AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Stellar and planetary aberration.

Apeiron

| June 01, 1994 | Phipps, Thomas E., Jr. | COPYRIGHT 2003 C. Roy Keys Inc. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

A way of looking at the topics of stellar and planetary aberration is suggested that enables them to be viewed as closely related--both being conceived as dependent on source-detector relative velocity. We show that the long-range limiting case, stellar aberration, has certain uniquely subtle aspects, as well as some hypothesized characteristics that lend themselves to empirical testing.

Introduction

For some time the writer has been seeking improved understanding of the several kinds of aberration--these being rather superficially explained in most texts, particularly texts of relativity theory. Indeed, in some of the more highly regarded of these (e.g., Moller 1972) the phenomenon of stellar aberration is so slightingly treated that use of the formulas provided would literally yield wrong answers. During much of this investigation it seemed that the fault lay with special relativity theory or with the Lorentz transformation. This may still, or may not, be the case. The reader will have to judge. Interest particularly in stellar aberration has increased of late [cf., Ives 1950, Eisner 1967, Phipps 1989, Hayden 1993, etc.] With help from recent studies by Marmet (1994) and Sherwin (1993) it has become apparent to the writer that with suitable interpretation relativity theory can accommodate both principal types of optical aberration, planetary and stellar. The purpose of the present paper is to confirm this assertion, to exhibit stellar aberration as (in a sense) a limiting case of planetary aberration, to seek a physical model of the phenomenon, to describe observations that could be made to test the model, and to touch on residual aberration issues that remain unsettled in the context of relativity theory.

1. Aberration via Lorentz Transformation

First, let us deal with the mathematics--which is the easy part--so that we can get on to the real problem, which (as so often happens in physics) is interpretation. According to the special theory of relativity (Einstein 1905) both the Doppler effect and stellar aberration can be treated by a Lorentz transformation of the four-vector of light propagation,

[MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSION NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ASCII]

Inertial system K' moves with velocity v relatively to system K along the direction of their common x-axes. We consider both K and K' to be for the moment arbitrary inertial systems. Propagation vectors (wave-normal or ray-path vectors) describing the same given light beam are k' and k in K' and K, respectively. Applying a Lorentz transformation, we have

[MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSION NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ASCII]

From this it is verifiable that a directional turning of the k-vector, k'/k' [not equal to] k/k, is an unavoidable consequence of the Lorentz transformation, except in the special case of parallelism of the v- and k-vectors.

To specialize for simplicity to a specific model, let the x-direction (parallel to earth's orbital motion), in our "laboratory" (observatory) system K, lie in the horizontal plane of the ecliptic; let the z-axis lie in the vertical, defining the zenith direction; and (to eliminate diurnal effects) consider our telescope to be located at the north pole of a nonrotating earth, so that the pole of the ecliptic lies at the zenith. To treat stellar aberration, consider a star emitting light described by the k-vector to lie in the x-z plane at angle [alpha] measured from the horizontal. Then [k.sub.x] = kcos[alpha] = [??][omega]/c[??]cos[alpha]. In K' the corresponding angle [alpha]' obeys [k.sub.x] = [??][omega]'/c[??]cos[alpha]'. With these substitutions it follows from the first of the above Lorentz transformation equations that [??][omega]/[omega]'[??]cos[alpha]' = [gamma][??]cos[alpha] + [v/c][??] and from the last of them that [omega]'/[omega] = [gamma][??]1 + [v/c]cos[alpha][??]. On taking the quotient of these equations we obtain the well-known relation (Synge 1965)

(1a) cos[alpha]' = [cos[alpha] + [v/c]]/1 + [v/c]cos[alpha],

or its dual (symmetric with respect to interchange of K, K', with sign change of relative velocity),

(1b) cos[alpha] = cos[alpha]' - [v/c]]/1 - [v/c]cos[alpha]'.

Subtracting cos[alpha] from both sides of (1a), using a standard trigonometric identity (Peirce 1957), and introducing an aberration angle [epsilon] = [alpha] - [alpha], we obtain

(2) [MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSION NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ASCII]

where [beta] = v/c. Observing that [epsilon] = O([beta]), we can expand the left-hand side of (2) as a power series in [epsilon],

[MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSION NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ASCII]

Substituting [epsilon] = a[beta] + b[[beta].sup.2] + c[[beta].sup.3] + O([[beta].sup.4]), where a,b,c are unknown coefficients, and equating the resulting [beta] - power series to the series expansion of the right-hand side of (2) in powers of [beta],

[MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSION NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ASCII]

we obtain, upon equating coefficients of successive powers of [beta], a…

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
On the application of the Lorentz transformation in O(3) electrodynamics.
Magazine article from: Apeiron Evans, Myron January 1, 2000 700+ words
...application and interpretation of the Lorentz transformation in O(3) electrodynamics. This...equations of motion in free space under Lorentz transformation, and on the correct interpretation...electrodynamics remain valid under Lorentz transformation. 2. The B Cyclic Theorem The...
Refutation of a refutation of the Lorentz transformation. (@ Issue:...
Magazine article from: Apeiron Good, I.J. Szego, Laszlo Ofner, Peter F. October 1, 1997 700+ words
Consider the Lorentz transformation in its familiar form in...course would refute the Lorentz transformation if their argument were...neat confirmation of the Lorentz transformation and also to make the argument...
Further debate about the Lorentz transformation. (@ Issue: correspondence,...
Magazine article from: Apeiron Good, I.J. January 1, 1998 700+ words
...and Good (1997a). They believe that the special Lorentz transformation (LT) is "riddled with [logical] dents" whereas...not with empirical evidence. 2. The (special) Lorentz transformation is de-fined by the identities (1a) x' = [gamma...
The Global Positioning System and the Lorentz transformation.(Report)
Magazine article from: Apeiron Buenker, Robert J. July 1, 2008 700+ words
...relativistic velocity transformation, alternative Lorentz transformation, isotropic length expansion I. Introduction The Global...simultaneous for an observer on the satellite. We can use the Lorentz transformation (LT) of STR to predict what the situation is from...
Attempts by Xu(s) to refute the self-consistency of the Lorentz transformation....
Magazine article from: Apeiron Good, I.J. January 1, 1999 700+ words
Introduction Readers of Apeiron know that Xu(s) believe(s) the usual "Lorentz transformation," LT, to be self-contradictory whereas I am confident that their arguments are fallacious. See the items mentioning Apeiron...
Simultaneity and the constancy of the speed of light: normalization of...
Magazine article from: Apeiron Buenker, Robert J. January 1, 2009 700+ words
...field of the observer. II. Derivation of the Galilean Transformation The main motivation for introducing the Lorentz transformation (LT) was the failure of the Galilean transformation (GT) to explain the fact that the speed of light is...
Testing relativity theory for one-way light propagation.
Magazine article from: Apeiron Phipps, Thomas E., Jr. January 1, 2005 700+ words
...in S, and is [alpha]', as measured...application of the Lorentz transformation between S and S...alpha] = [alpha]] - [alpha] is the radian...direction due to the Lorentz transformation. If v is interpreted...
Addition of velocities and electromagnetic interaction: geometrical derivations...
Magazine article from: Apeiron Galeriu, Calin January 1, 2003 700+ words
...which initially introduce the Lorentz transformation, the time dilatation and...OE = V/ic = tan(-i[alpha]) [??] tan(i[alpha]) = iV/c, (2) DC...theta] as functions of i[alpha]; i[beta], and i[gamma...
Epistemology and special relativity.
Magazine article from: Apeiron Kuligin, V.A. Kuligina, G.A. Korneva, M.V. October 1, 1994 700+ words
...new interpretation of the Lorentz transformation shows that real velocities...change the angle of viewing [alpha], then we see another visible...FIGURE 1 OMITTED] The angle [alpha] is the condition. If [alpha] is fixed, we see a single...
Relativistic Doppler effect and the principle of relativity.
Magazine article from: Apeiron Engelhardt, W. October 1, 2003 700+ words
...these postulates he deduced the Lorentz transformation, which led to the consequence...formulae, which are derived from the Lorentz transformation in textbooks, do not have this...effect are derived without using the Lorentz transformation (Section II). This can be done...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2010 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved. About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA

The AccessMyLibrary advertising network includes: womensforum.com GlamFamily