AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

LETTERS.(Letter to the Editor)

Academic Questions

| March 22, 2000 | COPYRIGHT 2000 Transaction Publishers, Inc. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

Confining the Classics

To the editor,

Your reflections on the use of highlighters and underlining text ("From the Editor's Desk," Spring 1999) brought to mind a visit of the formidable Professor Philip Rieff to Concordia's Great Books Liberal Arts College in Montreal. Those of your readers who have had the privilege of listening to Professor Rieff expound on Freud, universities, and modern culture (as we did on several occasions) will understand how this anecdote connects to this brilliant scholar and teacher. To your other readers, I urge you to get to a library and perhaps get a sense of why some of us consider Professor Rieff one of the outstanding intellects of the twentieth century.

Professor Rieff was leading a College seminar on Freud's Civilization and Its Discontents and at random chose a text sitting on the table. (The professor was late.) As he scanned the book, he noted, with evident displeasure, that the book was underlined. Our seminar's first half hour turned into a condemnatory and chastising peroration befitting an Old Testament prophet on how underlining violates reading, thinking, and the written word. We listened with awe, embarrassment, and I thought, now I know the meaning of a "hidden text."

In some sense the student (as narrated by editor Pinsker) who was underlining what seemed to be the entire text was closer to Professor Rieff's wisdom than Professor Pinsker's observation that "highlight means to select matter that's important--the very opposite of what this highlighter-mad student was doing." Professor Pinsker's explanation why selective underlining is necessary is, ironically, Professor Rieff's explanation why we should not underline. Professor Pinsker writes: "Serious books are read to be reread--as books change us, we change our minds about books." Professor Rieff called such books "thick texts." To underline Freud was to defile the text; it is to privilege our glancing and first impressions against the carefully chosen words of a master--and here we were selecting out and highlighting words that we needed to learn in their entirety as Freud wrote them. Professor Rieff then went on to a seemingly obscure reference to St. Francis of Assisi in Civilization and Its Discontents (no one had underlined this passage) brilliantly to show how this reference was the key to understanding Freud's great work.

Every year I continue to think of Professor Rieff as I begin to reread the Great Books with new students and uncomfortably look for my underlinings and marginal observations as I lead the seminar. Over the years, these annual rereadings produce more underlinings in various colors and angles, and more marginal notes so small that I cannot read them anymore. So Professor Rieff ultimately prevails as more and more of the text becomes highlighted and less and less of Shulman is retrievable. Every few years I reread a fresh, clean text and again have the opportunity of reading "thick texts" the way they were written, not the way I confined them.

 
Harvey Shulman 
Concordia University 
Montreal, Canada 
Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Sexual harassment between same-sex peers: Intersection of mental health,...
Magazine article from: Social Work Fineran, Susan January 1, 2002 700+ words
...framework for defining peer sexual harassment from three different perspectives...decisions that define sexual harassment in both education and...and arguments regarding sexual harassment between peers of the same...
Sexual harassment: a growing workplace dilemma.
Magazine article from: USA Today (Magazine) Losey, Michael R. March 1, 1995 700+ words
THE LAW prohibiting sexual harassment is nothing new. Such behavior...meaning efforts by employers, sexual harassment litigation continues to skyrocket...departments handled one or more sexual harassment reports rose from 35.2...
Sexual harassment: early adolescents' self-reports of experiences and...
Magazine article from: Adolescence Roscoe, Bruce Strouse, Jeremiah S. Goodwin, Megan P. September 22, 1994 700+ words
Sexual harassment of older adolescents has been...1984). Research on student sexual harassment has focused almost exclusively...recognize and address the reality that sexual harassment is occurring at considerably younger...
SEXUAL HARASSMENT IN HIGHER EDUCATION.
Magazine article from: Education LEITICH, KEITH A. June 22, 1999 700+ words
...recently that the issue of sexual harassment has become an acknowledged...Across the nation, sexual harassment has become a major issue...of research examining sexual harassment in higher education...
Sexual harassment in the Utah workplace: preventing claims.
Magazine article from: Utah Business Smith, Janet Hugie February 1, 1992 700+ words
SEXUAL HARASSMENT IN THE UTAH WORKPLACE In recent years...subtle forms of discrimination, such as sexual harassment, however, still pose obstacles to working women. (While sexual harassment charges have been brought by men, the...
Sexual Harassment in the 1990s.
Magazine article from: Journal of Higher Education Kelley, Michelle L. Parsons, Beth September 1, 2000 700+ words
...of the existing research examining sexual harassment was conducted when awareness of sexual harassment was low and policies were uncommon...may have affected the prevalence of sexual harassment on university campuses. Title VII...
Sexual harassment experiences of psychologists and psychological associates...
Magazine article from: The Canadian Journal of Human Sexuality Schneider, Margaret Baker, Sarah Stermac, Lana September 22, 2002 700+ words
...between past experiences of sexual harassment behaviours while in graduate...1995) was used to assess sexual harassment experiences. A majority...experiencing at least one sexual harassment behaviour exhibited by...
Sexual harassment of adolescents perpetrated by teachers and by peers: an...
Magazine article from: Sex Roles: A Journal of Research Timmerman, Greetje March 1, 2003 700+ words
Research on the sexual harassment of adolescents in secondary...these behaviors occur) between sexual harassment by teachers or peers is less...perpetrator have indicated that peer sexual harassment is much more common than sexual...
Sexual harassment: a legal perspective for public administrators.
Magazine article from: Public Personnel Management Strickland, Ruth Ann December 22, 1995 700+ words
Estimating the Scope of Sexual Harassment Surveys administered as early...employment were affected by sexual harassment, with as many as 59 percent...a direct experience with sexual harassment. In a random survey of female...
Sexual harassment policies in K-12 schools: examining accessibility to students...
Magazine article from: Journal of School Health Lichty, Lauren F. Torres, Jennifer M.C. Valenti, Maria T. Buchanan, Nicole T. November 1, 2008 700+ words
School-based peer sexual harassment emerged as an area of research...to youth. School-based sexual harassment is defined by social science...representative studies of sexual harassment in schools found that approximately...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA