AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Latin America's civil wars: conflict resolution and institutional change.

MACLAS Latin American Essays

| April 01, 2000 | Hartzell, Caroline A. | COPYRIGHT 2000 Middle Atlantic Council of Latin American Studies. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

War is the formative experience for most important nations and many governing institutions. After doing their worst, humans frequently find in the ashes they have produced reasons to think differently about themselves and their neighbors. (1)

Latin America has been the site of fourteen civil wars during the post-World War II era, thirteen of which now have ended. Although not as civil war-prone as some other areas of the world, Latin America has endured some extremely violent and destabilizing intrastate conflicts. (2) The region's experiences with civil wars and their resolution thus may prove instructive for other parts of the world in which such conflicts continue to rage. By examining Latin America's civil wars in some depth not only might we better understand the circumstances under which such conflicts are ended but also the institutional outcomes to which they give rise. More specifically, this paper focuses on the following central questions regarding Latin America's civil wars: Has the resolution of these conflicts produced significant institutional change in the countries in which they were fought? What is the nature of the institutional change that has taken place in the wake of these civil wars? What are the factors that are responsible for shaping post-war institutional change?

The end of civil wars provides a laboratory of sorts for exploring theoretically interesting questions about institutional choice. After all, once an armed conflict is over, former combatants need to (re-)construct rules to replace the ones whose collapse led to the outbreak of the civil war. In this study of institutional change following Latin America's civil wars I focus on four institutions: (1) rules regarding political inclusion, (2) the extension of security guarantees to antagonists, (3) power-sharing, and (4) rules regarding distributive policy. Clearly, this is not an exhaustive list of types of institutional change. For example, in recent years increasing emphasis has been given to crafting rules that hold accountable those who commit human rights abuses during the course of civil wars. (3) However, I have chosen to focus on these four institutions for two reasons. First, it seems reasonable to suppose that those actors in a position to create rules following a civil war will seek to secure coordination on the issues seen as responsible for the outbreak of the conflict. In that sense, these institutions can be considered ones directly aimed at the management of conflict. In regions like Latin America characterized by instability, weak rule of law and the sense of uncertainty that stems from this, poverty, and inequity, those issues likely will be ones centering on security, participation, and control of resources. Second, the ability of actors to craft institutions of conflict management is important because these are likely to have an impact on post-war stability and thus on the functioning of other institutions actors may design. Generally speaking, it has been found that those conflict management institutions that seek to include former antagonists or accommodate their central concerns are most likely to produce post-war stability. (4)

In this paper I focus on a number of structural and strategic actor variables in an effort to explain post-civil war institutional change in Latin America. I find that the majority of civil wars in Latin America have been followed by significant institutional change, that this change generally has been of an inclusive or accommodative nature, and that one structural variable, the means by which a conflict is settled, is the one most significantly associated with post-conflict institutional change.

Conflict Resolution and Institutional Change

Are civil wars sources of significant institutional change? And are the institutional changes that follow civil wars likely to produce more positive relations among a people formerly at war as the quote at the beginning of this paper implies? In an effort to answer these questions, I draw on the research and insights of two different literatures -- conflict resolution and the new institutionalism. Although there has been some cross-fertilization between these fields, it is surprising that scholars at work in each of these areas have not made more of a conscious effort to draw upon the research produced by others. (5) After all, conflict can only be resolved if institutions exist to process or manage conflict. It is the breakdown of these institutions or the violent efforts of some actors to reconfigure them that lead to the outbreak of civil war. And, if the actors who resort to the use of violence succeed in transforming institutions, one of the things they will seek to do with these institutions is to construct new rules for the management of conflict. Looked at this way, it seems clear that each of these fields should have something to say to the other about the relationship among institutions, violent conflicts, and the causes and consequences of institutional change.

Work in the area of conflict studies has emphasized the role that violence, including the security concerns of combatants, can play in shaping institutions. (6) And, although formerly focused primarily on questions of institutional stability, the institutional choice literature lately has sought to clarify how the preferences and power of social actors or "political entrepreneurs" may prompt institutional change. (7) Integrating insights from these two fields should enable scholars better to address the agency-structure problem that has been at the heart of questions of institutional change. By focusing on the actions of purposive actors, the new institutionalism serves to emphasize that institutions are the products of social decisions. The research agenda of scholars working in this tradition has been dominated by a focus on the strategic interactions of actors, most often defined as political and economic elites, and the reasons they seek to define the rules of the game as they do. These actors, we are told, construct those institutions that are most likely to advance their own interests, whether this be defined as furthering their political careers or securing a distributional advantage. (8) In this view, the preexisting institutional context and the distribution of power among actors determine the feasible alternatives among which institutional architects make their choices. (9) Institutional change, in this context, occurs incrementally, and is said to be path-dependent, as the actors who have structured institutions will actively resist large-scale change. (10)

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
The politics of labour reform in Latin America: Between flexibility and...
Magazine article from: International Labour Review Bensusan, Graciela March 22, 2008 700+ words
...labour reform in Latin America: Between flexibility...the agenda of institutional change in Latin America. The aim is to...Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean...political and institutional change" (p. 2...
Political Institutions and Economic Growth in Latin America: Essays in Policy,...
Press release article from: Business Wire May 18, 2000 700+ words
...historical cases of institutional change and economic...economies of Latin America. Haber and...Taylor on Latin America and Foreign...publicly induced institutional change relating to...history of Latin America. Stephen...
Review article: institutional design, party systems and governability -...
Magazine article from: British Journal of Political Science Foweraker, Joe October 1, 1998 700+ words
...the countries of Latin America in similar ways...institutional tradition in Latin America is real, and important...institutionally regulated institutional change',(6) the presidential...at hand.(8) In Latin America, with the deck so...
How Latin America Fell Behind: Essays on the Economic Histories of Brazil and...
Magazine article from: Business History Review Lewis, Colin M. June 22, 1999 700+ words
...focus of research on Latin America. For too long the...historiography of Latin America has lacked a systematic...understand processes of institutional change. Rejecting dependista...institutions examines Latin America from the perspective...
IMF report details new agenda for Latin America.
News wire article from: Miami Herald (Miami, FL) February 8, 2005 700+ words
...economic reforms in Latin America, is shifting gears...Tuesday assessing Latin America's apparent paradox...agenda, embracing institutional change is critical for the...The IMF admits that Latin America's economic record...
Book Examines Political Economy of Institutional Change in Electricity Supply...
News wire article from: Europe Intelligence Wire March 12, 2004 700+ words
...powerful shapers of institutional change. At the same time...precedent exists. "Institutional change is seldom easy...those interested in Latin America will find this...Understanding Institutional Change Appendix 1: Major...
Introduction: innovation, growth and development in Latin-America: stylized...
Magazine article from: Innovation: Management, Policy, & Practice Dutrenit, Gabriela Katz, Jorge April 1, 2005 700+ words
...innovation carried out in Latin America and suggests lines...and development in Latin America. Finally, in Section...technological and institutional change, and national technological...Development: Lessons from Latin America' (ISBN 0-9750436...
IMF report details new agenda for Latin America.(Knight Ridder Newspapers)
News wire article from: Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service Bachelet, Pablo February 9, 2005 700+ words
...economic reforms in Latin America, is shifting gears...Tuesday assessing Latin America's apparent paradox...agenda, embracing institutional change is critical for the...The IMF admits that Latin America's economic record...
Rank and Privilege: The Military and Society in Latin America.
Magazine article from: Canadian Journal of History Anna, Timothy E. April 1, 1995 700+ words
...Jaguar Books on Latin America." Designed for...of a new series on Latin America for university students...twentieth-century Latin America. Following a strong...Caudillismo and Institutional Change: Manuel Odria and...
Social Development in Latin America: The Politics of Reform. (Reviews).
Magazine article from: Journal of Latin American Studies Lewis, Colin M. February 1, 2002 700+ words
...Social Development in Latin America: The Politics of Reform...on social policy reform in Latin America. It starts from the premise...there are informed accounts of institutional change -- as well as of the challenges...
For more facts and information, see all results

Source: HighBeam Research, Latin America's civil wars: conflict resolution and institutional...

©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA