
Magazine article from: Teaching History: A Journal of Methods Saylor, Thomas March 22, 2002 700+ words
Frank McDonough. Hitler and Nazi Germany. New York and Cambridge, UK: Cambridge...one of these gaps with his Hitler and Nazi Germany, while Peter Neville, Senior Lecturer...another with The Holocaust. In Hitler and Nazi Germany, McDonough has produced a clearly written...
Interpretations of Nazi Germany.
History Review Claydon, John March 1, 2001 700+ words
...historiography. More words have been written about Nazi Germany than any other period of history, and...daily basis, no one can feel an expert on Nazi Germany. Nevertheless interpretations of Nazi Germany have always revolved around two main issues...
Nazi Germany and Neutral Europe during the Second World War.
Magazine article from: The Australian Journal of Politics and History Welch, Steven R. September 1, 2002 700+ words
...diplomatic and economic relations between Nazi Germany and these five neutrals. In the process...exhibiting the greatest sympathy with Nazi Germany and Turkey and Portugal maintaining...readable overview of the relations between Nazi Germany and the European neutrals. This is...
Nazi Germany and the Jews. (book reviews)
Magazine article from: History Today Rubinstein, William D. December 1, 1998 700+ words
Nazi Germany and the Jews The Years of Persecution...present time. Saul Friedlander's Nazi Germany and the Jews was published to great...attempted to tell the story of the Jews in Nazi Germany prior to the war in this multifaceted...
Michaud, Eric: The Cult of Art in Nazi Germany.(Book Review)
Magazine article from: History: Review of New Books Cherry, Rachael I. September 22, 2004 700+ words
Michaud, Eric The Cult of Art in Nazi Germany Trans. Janet Lloyd Palo Alto, CA...Date: March 2004 In The Cult of Art in Nazi Germany, Eric Michaud, a professor at the...specific pieces and types of art in Nazi Germany, Michaud views art as a conductor...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA