AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

NYT spies a story; overlooks the facts.(Beat the Press: The hand that rules the press ... rules the country--Judge Learned Hand)(New York Times)

The American Enterprise

| April 01, 2006 | Weinkopf, Chris | COPYRIGHT 2006 The American Enterprise, a national magazine of politics, business and culture (TEAmag.com). This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

In Journalism 101, students learn to write newspaper stories in what's referred to as the Inverted Pyramid--with all the important, newsworthy information at the top, and the less relevant details relegated to the bottom. The technique is simple, logical and efficient--and ignored by many of today's reporter hotshots.

To make it big in the establishment media, many writers follow what could be called the Perverted Pyramid, which looks more like an hourglass. In this format, the reporter places the points that support his or her agenda up at the top of the story, some mind-numbing minutiae in the middle, and the key details that contradict his or her point of view way down at the bottom. Few readers are likely to make it to the inconvenient facts. Yet no one can claim the reporter didn't present both sides.

Lots of media outlets now regularly pervert the reporting pyramid, but few as expertly as the New York Times. And in its latest series of trademark overblown page-one stories designed to destroy the Bush Presidency--these revealing the U.S. National Security Agency's tapping of terrorist calls to and from the U.S.--the Gray Lady perverts the pyramid in grand style.

In the series' first article, the third paragraph tells us that the NSA program may have "stretched, if not crossed, Constitutional limits on legal searches." But it's not until paragraph 52 (out of 53 in this 3,633-word epic) that we learn that a federal court recognized "the President's inherent Constitutional authority to conduct warrantless foreign intelligence surveillance" back in 2002.

In other words: The feeling of someone at the New York Times that the program might be un-Constitutional gets top billing. The fact that the federal courts have explicitly said otherwise barely merits a mention deep in the story's nether regions.

But there's more to perverting the pyramid than the mere misordering of facts. Just as important is the omission of important details, and the use of loaded terminology.

That's why the Times informs us that the federal ruling focused on "an unrelated matter" while leaving out its court name (In re Sealed Case), then fails to mention any of the other federal cases--United States v. ...

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Navy League of the United States, New York Council (New York, NY).(Gordon R....
Magazine article from: U.S. Department of Defense Speeches September 12, 2008 700+ words
...It's great to be in New York ... America's city! And...Although a visit to New York may only add 3 or 4 days if...much to the Navy League of the United States, and particularly the New York Council, for your great support...
UNITED STATES. New York. Manhattan. 1968. (PAR166776)
Picture from: Magnum Photos Bruno Barbey January 1, 1968 700+ words
...Bruno Barbey Magnum Photos 01-01-1968 UNITED STATES. New York. Manhattan. 1968. Keywords: travel ship...us nyc american geographical u s ny n y c united states. new york. united states. new york. manhattan. 1968. 1968 Magnum...
UNITED STATES, New York:people on the underground.(c) Ferdinando Scianna/Magnum...
Picture from: Magnum Photos Ferdinando Scianna January 1, 1985 700+ words
...Magnum Photos 01-01-1985 UNITED STATES, New York:people on the underground...unis. new york city. united states, new york:people on the underground...scianna/magnum photos united states, new york:people on the underground...
United States. New York State. East Hampton. 1981. (PAR50928)
Picture from: Magnum Photos Elliott Erwitt January 1, 1981 700+ words
...Photos 01-01-1981 United States. New York State. East Hampton...america north america united states of america new york state usa continent us...mineral miscellaneous. united states. new york state. east hampton...
United States. New York. East Hampton. Sasha and Amy on the beach. (PAR84043)
Picture from: Magnum Photos Elliott Erwitt January 1, 1984 700+ words
...Photos 01-01-1984 United States. New York. East Hampton. Sasha...america north america united states of america new york state usa continent us...people miscellaneous. united states. new york. east hampton. sasha...
United States. New York City. (PAR42261)
Picture from: Magnum Photos Elliott Erwitt January 1, 1953 700+ words
...Photos 01-01-1953 United States. New York City. Keywords: vehicle...america north america united states of america new york state new york city usa...continent miscellaneous. united states. new york city. 1953 Magnum Photos
United States. New York State. East Hampton. (PAR50928)
Picture from: Magnum Photos Elliott Erwitt January 1, 1981 700+ words
...Magnum Photos 01-01-1981 United States. New York State. East Hampton. Keywords...Dominant Photographic effect United States of America Water (Lake...geography Geology Close-up United States. New York State. East Hampton. Miscellaneous...
IncrediMail Ltd. Opens First Office in the United States; New York Location...
Press release article from: Business Wire June 19, 2006 700+ words
...the opening of a New York office for its newly...direct access to the United States media and investment...strategy in the United States." "The opening of our New York office is a significant...deals throughout the United States." About IncrediMail...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA