AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

My War with the AHA.

Academic Questions

| March 22, 2000 | Kaiser, David | COPYRIGHT 2000 Transaction Publishers, Inc. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

For the past twenty-three years I have been a practicing historian in three different academic departments, and during that time I have had an intermittent, generally difficult relationship with my professional organization, the American Historical Association. Were this story merely of personal interest I would keep it to myself, but I am persuaded that it is not. My various dealings with the AHA, which have now come to an end, illustrate the direction the historical profession has taken during the last twenty years, and the extent to which the association now belongs to a very narrow ideological group, quite intolerant of those who do not share their approaches. My experience is, I know, anything but unique, and it therefore deserves the attention of a wider audience, most of whom have no idea what is going on within the humanities today.

It was relatively early in my career, in 1983 I believe, that I first decided to propose a panel at the annual meeting of the association. Having published my first book in 1980, Economic Diplomacy and the Origins of the Second World War, I had returned to one of the most controversial issues in European history, the responsibility for the outbreak of the First World War, and I had had an article with a somewhat new view of Germany's responsibility accepted by the Journal of Modern History. That has been a leading journal on this issue since its founding in the 1920s. I thought it might be the basis for one paper on a panel on new views of the outbreak of the war. For the other papers I recruited William C. Fuller, Jr., the author of a book on Russian civil-military relations in the late imperial period, and Douglas Porch, who had already published several books on the French army in the early twentieth century. (The AHA did not yet have a rule, later adopted, that any panel submitted had to include women as well as men.) With Germany, France, and Russia covered by established young scholars (we were all in our thirties at that time), and having recruited another well-known authority on the period, Joachim Remak, to chair the panel, I didn't see how we could miss.

I was wrong. Upon receiving notice that our panel had been rejected, I called the then-chairman of the program committee, whom I knew slightly, to ask what had happened. He replied that a member of the committee had argued vehemently that no one could possibly have anything new to say about 1914. Since various leading university presses had reached the opposite conclusion about our work, I was shocked, but there was nothing that I could do. Already busy with additional projects, I more or less put the issue out of my mind. Only later did I realize that this was, in its own way, a significant event in the history of my profession.

Essentially, a trend has developed over the last three decades not merely in favor of writing the history of hitherto neglected groups, including the poor, minorities, and women, but actively against writing the history of governments and their role in society or abroad. Exactly why this has happened is a complex question. Professional humanists are, alas, always eager for new approaches, since they help provide new generations of graduate students with dissertation topics. The new areas of study matched the political interests of a new generation of historians who sympathized instinctively with the disadvantaged, as, indeed, I always have myself. More recently, as we shall see, the new emphasis has become connected to a new methodology that explicitly militates against studying white males, who, for better or for worse, have dominated modern Western governments. And lastly, traditional but liberal historians like myself took a sympathetic view of the new history as a means of rounding out the profession, not realizing that it was instead likely to transform it entirely from the discipline to which we had decided to devote our lives.

Now, as we enter a new century, many fine historians are still writing excellent political and diplomatic history, but one would never know it from any of the recent programs of the AHA convention, one of which I now hold in my hand. Out of 149 panels, the index lists only eleven on politics and four on diplomacy and foreign policy, but even this is misleading. Only three of the panels listed on politics deal with what governments did, rather than with what various people thought about politics, and only one of the four panels on diplomacy and foreign policy does. Only four out of 149 panels, in other words, deal with the concrete workings of governments, the institutions that exercise the most power over the lives of their citizens. Meanwhile, the index lists fifteen panels on "culture," thirteen on "identity," sixteen on "race," ten on "religion," and nine on "women." Every year on H-Diplo, a bulletin board for diplomatic historians, people raise this issue, and every year the AHA program committee claims that its distribution of panels reflects the distribution of proposals submitted. If that is true, it can only mean that political and diplomatic historians have been effectively intimidated or discouraged from taking part.

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Lobbying legacy: AHA's D.C. office forever changed by Medicare PPS.(American...
Magazine article from: Modern Healthcare Weissenstein, Eric January 26, 1998 700+ words
...chart). But when you ask veteran AHA lobbyists and alumni of the Washington...and for the Washington office of the AHA, life has never been the same. The AHA opened its Washington office during World War II as the Wartime Service Bureau...
FOR DIRECTOR OF MUSEUM OF SCIENCE, THERE'S A MAGIC WORD: 'AHA!'
Newspaper article from: The Boston Globe Elizabeth New Weld, Globe Staff May 17, 1987 700+ words
...when they experience what he calls the "aha factor." "Watch the little girls when...connections -- they just need to get the aha factor on something that is well known...it was not that significant before World War II," he said. "For citizens to be literate...
AHA disappointed by stimulus package. (Newswire).
Magazine article from: Healthcare Purchasing News June 1, 2003 700+ words
...a time when states face the most severe fiscal crisis since World War II, Medicaid relief and critical relief for all states in the...be included in any economic stimulus package." Joining the AHA were the National Association of Public Hospitals and Health...
Awakenings: one woman found a Catwoman-like power in her adolescent fingertips....
Magazine article from: O, The Oprah Magazine Monroe, Valerie Slater, Lauren Frankel, Valerie Mendel, Daniel Lamott, Anne Mosley, Walter Sonnenberg, Susanna Kogan, Lisa October 1, 2004 700+ words
...Suddenly, I remembered a postcard he'd given me, picturing a World War II battleship smoking its way across a choppy sea. On the back...he confessed to me that he had once had sex with a patient. Aha! Now I understood my reservations. I was strongly attracted...
EXCAVATING WORLD WAR'S LAYER OF LIES.(Editorial)(Column)
Newspaper article from: Rocky Mountain News (Denver, CO) May 11, 1997 700+ words
...paintings recovered from the Nazis after World War II. Then he lights briefly in front...pointing his finger excitedly in an ``Aha'' moment. This was one of the...Europe is revisiting and excavating World War II cover-ups and postwar complicities...
AHA buffeted by industry changes.(American Hospital Association)
Magazine article from: Modern Healthcare Burda, David October 7, 1996 700+ words
...of hospital industry consolidation, the AHA has lost more than 250 individual hospitals...systems as members since 1993, according to AHA figures. Consequently, the association...current members happy and in the fold. The AHA's experience mirrors that of other healthcare...
AHA tightens grip on info offered to public.(American Hospital Association)
Magazine article from: Modern Healthcare Burda, David June 24, 1996 700+ words
...sending annual reports about its activities to AHA members, MODERN HEALTHCARE has learned...report comes during a period in which the AHA was caught off guard by the disclosure of...that had not been widely disseminated to AHA members. That included the failure of a...
AHA Career Center Announces Winners of 2008 Fall NHCN Scholarships.
Press release article from: Business Wire October 13, 2008 700+ words
...said Anthony J. Burke, President and CEO of AHA Solutions, Inc., "and the AHA is proud to offer these scholarship awards to individuals...journey." The winners were selected by a committee of AHA Career Center Charter Members (Frankford Hospital...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA