AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Point of view: in teaching composition, 'formulaic' is not a four-letter word *.

Style

| March 22, 2008 | Birkenstein, Cathy; Graff, Gerald | COPYRIGHT 2008 Northern Illinois University. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

One of the least-examined assumptions among academics today is that being "formulaic"--using established formulas to structure thought--is always a bad thing. In the field of rhetoric and composition, to say that a mode of writing instruction is formulaic is to charge it with having a "cookie cutter" quality: the student writer presumably inserts raw material into a mold, and the product automatically comes out, no thought required.

That is the charge commonly leveled against the five-paragraph essay that has long been a dominant model for high-school writing. Specifically, it is said that the five-paragraph formula forces students to conform to a mechanical routine that chokes the life out of writing, encouraging them not to wrestle with ideas but to conform to a one-size-fits-all straitjacket.

Dennis Baron, a linguist and English professor, complains that the SAT's "formulaic approach will reverse decades of progress in literacy instruction and ultimately turn students into intellectual automatons." Like many academics, Baron uses "formulaic" pejoratively, as if the word always merits an eye-roiling grimace.

There are several problems with this formulaphobia. For one thing, not all formulas function in the same deadening way. Furthermore, the idea that formulas in themselves are bad--or that we could possibly communicate in some formula-free way--is mistaken. Formulas, less invidiously called conventions, pervade everything we do.

Try writing a sonnet, doing the cha-cha, saying "Hi, how are you?" or "I love you," or even questioning the value of formulas without relying on established forms that you didn't invent. Far from shutting down thought and stifling creativity, formulas structure thought and feeling and make creativity possible. Most important, if we try to reject formulas altogether, we forfeit a valuable tool for clarifying academic mysteries to large numbers of students. The proper antidote to the five-paragraph formula is not to reject formulas as such, but to look for ones that more closely capture the way critical thinking really operates. The reason the five-paragraph essay has survived as long as it has, we suspect, is that it gives students who need it a series of clear operations to perform: offer an introductory claim followed by three supporting paragraphs and then a conclusion that restates and deepens the claim.

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
A cookie-cutter approach to collecting: is there a better symbol for home sweet...
Magazine article from: Antiques Roadshow Insider Palmer, Sharon January 1, 2009 700+ words
...specializing in antique cookware. "The cookie cutter is an item that seems to come in an...Linzer cookies. The U.S. chapter on cookie cutter history during the 1800s is a scrappy...1990s.) Hallmark joined the plastic cookie cutter scene in the 1970s. SWEET TIPS Have...
Cute as a cookie? Not this shark.(ANIMAL ANGLES)(cookie-cutter shark)
Magazine article from: Odyssey Lopata, Peg May 1, 2009 700+ words
...slow-moving, and glows, yet, the cookie-cutter shark (Isistius brasiliensis) feasts...glow in the dark) as a lure, the cookie-cutter shark has a different approach. It...fish knows what has happened, the cookie-cutter shark plunges its saw-like teeth...
Notebook, blog, Cookie Cutter celebrate anniversaries [Derived headline]
Newspaper article from: Yakima Herald-Republic Mai Hoang October 12, 2009 700+ words
...celebrating 30 years in business. Cookie Cutter turns 30 A local Yakima kitchen shop...pair decided to take the opportunity. Cookie Cutter Etc. opened in November 1979. The...Having a stable tenant such as the Cookie Cutter helps attract new tenants, he said...
Glow-in-the-dark shark has killer smudge.(dark patch on cookie-cutter shark...
Magazine article from: Science News Milius, Susan August 1, 1998 700+ words
...itself by the smaller predator called a cookie-cutter shark. This shark does what its name...fatal. Widder's discussion of the cookie-cutter shark's dark patch is scheduled to...their shapes, Widder explains. The cookie-cutter shark has carried this phenomenon...
Longtime Pennsylvania-Based Cookie-Cutter Maker Stays in the Family.(Originated...
Newspaper article from: Knight Ridder/Tribune Business News Warner, Susan December 23, 1996 700+ words
...fly over the spot welders. This is cookie-cutter production. Literally. Fox Run Craftsmen...with beeswax, but it has expanded its cookie cutter lines and has become a major importer...and black label that reads, simply: Cookie Cutter. "The public doesn't recognize...
cookie cutter shopping centers: East Valley seeing same old, same old lineups...
Newspaper article from: Tribune (Mesa, AZ) June 30, 2007 700+ words
...Sarah J. Boggan Jun. 30--First it was cookie-cutter houses, and now cookie-cutter shopping centers are popping up all over...stores closer to home. "They are kind of cookie-cutter, but at least we're getting more out...
The new niche: smashing cookie-cutter molds. (convenience stores) (Convenience...
Magazine article from: National Petroleum News Abcede, Angel August 1, 1994 700+ words
...water instinct and throw away the cookie cutter. It may seem hard to believe, but...petroleum operators are taking the cookie cutter out of their merchandising recipe and...chain defined for many the idea of "cookie-cutter" franchising. For years, the 7...
Cookie cutter approach to faster project start-ups.
Magazine article from: Control Engineering December 1, 2005 700+ words
...works in the engineering world, think of a cookie cutter. A cookie cutter is basically the same thing as a "parent template...oriented software. The cookies cut with a cookie cutter are "objects" in the software world. Typically...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA