AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

The Human Stain.(Review)

Academic Questions

| December 22, 2000 | Hollander, Paul | COPYRIGHT 2000 Transaction Publishers, Inc. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

The Human Stain, by Philip Roth. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 2000, 361 pp., $26.00 hardbound.

Understandably enough Academic Questions does not, as a rule, review works of fiction. The Human Stain however is the kind of novel that has much to say to the readers of this journal. It exemplifies art imitating life, illustrating as it does the blight of political correctness (PC)--the key dramatic ingredient of the story. Philip Roth has an excellent grasp of what has been going on in our colleges over the past three decades, a knowledge acquired presumably in part during the years when he taught comparative literature at the University of Pennsylvania and literature at Hunter College in New York. He knows intimately the terminology, the cliches, the styles of solicitude, the verbiage of the prevailing politically correct conventional wisdom. The fictional "Athena College" can be readily substituted for many others personally known to the readers of this journal.

This novel is a powerful work of fiction, both in its imaginative and realistic aspects, that grasps certain defining characteristics of our times. In any work of fiction the artistic-imaginary as distinct from the sociological-social historical dimension requires separate consideration. The latter, in these pages, will be given more attention. But it should be made clear at the outset that this is a fine novel, quite apart from its focus on matters that weigh heavily on the minds of the readers of Academic Questions.

It is in itself significant that Philip Roth, veteran chronicler of the afflictions of contemporary American (and personal) life turned his attention to the two major components of PC--the preoccupation with racism and sexism--and found them a dramatic enough point of departure for a story that is by no means limited to these current concerns. (Another recent novel of his, American Pastoral, too dealt with political issues associated with the 1960s and could be read as a cautionary tale of the fruits of idealistic, if mindless, political violence.)

Future readers of another era may wonder how much of this novel is pure fiction, a product of the fertile imagination of its author or one that was inspired by actual events, rooted in social realities? Could it really happen in the 1990s that a professor of classics (Coleman Silk) in a small New England college would be harassed, hounded, and denigrated as a racist for referring to two students who never showed up in his class as "spooks," and who were, unbeknownst to him, black? Could this have led to the automatic, reflexive attribution of racism and the attendant demands for apologies, penalties and humiliations? This is how it began:

 
   He was astonished to be called by his successor, the new dean of faculty, 
   to address the charge of racism brought against him by the two missing 
   students, who turned out to be black, and who, though absent, quickly 
   learned of the locution in which he'd publicly raised the question of their 
   absence. Coleman told the dean: "These two students had not attended a 
   single class. That's all I knew about them. I was using the word in its 
   customary and primary meaning: `spook' as a specter or ghost. I had no idea 
   what color these students might be. I had known perhaps fifty years ago but 
   had totally forgotten that `spooks' is an invidious term sometimes applied 
   to blacks ... The issue, the only issue, is the non-attendance of these 
   students and their flagrant and inexcusable neglect of work. What's galling 
   is that the charge is not just false--it is spectacularly false (6-7). 

The dean and the rest of the college community were not convinced. (As we all know the non-attendance of students is hardly a matter to exercise administrators.)

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Rage is all the rage in America: With 'The Human Stain,' Philip Roth completes...
Newspaper article from: The Christian Science Monitor May 11, 2000 700+ words
The Human Stain By Philip Roth Houghton Mifflin 361 pp., $26 Shhhhh. Philip Roth has written another brilliant novel, but almost anything you read about "The Human Stain" will spoil the effect. Several reviewers have already blown it...
`The Human Stain,' by Philip Roth; Houghton Mifflin ( 361 pages, $26).
News wire article from: Detroit Free Press (Detroit, MI) May 12, 2000 700+ words
Byline: Helene Lorber ``The Human Stain," is full of secrets, but Philip Roth spills them early. By Page 50, we learn...you've forgotten the beginning. But "The Human Stain" is a fitting close to "American Pastoral...
`The Human Stain,' by Philip Roth; Houghton Mifflin.(Knight Ridder Newspapers)
News wire article from: Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service Lorber, Helene May 24, 2000 700+ words
``The Human Stain," is full of secrets, but Philip Roth spills them early. By Page 50, we learn not only the...the end you've forgotten the beginning. But "The Human Stain" is a fitting close to "American Pastoral" and "I...
Dark secrets.("The Human Stain" by Philip Roth)(Movie Review)
Magazine article from: The Christian Century Petrakis, John November 1, 2003 700+ words
THE TITLE OF Philip Roth's 2000 novel, The Human Stain, suggests something left behind unwillingly, something to regret, even something to be ashamed of. It alludes to the infamous...
'Stain' comes out in a wash; Film of 'The Human Stain' loses the voice of...
Newspaper article from: The Christian Science Monitor October 31, 2003 700+ words
...star as the illiterate cleaning woman of "The Human Stain," based on Philip Roth's novel, sounded like one of Hollywood's...including his affair with the cleaning woman. "The Human Stain" isn't one of Mr. Roth's finest books...
Rush Limbaugh's inner black child.(The Human Stain, movie adaptation of book by...
Magazine article from: The Nation Williams, Patricia J. October 27, 2003 700+ words
Philip Roth's novel The Human Stain attracted considerable attention...connect as individuals. Yet The Human Stain begins its run against a complicated...not malice. So how does The Human Stain, if it wants to be more than mere...
Secrecy and self-invention: Philip Roth's postmodern identity in The Human...
Magazine article from: International Fiction Review Neelakantan, G. January 1, 2007 700+ words
Philip Roth's The Human Stain (2000), a fitting final...multicultural America, The Human Stain focuses on the constitution...working through traumas of life. Philip Roth's The Human Stain is saturated with images and...
The faking of the Americans: passing, trauma, and national identity in Philip...
Magazine article from: Modern Language Quarterly Maslan, Mark September 1, 2005 700+ words
...Nathan Zuckerman's thoughts in Philip Roth's Human Stain when he discovers that his...birthright is bifurcation. The Human Stain thus breaks with its predecessors...condition of possibility. The Human Stain dramatizes the conflict between...
The stain and the sign. Poetics in Philip Roth's The human...
Magazine article from: Studia Anglica Posnaniensia: international review of English Studies Veisland, Jorgen January 1, 2008 700+ words
...ABSTRACT The paper shows how Philip Roth's text discards and negates...construct a poetics based on Philip Roth's novel The human stain, or rather, perhaps, explicate...abjection; and, of course, Philip Roth's own aesthetic reflection...
Nobody's fool: Hollywood legend Robert Benton brings Philip Roth's novel The...
Magazine article from: W Heyman, Marshall November 1, 2003 700+ words
...like this month's The Human Stain, is something of an...get to work." In The Human Stain, which was adapted by Nicholas Meyer from Philip Roth's 2000 novel, Anthony...Bonnie and Clyde, The Human Stain is about two people from...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA