AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.
Create a link to this page
Copy and paste this link tag into your Web page or blog:
SIR: In my review of George Molnar's fine book Powers (September 2003) I spoke of the tired rhetoric that followers of Hume direct against the old metaphysics of powers, now revived by Molnar and many other distinguished philosophers. I did not say, although it is the case, that a new rhetoric is used by many who uphold the real existence of powers. An example is to be found in the letter from Christopher Game in your November issue. He contrasts "Newton's chilly, impassive inactive material particles" with the "creative, causative, energetic, originative, wilful, passionate activity as the sole ultimate abstraction of the existent". This is meant to warm us to the powers.
The argument currently going on between those who explain the regularity of the world in terms of laws of nature, and those who appeal instead to the powers of particular ...