More Grapes, Less Wrath.(International Edition; BUSINESS)(financial crises)(Viewpoint essay)

Byline: Zachary Karabell

If we're in the middle of a new Great Depression, then why are we still ordering $17 cocktails?

It has now been firmly established--and endlessly repeated--that the world is mired in the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression. In the past weeks alone, there have been headlines announcing the "worst industrial production numbers since World War II" and the greatest contraction of prices since the middle of last century. And throughout the world the data continues to roll in, with economic growth in the United States likely contracting at nearly a 6 percent rate for the first quarter of 2009 and countries from Japan to Brazil linked by the common phenomenon of shrinking economies and lost jobs. While U.S. and global stock markets have made up some ground, they remain down as much as 50 percent from their highs just over a year ago.

And yet, there's reason to believe that the Depression is not a good analogy for today's crisis. The Depression conjures images of lines of grim-faced men and women, waiting on bread lines and work lines, or "Okies" trekking glumly from their desiccated farms to California in scenes of Steinbeckian squalor. It evokes James Agee's haunting photographs in ironic "praise of famous men" who would never be famous save for the shared infamy of their misery. The Depression gave birth to violent politics: Nazi nationalism in Germany, hard-line jingoism in Japan, war and Mao's long march in China. It was an age of toppled governments, nationalized industry and seething workers throughout Latin America.

The images from around the world are very different today. It is the Western elite that has supposedly been hit hardest and changed forever, but they are pondering their losses while downing $17 martinis in New York or Dallas. And even though the IMF and the World Bank have grim projections for the year ahead and fears of instability are rife, we are, for whatever reason, not seeing much evidence of that. There is not yet an Agee documenting the plight of the emerging world, which suggests that misery is not as easy to spot as it was in the 1930s.

Take the city of Buenos Aires, capital of an economy built on the export of food and leather, and acutely sensitive to downdrafts in global trade. The sprawling old neighborhood of Palermo and its subsections "Palermo Soho" and "Palermo Hollywood" see new clubs, bars and restaurants opening weekly. Hip spaces are filled nightly with the young and sleek, including young American and European expats with funds to spare.

The same might be said of Sao Paolo, or of Mumbai, Dubai, and Shanghai. Business in these boomtowns is more muted than before, but Dubai has a multibillion-dollar credit line from oil-rich Abu Dhabi; Mumbai continues to hum even after the wrenching terrorist attacks; China's recovery is so sharp and so V-shaped that you could have missed the bottom by going away for a weekend.