AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Counterpoint: A response to Bernard.(Jonathan Bernard)

Perspectives of New Music

| January 01, 2001 | Nuss, Steven | COPYRIGHT 2001 Perspectives of New Music. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

IN THE COURSE of developing elegant and provocative ways for hearing and thinking about minimal music, Jonathan Bernard proposes certain criteria for music-analytical relevance and cultural authority that, while he did not intend to talk about such things, nevertheless inform and inflect his work in ways that give me pause. In my "Yes I Wrote It ...", I referred to these criteria and some other incidental comments as "hotspots" and "fires." Though I have no doubt that identity politics cause Bernard as much discomfort as they do me, these fires flicker near this very combustible stuff. They threaten the integrity of the analytical foundations Bernard constructs and, if ignored, could bear down on my own work and that of others concerned with the musical ramifications and manifestations produced by the complicated dance between what we are generally referring to in this exchange as "the West" and "the non-West."

In his thoughtful and spirited response to my article, Bernard says he doesn't see the fires. And though he acknowledges that, in light of our exchange, he perhaps should have omitted or tempered some of his original comments or made an intended allusion more explicit, he nevertheless feels that I have invented these fires by distorting and unfairly recontextualizing both what he said and what he meant to say. Rather than attempting a point by point reassessment of how I understand what each of us said in our respective articles, I will leave it to the reader to decide to what extent, if any, Bernard's feelings are justified. In his response, however, he outlines his positions on a number of the issues I felt he touched on in "Theory, Analysis ... ," and about which I voiced concern in "Yes I Wrote It...." Thus, whether or not the reader senses, as I do, that there are indeed fires (albeit unintended ones) in Bernard's article, they blaze brightly in his response to mine. I would like to comment briefly on so me of them.

"The question of what happens when a creative musician in one culture encounters the music of another culture is really a very complicated one; I didn't address it in 'Theory, Analysis...' and I don't propose to do so now," says Bernard early in his response. But I fail to see how his subsequent remarks don't address this question head on in ways that need to be discussed. While Bernard lauds attempts to focus music analytical efforts on identifying cultural crossing points, he insists that (and this is not unique to Bernard)--in order to avoid analytical "wildgoose chases"--such efforts should be undertaken only if there is some "plausible" evidence that justifies their pursuit. For Bernard, this plausibility seems intimately tied to two interconnected constraints, and both feel "hot" to me. In order to avoid membership in Bernard's wild-goose chase category, consideration of possible music-cultural crossing points in a given work can (and should) be made if and only if its composer has: 1) spent a significa nt amount of time studying and (presumably) performing music of a culture not his or her own; and 2) studied and performed (for the same significant time) in the geographical location commonly identified as a/the home for that music and culture. With these constraints in place, Bernard feels justified in dismissing the possibility of meaningful/ interesting Ghanaian crossing points in Reich's music because, for Bernard, Reich's five-week stay in that country was not sufficiently long enough to have had any plausible impact on him, at least none that could be regarded as having the potential to manifest itself as anything more than trivial, superficial, "vague" influences. The possibility that, despite his time/location profile, Reich might have left Ghana with some degree of music-cultural authority that could later manifest itself compositionally in non-trivial ways is denied tout court. "Impossible," says Bernard.

While I certainly agree that achieving a deep understanding of all aspects of a musical genre in any musical culture is not possible in five weeks, is it fair to assume, as Bernard seems to, that Reich left with nothing significant? no potential crossing-points? nothing that might contribute to solving the "problem" of his minimal music? For an analyst considering cross-cultural music-analytical potential in Reich's music, is Reich's stay in Ghana really equal to no time? Just how much time would be enough? And exactly why does Ghanaian musical authority/analytical plausibility seem to depend so heavily on Reich's physical presence in Ghana? Are we to assume that Reich never again considered or studied Ghanaian music in another location, never continued to build on what he had begun? (It's possible, I suppose. But it seems unlikely.) Or are we to assume that even if he did study independently that such immersion would somehow not count? that the authority that Bernard demands can be conferred and earned only "over there" and consequently by "those people"? Bernard gives no answers to these questions other than alluding to a "court of true jurisdiction" that apparently adjudicates such matters (among other things). But I am not at all sure where this court exists. Who writes its judicial code? Who wields its gavel?

Despite the fact that Bernard acknowledges that cross-cultural encounters are a complicated business, the method suggested in his response for addressing those of Steve Reich and Phillip Glass seems remarkably simple: their ...

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Reich, Bernard. A Brief History of Israel.(Brief Article)(Young Adult...
Magazine article from: Booklist Cohen, George December 1, 2004 700+ words
Reich, Bernard. A Brief History of Israel. Dec. 2004...95 (0-8160-5793-1). 956.940 Reich's preface indicates that his purpose...1880 to 1948. In the remaining chapters, Reich chronicles the nation's development...
Daimler-Benz in the Third Reich.(Review)
Magazine article from: Business History Stokes, Ray January 1, 1999 700+ words
...business and industry in the Third Reich. His book complements those...labour relations in the Third Reich; the thesis of the primacy...an impressive complement to Bernard Bellon's earlier labour history...and industries in the Third Reich on which to draw for comparisons...
The Third Reich reflected: German civil administration in the occupied Soviet...
Magazine article from: The English Historical Review Steinberg, Jonathan June 1, 1995 700+ words
...nature of the Nazi system itself'.(1) Bernard Chiari, in a recent study of German civil...or living space for his greater German Reich. In a speech in 1928, he explained his...sharp relief central features of the Third Reich, in particular the administrative chaos...
U.S. to Start War on Iraq by End of March: Expert.
News wire article from: Asia Africa Intelligence Wire March 12, 2003 700+ words
...begins about April 1," said Prof. Bernard Reich of George Washington University in...sanction military action against Iraq, Reich said, "At the moment I don't...difficulty backing down from his, Reich said. Of the permanent Security...
What Abbas wants from US; Palestinian leader - and Bush - face new challenges...
Newspaper article from: The Christian Science Monitor May 24, 2005 700+ words
...and economic conditions," says Bernard Reich, an expert on the Israeli-Palestinian...Israel's withdrawal from Gaza, Mr. Reich says. "He wants to hear loud and...process from A to B," he says. But Reich says that the spotlight Bush will...
Modern history and politics.(The Diplomacy of the Middle East: The...
Magazine article from: The Middle East Journal Clarke, Duncan L. Kushner, David Lawrence, Bruce Ozdalga, Elisabeth March 22, 2002 700+ words
...satisfying chapter, however, is Bernard Reich's on Israeli foreign policy. As in some of his other writings, Reich tends to portray "small Israel...quest for peace ..." (p. 125). Reich gives the impression that he laments...
Conservative US right, close to Bush, becomes key ally of Israel.
News wire article from: Europe Intelligence Wire June 20, 2003 700+ words
...Christian community is growing," said Bernard Reich, author of three books about US...little else in common," stressed Reich. He also noted that most US Jews...genuine religious belief," said Reich. If so, Bush is not the first US...
New push for Mideast peace.(USA)
Newspaper article from: The Christian Science Monitor June 20, 2007 700+ words
...s use it to move forward," says Bernard Reich, a professor of international affairs...seizing opportunities," Mr. Reich cautions that this is not akin to...world was changed. The major hurdle Reich sees is that the hard bargaining...
Arabs condemn Israeli assault on Arafat's headquarters.(Knight Ridder...
Newspaper article from: Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service Moritsugu, Ken Landay, Jonathan S. March 29, 2002 700+ words
...lots of rhetoric," said professor Bernard Reich, a Middle East expert at The George...Israel's northern border. But Reich played down such a scenario, saying...they are about the Palestinians," Reich said. "U.S. aid, U.S. tourism...
Chance of Large-Scale Arab-Israeli Conflict Remains Remote, Experts Say.
News wire article from: Knight Ridder Washington Bureau (Washington, DC) March 30, 2002 700+ words
...lots of rhetoric," said professor Bernard Reich, a Middle East expert at The George...Israel's northern border. But Reich played down such a scenario, saying...they are about the Palestinians," Reich said. "U.S. aid, U.S. tourism...
For more facts and information, see all results

Source: HighBeam Research, Counterpoint: A response to Bernard.(Jonathan Bernard)

©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA