AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Cleaning up condemnation proceedings: legislative and judicial solutions to the dilemma of admitting contamination evidence.

Iowa Law Review

| March 01, 2008 | Reed, Andrea L. | COPYRIGHT 2008 University of Iowa. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

ABSTRACT: State courts have adopted different approaches to valuing contaminated properties for purposes of awarding just compensation in eminent domain proceedings. Of the states that have adjudicated this issue, the majority have held that evidence of contamination is admissible under the principle that market value is the best measure of just compensation and contamination is relevant to market value. A minority exclude contamination evidence to avoid penalizing the condemnee for contamination twice: once in the form of a reduced compensation award and again when the condemnee is held liable for remediation costs in a cost-recovery proceeding. A few states have adopted a third alternative, the trust-escrow approach, which omits evidence of contamination during the condemnation proceeding and holds the award in escrow pending the resolution of a cost-recovery action. Ideally, courts and legislatures should fashion a remedy that protects the condemnee from double liability and protects the condemnor from paying an unreasonably high price for the property. This Note suggests that the best solution to this problem is a statutory fix specifying that contamination evidence is admissible in condemnation proceedings and that any reduction in value due to contamination will offset future cleanup liability. In the absence of a legislative fix, however, this Note concludes that the trust--escrow approach is the best judicial solution because it strikes the most equitable balance between the interests of the condemnor and condemnee.

 
  I. INTRODUCTION 
 II. TRADITIONAL PRINCIPLES OF EMINENT DOMAIN AND JUST 
     COMPENSATION 
     A. EMINENT DOMAIN 
        1. The Process and Use of Condemnation 
        2. Public-Use Doctrine and Contaminated Properties 
     B. DEFINING "JUST COMPENSATION" 
        1. Comparable-Sales Method 
        2. Capitalization-of-Income Method 
        3. Other Methods of Valuing Property 
III. JUST COMPENSATION FOR CONTAMINATED PROPERTIES 
     A. THE NATURE OF THE DIFFICULTY IN APPLYING TRADITIONAL 
        PRINCIPLES OF "JUST COMPENSATION" 
        1. Difficulty in Measuring Fair Market Value 
        2. Potential for "Double Liability" in Cost-Recovery 
           Proceedings 
     B. THE SPLIT IN AUTHORITY AMONG THE STATES 
        1. Majority Rule: Admitting Evidence of Contamination 
        2. Minority Rule: Omitting Evidence of Contamination 
           a. Avoiding Double Liability 
           b. Protecting Due-Process Rights 
           c. Upholding the Independent Nature of Eminent Domain 
              and Environmental Law 
           d. Avoiding Complications and Delay in Condemnation 
        3. A Possible Compromise: The Trust-Escrow Approach 
 IV. RECOMMENDED LEGISLATIVE AND JUDICIAL SOLUTIONS 
     A. THE BEST LEGISLATIVE SOLUTION: ADMISSION WITH SET-OFF 
        1. The Admission with Set-Off Approach and Modern 
           Brownfield Development Practices 
        2. Uncertainty in Cost-Recovery 
        3. Mechanisms for Offsetting Cleanup Liability 
     B. THE BEST JUDICIAL SOLUTION: OMISSION WITH TRUST-ESCROW 
  V. POTENTIAL FOR SUPREME COURT REVIEW 
 VI. CONCLUSION 

I. INTRODUCTION

The Windham Mills Technology Center in Northeast Connecticut is comprised of renovated factory buildings that once housed The American Thread Company, the largest cotton mill in the world during the early twentieth century. (1) The mill finally closed its doors in 1985 after many years of steady decline, leaving behind the dilapidated relics of a once-thriving factory and the stain of hazardous chemicals that had seeped into the soil over its years of operation. (2) In an effort to revive the local economy, which had crumbled along with the mill, the city condemned the property and conveyed it to the Windham Mills Development Corporation. (3) Before the Corporation could adapt the site for commercial use, however, it required extensive environmental remediation. (4) This became a major issue in determining how to value the property in the condemnation trial. (5) The presence of contamination complicated the process of determining what constituted just compensation for the owner of the property. (6)

Traditionally, just compensation for the exercise of eminent domain is some measure of market value for the property. (7) In the case of contaminated properties, market value is complicated by the costs of cleaning up the property for the intended use and the possibility of subsequent cost-recovery actions against the condemnee. Finding just compensation for contaminated properties presents the decisionmaker(8) with two undesirable alternatives: admit evidence of contamination to reduce the condemnation award at the risk of imposing double liability for cleanup costs, (9) or withhold the evidence of contamination and compensate the landowner as if the property were remediated at the risk of overcompensating the landowner at the expense of taxpayers.

The Connecticut Supreme Court addressed this issue when evaluating just compensation for the landowner in the condemnation of The American Thread Company's dilapidated cotton mill. In Northeast Ct. Economic Alliance, Inc. v. ATC Partnership, (11) the court held that contamination evidence must be admitted, thereby reducing the compensation awarded to the landowner. (12) The Connecticut approach falls in line with the majority of states that have considered this issue. (13) However, many state courts and legislatures are split between this approach and its alternatives, and there is a substantial body of authority defending or disparaging each alternative. (14)

The divide in authority is likely to grow as courts see an increasing number of contaminated properties subjected to eminent domain proceedings, in part because the growing national interest in urban renewal has created a greater demand for the redevelopment of stagnant, often contaminated, urban properties. Many of these properties are relics of the industrial age and exist today only as scars on city landscapes. Entrepreneurs are taking advantage of the opportunities to redevelop these properties into uses that are profitable and beneficial for the public. (15) The Windham Mills Technology Center development on the former site of the American Thread Company is just one example of an industrial relic being transformed into modern use. (16)

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Eminent Domain: Information about Its Uses and Effect on Property Owners and...
General Accounting Office Reports & Testimony December 1, 2006 700+ words
...conduct a nationwide study on the use of eminent domain by state and local governments. This...the purposes for and extent to which eminent domain can be and has been used; (2) the...use to acquire land, including by eminent domain; (3) how the use of eminent domain...
Eminent domain reform on horizon: local government, environmentalists seek to...
Newspaper article from: California Planning & Development Report Shigley, Paul January 1, 2007 700+ words
...Proposition 90, new proposals to alter eminent domain law are already arising. Anti-tax...state lawmakers are all working on eminent domain proposals, and it is likely that voters...will lose at least some measure of eminent domain authority, as even the California...
Eminent domain will get airing in 2006 legislative session.
Newspaper article from: Finance and Commerce Daily Newspaper, MN January 12, 2006 700+ words
...proposals floating around the Capitol, eminent domain is expected to be a dominant issue...government can take property under eminent domain for purposes of economic development...couple of bills would have prohibited eminent domain in cases where property would be transferred...
Eminent domain is an essential development tool to acquire contaminated sites...
Newspaper article from: St. Charles County Business Record, MO May 19, 2006 700+ words
Byline: Shawna M. Bligh Eminent domain is often an essential development...contamination. However, using eminent domain for private projects, such...property, through its powers of eminent domain, and sells it for private development...
States and eminent domain: limiting public use, increasing...
Magazine article from: Valuation Insights & Perspectives Morton, Justin September 22, 2005 700+ words
...ITS JUNE 2005 RULING IN THE LANDMARK EMINENT DOMAIN CASE, KELO V. CITY OF NEW LONDON...governments could limit how localities use eminent domain. Specifically, the court said states...definition of "public use" to allow eminent domain only for traditional definitions of...
Official defends eminent domain.
News wire article from: Macon Telegraph (Macon, GA) February 13, 2006 700+ words
...week that his proposal to rein in eminent domain powers might be too weak. Perdue's bills would strip eminent domain power from development and housing...Some lawmakers, however, say eminent domain power should only be used to acquire...
BG's eminent domain plan gets noticed.
Newspaper article from: Daily News (Bowling Green, KY) November 7, 2005 700+ words
...Bowling Green's recent restriction of eminent domain might serve as the model for new statewide...vote, banning themselves from using eminent domain for anything but expressly public projects...any Kentucky government's use of eminent domain to " 'qualified public uses,' involving...
Panel tackles eminent domain.
Newspaper article from: The Indianapolis Star (Indianapolis, Indiana) (via Knight-Ridder/Tribune Business News) August 11, 2005 700+ words
...the first time to study the issue of eminent domain, is to balance private property rights...ensure Hoosiers get a fair price when eminent domain is used. In June, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that a government may use eminent domain to obtain private property that later...
California Voters Pass Eminent Domain Reform: Impact Limited.
News wire article from: Mondaq Business Briefing June 5, 2008 700+ words
...and local governments from using eminent domain to take an owner-occupied, single...California voters rejected a competing eminent domain proposal, Proposition 98. Prop. 98 would have taken eminent domain reform to a new level. Termed...
Cities may dodge stricter eminent domain standard; Local `home rule' still...
Magazine article from: Crain's Cleveland Business June 4, 2007 700+ words
...new set of rules to guide the use of eminent domain before the Legislature adjourns. But...legislative schizophrenia may leave municipal eminent domain untouched, which would be a relief...the Legislature decides to control eminent domain on the state level. "Where we have...
For more facts and information, see all results

Source: HighBeam Research, Cleaning up condemnation proceedings: legislative and judicial...

©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA