AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Sex-based occupational segregation in U.S. state bureaucracies, 1987-97.(Statistical Data Included)

Public Administration Review

| July 01, 2002 | Kerr, Brinck; Miller, Will; Reid, Margaret | COPYRIGHT 2002 American Society for Public Administration. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

Introduction

The literature on the distribution of women and men in public-sector jobs and the integration of women into government managerial ranks is replete with evidence that women often face glass walls, especially in certain types of agencies (Lewis and Emmert 1986; Pfeifer and Davis-Blake 1987; Kellough 1989, 1990; Guy and Duerst-Lahti 1992; Bullard and Wright 1993; Cornwell and Kellough 1994; Guy 1994; Lewis and Nice 1994; Naif 1994; Newman 1994; Riccucci and Saidel 1997). The glass wall metaphor refers to occupational segregation attributed to barriers that restrict women's access to certain types of jobs (or agencies) or to factors that concentrate women within certain types of jobs (or agencies). Glass walls are likely to persist when (1) the agency and its clientele do not engage in efforts to remove impediments to change; and/or (2) skills necessary to perform jobs in a given agency are not highly valued outside the agency.

Large-scale studies of sex-based occupational segregation have been conducted on U.S. federal government (Rosenbloom 1977; Lewis and Emmert 1986; Kellough 1989, 1990) and municipal government workforces (Miller, Kerr, and Reid 1999), but the lack of access to comparative public employment data on states has resulted in a dearth of generalizable empirical studies on employment in state-level bureaucracies. Numerous studies employ summary data from the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission's (EEOC) Job Patterns for Minorities and Women In State and Local Government (Cayer and Sigelman 1980; Moore and Mazey 1986; Sigelman and Dometrius 1986; Lewis and Nice 1994; Dometrius and Sigelman 1997). (1) Many other studies are based on samples drawn from one state or just a few states (Bayes 1989; Rehfuss 1986; Hale, Kelly, and Burgess 1989; Kelly et al. 1991; Duerst-Lahti and Johnson 1992; Guy 1992; Newman 1994). The data employed by Bullard and Wright (1993) and Riccucci and Saidel (1997) are limited to agency heads from across the 50 states and gubernatorial appointees from nearly all 50 states, respectively. Previous research on the distribution of state jobs provides some useful conceptual and analytic frameworks, but findings from these studies provide little basis for generalizing about the employment patterns of career administrative and professional personnel.

In this article, we examine the distribution of women and men in state-level administrative and professional positions by agency type and over time in each of the 50 states to determine whether agency missions are associated with the extent and nature of glass walls. We are interested in the following questions: (1) what is the distribution of female and male administrators and professionals in various functional areas in state governments (police, corrections, natural resources/parks, highways, public welfare, etc.); and (2) is the underrepresentation and/or overrepresentation of female or male administrators and professionals in various functional areas related to the agency missions in those functional areas?

These questions are important for several reasons. Greater access to quality jobs, including public-sector managerial positions, promotes the economic, social, and political progress of women, and it may result in longterm benefits through altered socialization processes (Kanter 1977; MacManus 1981; Tolleson-Rinehart 1991; Guy and Duerst-Lahti 1992). Greater representation for women among managerial personnel is also likely to result in changes in management styles and leadership processes, perhaps making them more innovative and democratic (Tolleson-Rinehart 1991; Duerst-Lahti and Johnson 1992; Stivers 1993). The increased presence of women is also likely to have a distinctive impact on policy outputs (Mezey 1978; Stewart 1980; Stanwick and Kleeman 1983; Welch 1985; Gelb and Palley 1996; Carroll, Dodson, and Mandel 1991; Dodson and Carroll 1991; Tolleson-Rinehart 1991; Thomas 1994; but see Donahue 1997; Ford and Dolan 1999).

The focus on women in state bureaucracies is important because state governments function as distinct entities with their own constitutions, laws, and independently raised revenues (Kelly et al. 1991). Osborne (1988) and Van Horn (1989) argue that state governments have become more responsive, innovative, and effective; however, these efforts are by no means distributed uniformly across all states (Brudney, Hebert, and Wright 1999). Nonetheless, over the last three decades there has been a marked increase in state agency activism (Wright, Yoo, and Cohen 1991; Bullard and Wright 1993). Bullard and Wright (1993) argue that administrative activism in the states converged with women's activism to create expanded opportunities for women at the state level, often in the form of newly created agencies and programs. They also argue that, all else being equal, new agencies and programs are less likely than existing agencies and programs to be subject to constraints invidious to women (Bullard and Wright 1993). Such expanded opportunities provide reason to think that, in general, employment patterns should indicate evidence of growth in women's share of managerial positions in state government.

Theory and Hypotheses

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Barry Wright Corp. adds details to restructuring. (includes text of letter)
Press release article from: PR Newswire October 13, 1988 700+ words
BARRY WRIGHT CORP. ADDS DETAILS TO RESTRUCTURING NEWTON...Mass., Oct. 13 /PRNewswire/ -- Barry Wright Corporation (NYSE: BAR) announced today...contemplated by Phase Two is the sale of Wright Line Inc. to Wright Acquisition Corporation...
Wright Medical Technology, Inc. completes tender offer for Orthomet, Inc.
Press release article from: Business Wire December 8, 1994 700+ words
...BUSINESS WIRE)--Dec. 8, 1994--Wright Acquisition, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Wright Medical Technology, Inc. announced today...New York City time on Dec. 7, 1994. Wright Medical Technology further announced that...
Wright buys Darco's foot and ankle division.
Newspaper article from: Commercial Appeal (Memphis, TN) March 6, 2007 700+ words
...Arlington-based medical device maker Wright Medical Group Inc. announced its return...Darco International Inc. The purchase was Wright Medical's first since 2003 and reflects...Davis was involved in the Darco deal, Wright executive vice president and chief financial...
Richard Wright: A Collection of Critical Essays.
Magazine article from: African American Review Smith, Virginia Whatley March 22, 1997 700+ words
...seminal essay labeling Richard Wright as a misogynist and anti...Margolies, who had condemned Wright for his unfavorable portrayal of black women). Rampersad wisely starts the collection with critiques of Wright's most famous novel, Native...
Wright's Counsel in Probe Also Represents Witnesses; 2 Clients' Ties to Speaker...
Newspaper article from: The Washington Post Tom Kenworthy November 16, 1988 700+ words
...attorney representing House Speaker Jim Wright (D-Tex.) in the House ethics committee's investigation of Wright, also serves as counsel to key witnesses...two longtime Fort Worth associates of Wright whose financial relationships to the...
Wright Medical Group, Inc. Announces Key Developments in Bio-Orthopaedic...
Press release article from: Business Wire May 28, 2003 700+ words
...BUSINESS WIRE)--May 28, 2003 Wright Launches Next Generation MIIG(TM) X3...Peer-Reviewed Clinical Data Supporting Wright's Bone Regeneration Materials Recently Published Wright Medical Group, Inc. (NASDAQ: WMGI...
Wright Reproductions
Newspaper article from: The Washington Post JURA KONCIUS August 11, 1988 700+ words
At long last, the Wright stuff is available by catalogue. The Frank Lloyd Wright Decorative Designs Collection is a handsome 30...The offerings are authorized reproductions of Wright's original pieces, from oak dining room chairs...
The Wright timing: Pamela Wright says now is the time to expand, but...
Magazine article from: Travel Agent Michels, Jennifer January 20, 2003 700+ words
...about the future of their businesses, but Pamela Wright, owner and president of Wright Travel in Nashville, is smiling all the way to...it's currently negotiating with three more. Wright says her goal is to continue to grow, and there...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA