AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Adaptable careers: maximizing less and exploring more.(Articles)

Career Development Quarterly

| June 01, 2009 | van Vianen, Annelies E.M.; Pater, Irene E. De; Preenen, Paul T.Y. | COPYRIGHT 2009 National Career Development Association. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

Today, young adults are expected to decide between educational, vocational, and job options and to make the best choice possible. Career literatures emphasize the importance of young adults' career decision making but also acknowledge the problems related to making these decisions. The authors argue that career counselors could support clients' intuitive processing of career information and help their clients to develop a positive and flexible view of the self and the environment while diminishing concerns about accountability for and irreversibility of career decisions. The authors argue that career adaptability rather than decision making should become the focal concept of career theory and practice.

Most people struggle with making career decisions, for example, when they have to choose between available educational, vocational, and job options. Especially young people who face the transition from school to work may experience indecision, often feeling unable to decide what career they wish to pursue. Career indecision is prevalent among college students and is frequently experienced as a burden and associated with feelings of anxiety and lowered self-esteem (Betz & Serling, 1993). Generally, humans find it difficult to use rational strategies when making decisions (e.g., Anderson, 2003). Moreover, they are sometimes unhappy with their decisions once they are finally made. Yet, many career theories emphasize conscious decision making as a necessity for healthy career development. This pressure on career decision making as reflected in daily practices together with the difficulties that young people experience with making career decisions may cause them to feel insecure and unhappy.

In this article, we question the need for younger people to in fact decide about their careers, given the traditional definition of the career concept. Using the literature on decision making and cognitive processing as a basis, we argue that conscious decision making is a less optimal strategy for making career decisions than is often thought. In addition, taking a perspective on the concept of careers that is focused on the future, we argue that traditional career theories are no longer adequate and should be replaced by new concepts that emphasize career adaptability, such as malleable selves, mastery of different roles, and short-term decision making.

Decision Making: Rationality and Intution

Each day, people have to make many choices and decisions. The moment they enter a shop, they start the process of choosing and deciding: What do I eat today, what brand of a product should I buy? Today, people live in a world with numerous choices. The economic prosperity of Western society has provided them with this choice luxury. Moreover, modern societies emphasize people's self-determination and freedom of choice (Schwartz, 2000). Many aspects of human life have become self-determined: People can choose whether they will marry or whether they will have children, and they have the freedom to choose their career. Young adults have more freedom in fashioning their career than their parents did at the time they were young. Although social mobility is often difficult (e.g., Leong, 1995), children are not necessarily bound to the economic class of their parents that dictated the educational level they could reach. Young adults arc often not constrained to do the type of work their parents did. Instead, they have the opportunity to choose from a long list of vocational and career options. This seems like a luxury but may not be experienced as such.

Decision making is difficult. It involves a complex process of cognitive reasoning and, therefore, it costs time and effort. Moreover, decisions regarding one's vocation and career usually have to be made under conditions of great uncertainty. Decision making generally encompasses five stages: defining the problem, understanding the underlying mechanisms, formulating plausible alternatives, prioritizing alternatives, and evaluating the outcomes (Peterson, Sampson, Lenz, & Reardon, 2002).

Defining the decision problem is the very first obstacle with which young people are confronted. They struggle with questions such as What are the specific goals I strive for in my future career? Should I focus on a short-term or a long-term perspective? Should I go for what I prefer right now or for more realistic opportunities, eventually at the expense of my actual preferences? In addition, the overall picture of the decision-making task is often unclear. A good overview of plausible alternatives is usually missing (i.e., the options in the labor market and exactly what these options include), as is a clear idea of one's self-concept (i.e., knowledge regarding who one is and of one's capacities and interests). It seems almost impossible to make a conscientious choice when the two components of that choice, the self and the environment, are highly ambiguous. Moreover, if all choice options are listed, it yet remains difficult to rank-order them because it is uncertain which decision strategy may lead to a good decision. Also, there may be no single correct or best option, so there is no guarantee that the decision will ensure success (Germeijs & De Boeck, 2002).

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Applying Social Learning Theory of Career Decision Making to Gay, Lesbian,...
Magazine article from: The Career Development Quarterly Datti, Paul A September 1, 2009 700+ words
...GLBTQ) adolescents and young adults. Unique challenges...million adolescents and young adults may be predominately...in particular face career decisions that are unique to...concerning adolescents and young adults. Schmidt and Nilsson...
Applying social learning theory of career decision making to gay, lesbian,...
Magazine article from: Career Development Quarterly Datti, Paul A. September 1, 2009 700+ words
...GLBTQ) adolescents and young adults. Unique challenges...million adolescents and young adults may be predominately...in particular face career decisions that are unique to...concerning adolescents and young adults. Schmidt and Nilsson...
'Council Rock Cares' to address issues of young adults. (NEWS ADVISORY)
Press release article from: PR Newswire March 29, 1989 700+ words
...CARES' TO ADDRESS ISSUES OF YOUNG ADULTS In a prime example of cooperation...causing stress in the lives of young adults throughout the country. Mark...College Entrance Examinations! Career Decisions! Peer Pressue! All of the above...
Interpersonal Influences on Students' Academic and Career Decisions: The Impact...
Magazine article from: Career Development Quarterly Nauta, Margaret M. Saucier, Amy M. Woodard, Leigh E. June 1, 2001 700+ words
...models who are out at work may help young adults anticipate reactions to and consequences...formation often occur simultaneously in young adults (Etringer et al., 1990), GLB individuals...time that coincides with important career decisions. Any resulting loss of support and...
UT scholar finds 9/11 inspired young adults.
Newspaper article from: Dallas Morning News (Dallas, TX) September 10, 2006 700+ words
...about how the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks in New York and Washington, D.C., were factoring into students' career decisions, choices of majors and even personal relationships. Three years ago, Dr. Somers launched a project on the 9/11 generation...
All Alone: Michigan Students Helpless When Choosing Careers, Ferris State Study...
Press release article from: PR Newswire January 5, 2001 700+ words
...Decision-Making has completed a year's worth of research and discussion centered around how Michigan's young adults make career decisions, what factors influence those decisions and whether it is feasible to try to influence students to explore...
First impressions. ('Quick Printing: Where Great Impressions Last a Lifetime':...
Magazine article from: Graphic Arts Monthly Piskora, Beth January 1, 1990 700+ words
...nation's career-bound young adults by introducing a new video...workforce at a time when young adults are making career decisions. Facing a future that includes...The video aims to educate young adults to the challenges and opportunities...
Young Adults Visit Doctors Least at an Age When Risky Behavior Peaks.
Newspaper article from: Biotech Week October 7, 2009 700+ words
...wayside. A recent study has found that young adults are much less likely to use ambulatory...University of Rochester Medical Center). "Young adults are generally a healthy population...rate of many preventable diseases, young adults garner relatively little attention from...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA