AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Faking Literature.(Book Review)

Australian Literary Studies

| October 01, 2002 | Dawson, Carrie | COPYRIGHT 2002 Australian Literary Studies. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

by K.K. Ruthven. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001. Paperback, $49.95

`Pleasure in the spurious helps perpetuate it' (89), writes K.K. Ruthven, author of Faking Literature. And he is right. Indeed, the argument that Ruthven makes about literary hoaxes applies to his own book: in the process of demonstrating that literary forgery is a `critique of the twin institutions of literature and literary criticism' (195), Ruthven offers some very engaging accounts of literary hoaxes, plagiarism, imposture, and forgery. The problem is that by yoking together perpetrators of so many kinds of authorial misrepresentation under the rubric of literary forgery, Ruthven undermines his central argument that literary forgeries constitute an important mode of cultural critique. By way of example, readers familiar with Ern Malley and Helen Demidenko will know that one name signals a hoax designed to `destabilise the fragile economy of literary accreditation' (4), but the other recalls a very different kind of authorial misnaming, one which inadvertently revealed something about the reception of ethnic writing in Australia in the mid 1990s. Put differently, the news that Helen Demidenko, the author of an ostensibly semi-autobiographical account of the Ukrainian collaboration with Nazis during World War Il, was really Helen Darville, an Australian of British descent, provided scores of journalists, scholars, and media pundits with the opportunity to mount `a powerful indictment of such cultural practices as literary reviewing and the awarding of literary prizes' (4), but Darville/Demidenko should not be credited with engineering this critique. And by contending that `literary forgery is criticism by other means' (171) Ruthven disregards the important cultural work that is being done by scholars--like him!--who produce the criticism he indiscriminately attributes to literary forgeries.

Ruthven argues that the scholarly `scapegoating of fake literature' has, in the twentieth century, become a means of `shoring up the correspondingly real thing while also displaying one's own probity by occupying the moral high-ground' (45). He locates the seeds of this `scapegoating' in a `Romantic ideology of literary authorship which conceives of the text as an autonomous object produced by an individual genius' (41). The argument turns out to be convincing, but it is not made in any detail until later chapters, and the many intervening references to `a Romantic conception of authorship' are frustratingly vague. Chapter three argues against a perceived tendency to treat literature and literary forgery as logically dichotomous. Here Ruthven neatly summarizes the ways in which poststructuralist critical theory has challenged the notions of authorship and literary originality that were explored in the previous chapter, but his central contention that `the received wisdom of literary ...

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
CEO: Psychiatric medications not prescribed properly.(Les Ruthven)(Brief...
Magazine article from: Wichita Business Journal (KS) KRATZER, DAVE November 24, 2000 700+ words
...additional health care costs, says Les Ruthven, Ph.D., president and CEO of the...serious clinical depression is incorrect, Ruthven says. He's quick to add there's no...person change their thinking," says Ruthven, who practiced clinical and neuropsychology...
Ruthven to Be Inducted Into Business Hall of Fame.
Newspaper article from: Ledger (Lakeland, Florida) February 17, 2005 700+ words
...17--LAKELAND, Fla. -- Joe P. Ruthven, owner of The Ruthvens, will be inducted...generations," according to the organizers. Ruthven, 77, has a long history of civic leadership...can be added to a stockpile of honors Ruthven has accumulated; he has also received...
In high water conditions, Ruthven trout sometimes stray and it is worth a cast...
News wire article from: Europe Intelligence Wire January 8, 2004 700+ words
...Chlachain, Loch a'Choire and Loch Ruthven. Loch Duntelchaig is the largest loch...Inverness (tel 01463 233178). Loch Ruthven is my favourite, not only because of...the diversity of the loch's wildlife. Ruthven, margined by sedges and birch woods...
Realtor group wants Ruthven to continue as president.
Newspaper article from: Ledger (Lakeland, Florida) January 6, 2007 700+ words
...Maready Jan. 6--LAKELAND -- Matt Ruthven will continue as president of the...Association of Realtors in 2007. Ruthven's term as 2006 president had ended...board voted unanimously Friday for Ruthven to stay. The board meeting was expected...
Ruthven, Malise With Azim Nanji. Historical Atlas of Islam.(Brief Article)(Book...
Magazine article from: Library Journal Werner, Edward K. June 1, 2004 700+ words
RUTHVEN, MALISE WITH AZIM NANJI. Historical Atlas of Islam. Harvard Univ. 2004...time when our understanding of Islam and Muslim culture is so critical, Ruthven (Islam in the World) and Nanji, director of London's Institute of Ismaili...
The world of telematics: an interview with Jim Ruthven.(Interview)
Magazine article from: WebSphere Journal September 1, 2004 700+ words
WebSphere Journal: I'm talking now to Jim Ruthven, program director for IBM Telematic Solutions. Jim, what do you do? Jim Ruthven: I'm responsible for the sales and development activities for IBM Telematics in the North American region...
Thomas Ruthven. (People On the Move)
Magazine article from: Business First of Buffalo April 9, 1990 700+ words
Thomas Ruthven has been named chairman of the board of Power Funding Group, Inc., a mortgage banker. He supervises market development and corporate administration and was vice president for Northeast Goldome Realty Credit Corp.
Toronto, Ontario-based Cangro Foods Inc. sold its Primo brand for pasta and...
Magazine article from: The Food Institute Report August 28, 2006 700+ words
...Ontario-based CANGRO FOODS INC. sold its Primo brand for pasta and tomato products, including associated pasta assets, to Ruthven, Ontario-based SUN-BRITE CANNING LIMITED, a marketer of Mediterranean-type foods and a wide range of canned tomato...
Bringing Eden to earth: Sandy and Caz Hore-Ruthven visit a tourist trap with a...
Magazine article from: For A Change Hore-Ruthven, Sandy Hore-Ruthven, Caz August 1, 2003 700+ words
The Eden Project in Cornwall, England, was named after the ancient biblical paradise, lost through original sin. Today, many would say we are in danger of losing our present Eden, the natural world. The philosophy of the Eden Project evolved over four years. Its first aim was simply to showcase
Food for the soul: James Hore-Ruthven discovers that `Celebrating life' by...
Magazine article from: For A Change Hore-Ruthven, James August 1, 2002 700+ words
As one who tries to take time each day in quiet reflection, I know of few better ways of starting than by reading a chapter of Celebrating life--finding happiness in unexpected places by Jonathan Sacks, the Chief Rabbi of Great Britain and the Commonwealth. Celebrating life consists of 58 chapters,
For more facts and information, see all results

Source: HighBeam Research, Faking Literature.(Book Review)

©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA