AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

A Descent to Cultural Studies.(Brief Article)

Academic Questions

| September 22, 2000 | Tracy, James D. | COPYRIGHT 2000 Transaction Publishers, Inc. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

When we encourage young people to suffer the rigors of higher education, we do not think enough has been said if we merely point to the connection between a college degree and a better-paying job. A college education, we believe, is a chance to broaden one's mind, a precious opportunity one will not have again during the course of a working life. Yet, many of the fields of study by which students can indeed broaden their minds--in particular the humanities--have been in recent decades undermined from within, so that students are less likely to have their minds broadened than to have some of their adolescent prejudices confirmed. This subversion of one of the commonly agreed-on purposes of higher education ought to be a public issue, but it has not been, in part because the rationale for this intellectual revolution is couched in an arcane language that is difficult to grasp even for those of us familiar with academic discourse. This essay attempts to clarify what has been happening, first by describing the demise of what used to be called the Humanities Department at the University of Minnesota, then by showing how this local incident fits into the larger canvass of contemporary academic life.

1. From Humanities to Cultural Studies, Writ Small

During the 1950s, the University of Minnesota's College of Letters, Sciences, and the Arts created two academic units, Humanities and Social Sciences, for teaching undergraduate courses on broad topics not then dealt with by any of the departments. Both were called programs, not departments, meaning that those teaching only in these units could not achieve academic tenure. Hence, courses were taught either by graduate students working for their doctorates in specific fields, or by faculty whose tenure-home department was likely to be English, philosophy, or history. Social studies fell by the wayside during the 1960s, but the dean of what was now called the College of Liberal Arts sought to maintain the Humanities Program by negotiating with the key departments: in some cases there was money for a new position, on condition that the new appointee teach half-time in humanities for the first three years.

These were the terms on which I was hired as an assistant professor of history in 1966. In fact I liked the idea, since I had just come from a temporary appointment at the University of Michigan, where I taught Great Books courses. To be sure, the Humanities Program prided itself on being multidisciplinary, not limited to great works that happened also to be books: each course syllabus was to include some treatment of art or music as well. This regulation I probably honored more in the breach than in practice, but I enjoyed the Humanities courses and I think students did, too. Instead of lecturing most class periods, as in a history course, I conducted class discussions on the texts assigned for that quarter (Homer-Thucydides-Plato-Sophocles, Vergil-Livy-Augustine-Dante, Machiavelli-Erasmus-Luther-Cervantes, or Montesquieu-Pope-Voltaire-Rousseau). That I was an expert in only one of the chronological periods involved did not matter, since imparting expertise was not, I thought, the purpose of these courses. Rather, a Humanities course was to be a conversation between teacher and students about how to read intelligently works that subsequent generations had identified as great--each so different from our world in its basic assumptions, yet so uncannily similar in other ways. This stretching of the imagination beyond the limits of the present is an obvious and important way of broadening the mind.

During the 1970s I was a member of a supervisory committee that, in response to the wishes of Humanities faculty, oversaw the transformation of the program into a department, with its own tenure-track appointments. In retrospect, I think this was a mistake. Humanities had value as a forum where scholars from various disciplines could meet, less as experts than as readers of works whose richness tests the limits of all our expertise. But the self-understanding of the new department (notably on the part of its first chair, brought in from the University of Chicago) was that humanities itself was a kind of discipline-of-all-disciplines, foundational, in its multi-disciplinarity, to fields like English or art history. The pretentiousness of this rationale is obvious (most departments in a college of liberal arts can easily construct an argument as to why their field is foundational to all the others; such talk is seldom taken seriously by members of other departments). But there was another and more serious problem. Defining humanities as foundational opened the door to bright young scholars who, working from the perspective of "critical theory" or "cultural studies" (for both these terms, see below), claimed to have the real truth about the ugly social reality on which humanities in the traditional sense was founded.

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
BREVARD COMMUNITY COLLEGE STUDY ABROAD HUMANITIES PROGRAM RECRUITS STUDENTS
News wire article from: US Fed News Service, Including US State News September 28, 2009 700+ words
...Program is now accepting applications for the study abroad humanities program, which is offered July 14 - July 28 as part of the college...program fees, McCalla said. "The Study Abroad in the Humanities Program is about getting out of the classroom and into the world...
Ralph Ross; professor, former head of `U' humanities program.(NEWS)
Newspaper article from: Star Tribune (Minneapolis, MN) Haga, Chuck April 19, 2000 700+ words
...G. Ross, chairman of the University of Minnesota's humanities program in the 1950s and '60s and a champion of liberal arts...Claremont, Calif. At Minnesota, "he really made the humanities program into a remarkable thing," Siegelman said. Ross was...
MCMASTER UNIVERSITY: Unique McMaster humanities program competes for advanced...
Press release article from: M2 Presswire November 19, 1998 700+ words
M2 PRESSWIRE-19 November 1998-MCMASTER UNIVERSITY: Unique McMaster humanities program competes for advanced technology funding (C)1994-98 M2 COMMUNICATIONS LTD RDATE:181198 McMaster University's Faculty of...
Central's Humanities Program Reaching for Ideal
Newspaper article from: The Washington Post Leonard Hall March 24, 1988 700+ words
When Prince George's school administrator David Lemmond proposed two years ago that a Humanities and International Studies high school magnet program be established, he stressed the need for a broad liberal arts education that would include intensive instruction in history, literature, art, music,
Cultural studies and its impact on composition.(Panoramas and Vistas: New...
The Clearing House Leight, David September 1, 1995 700+ words
...last five years has been its movement into cultural studies. Although cultural studies has been around for four decades--first...discourses. In this article I will describe cultural studies, show the ways in which composition theorists...
Cultural studies and beyond: fragments of empire.
Magazine article from: Canadian Journal of Sociology September 22, 1997 700+ words
...Routledge, 1995, 203 pp. In Cultural Studies and Beyond: Fragments of Empire...evaluation of the current status of cultural studies. His intent is to critically...the institutionalization of cultural studies and to highlight the deficiency...
Cultural studies in Africa: positioning difference.
Magazine article from: Critical Arts Tomaselli, Keyan G January 1, 1999 700+ words
DOES AN AFRICAN cultural studies exist? If so, is it a unified field of...intellectual origins and discussions of cultural studies. Questions on the historical lineage of cultural studies offer one trajectory of current discussion...
Green cultural studies: an introductory critique of an emerging discipline.
Magazine article from: Mosaic (Winnipeg) Hochman, Jhan March 1, 1997 700+ words
...loosely federated but emerging field generally designated as "green cultural studies." As the term suggests, green cultural studies has major affinities with cultural studies, whose prevalent concern has been the impact that texts and social...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA