AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

CONSUMPTION.(The Talk of the Town)(medical care)

The New Yorker

| April 17, 2006 | Hertzberg, Hendrik | COPYRIGHT 2006 All rights reserved. Reproduced by permission of The Condé Nast Publications Inc. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

Perhaps you have been wondering who or what is to blame for the high cost of medical care in this land of ours--and, more broadly, for the ungainly, unjust mess that is the American health-care system. If so, wonder no more. Your government has fingered the culprit: it's "the vast majority of Americans."

The perp having been collared, the trial held, and the verdict rendered, only the sentencing phase remains. Providentially, our leaders have come up with a punishment that fits the crime. We, the guilty, are to be condemned--or invited, but in any case for the rest of our natural lives, without possibility of parole--to turn over our bodily well-being to "consumer-directed Health Savings Accounts" in conjunction with "high-deductible health policies."

This judgment was handed down last Monday, in the form of an article on the Op-Ed page of the Times. The piece was no Dowdy jestfest or Friedmanesque memo-to-the-mullahs, and not only because of the dreariness of its style and the banality of its content. Its author, Allan B. Hubbard, identified as "assistant to the president for economic policy and director of the National Economic Council," has lately emerged as the White House point man on health policy, and, in subsequent days, his Op-Ed proved to have been the overture to a veritable symphony of spin conducted by President Bush himself, including an Air Force One ride to Bridgeport, Connecticut, for a stagy "Panel on Health Savings Accounts."

Hubbard's article, headlined "The Health of a Nation," begins with a frank-sounding acknowledgment that "in the past five years"--that is, since the present Administration took office--"private health insurance premiums have risen 73 percent," with the result that "some businesses" have dropped coverage altogether. "What is driving this unsustainable run-up in health insurance costs," Hubbard asks, "and how can we make things better?" Then comes what bloggers call the money quote:

Health care is expensive because the vast majority of Americans consume it as if it were free. Health insurance policies with low deductibles insulate people from the cost of the medical care they use--so much so that they often do not even ask for prices.

Can this really be the Administration's view of the health-care crisis? That its root cause is that Americans are (a) malingerers and (b) freeloaders who perversely refuse to go comparison shopping when illness strikes? That we're overinsured? Hard as it is to believe that this is what they say, it's even harder to believe that this is what they believe.

Health care is indeed expensive, but not because people are too quick to call the doctor when they experience a scary symptom or merely an annoying one, and not because some of them may bridle at entrusting their health to the lowest bidder. Throughout the Western world, health care is expensive, first of all, because it is expensive, and is bound to get more so as populations age and medical technology advances. Indeed, it should get more expensive, both in absolute terms and as a proportion of national income, because what it aims to provide--healing, the relief of suffering, the staving off of death--is of such inestimable value.

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Defense Health Care: Health Insurance Stipend Program Expected to Cost More...
General Accounting Office Reports & Testimony January 1, 2006 700+ words
...their private health insurance reported problems...difficulty finding a health care provider, establishing...current private health insurance coverage for their...implementation of a health care stipend program...their private health insurance would help ...
A dose of the HIPCs: health care. (health insurance purchasing...
Magazine article from: The Economist (US) February 27, 1993 700+ words
...is state-run health insurance purchasing co...up last year by health-care reformers known...employers offer health insurance rather than on...between a person's health-care and his current...California's health care, which Mr Zelman...competitive national ...
Mandates won't fix health-care crisis.(HEALTH INSURANCE)
Magazine article from: New Hampshire Business Review Roche, Jim April 27, 2007 700+ words
...cost of a health insurance policy...Hampshire has 38 health-care mandates...that make health insurance unaffordable. Our health-care system still...and more health insurance mandates...solve the health-care cost crisis...
Too sick to wait: health care. (health insurance reform in Florida) (American...
Magazine article from: The Economist (US) January 16, 1993 700+ words
...state employee health-insurance programme quadrupled...Florida has a health-care burden heavier...programme to provide health insurance for the poor...schools. Total health-care costs in the state...with insurers and health-care providers for...that the ...
Talking the talk: before you contact an insurance broker, you need to speak the...
Magazine article from: Detroiter Lamphier, Roy November 1, 2001 700+ words
Shopping for health insurance can be a daunting experience...three basic types of health insurance: Indemnity or Fee...restricted choice of health-care providers and the need to coordinate most health-care visits through your...
Making health care more affordable through health insurance finance reform:...
Magazine article from: Business Economics Baicker, Katherine July 1, 2007 700+ words
...The Tax Treatment of Health Insurance Is Inefficient and...getting more for our health care spending? A major...upward pressure on health care costs system-wide, making health care and health insurance increasingly unaffordable...
Lack of health insurance plagues Montanans.(Health Care)
Magazine article from: Montana Business Quarterly Seninger, Stephen F. Herling, Daphne March 22, 2004 700+ words
...higher cost of health care and health insurance to employers and...Affordability Gap Health care costs and health insurance premium increases...major obstacles to health insurance coverage. These higher health care costs put employers...
HIPAA changes to aid cost savings and privacy: Health industry complies to...
Magazine article from: San Diego Business Journal Reed, Michael A. April 8, 2002 700+ words
Health care providers often complain...quality, cost-effective health care is hampered by well...simplification provisions of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability...efficient processing of health care claims by encouraging...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA