AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Hands and fists across the border: Canadian and American cattlemen in the twentieth century.

Alberta History

| March 22, 2008 | Foran, Max | COPYRIGHT 2008 Historical Society of Alberta. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]

The American and Canadian cattle industries are very similar and through time they have developed close personal, commercial, and cultural bonds. They have fought common battles against animal disease; have integrated their breeding regimes: developed similar technologies, and adopted like scientific principles to range management. However, a reliance on inflexible cattlemen's associations as mouthpieces and on federal governments to set protective trade agendas, has led to periodic and sometimes acrimonious disputes. The Canadians through their associations want government to secure free access to lucrative markets in the United States while the American cattlemen utilize the same avenues to gain some protection or restraint of trade.

For the most part the two industries have developed in like fashion, following similar breeding, range management, and marketing practices, and along the way, each falling prey to wider national interests while profiting from the twentieth century fixation with beef as a status food. One has only to note how the industry promotes the mythology of beef in both countries. For instance, Omaha beef is eulogized south of the border in much the same way as Alberta beef is north of the 49th Parallel. To J. Patrick Boyle, president and CEO of the American Meat Institute, "the beef industries in the U.S. and its northern neighbor have become so alike in recent years that it's nearly impossible to differentiate between the two, outside of political jurisdictions. In fact, the cattle not only come from the same gene pool, but are raised under nearly identical conditions, fed virtually the same feed and handled under the same regimens. In fact, if Canadian cattle didn't occasionally utter 'eh' instead of the traditional 'moo,' they'd be completely indistinguishable from their American counterparts." (1)

A worthwhile prelude to this paper may be to consider the very different ways academics in both countries have depicted the two founding ranching traditions. In Canada, scholarly interest has not focussed on the historical evolution of the industry itself but rather on socio-cultural factors which distinguished Canada's ranching tradition from that in the United States. Canadian historians Lewis G. Thomas and Sheilagh Jameson, and later, David Breen in his seminal study of the early western Canadian ranching industry, have argued that the presence of powerful east-west metropolitan forces differentiated it from its American counterpart. (2)

In Canada this resulted in a law abiding and hierarchical frontier that contradicted the more egalitarian and lawless American ranching experience. This debate has received short thrift in the United States where historians have argued that there were never two ranching traditions separated by a national boundary but rather different regional manifestations. (3) As for the Canadian cattle frontier, Terry Jordan Bychkov simply places it as an extension of what he called the Midwestern ranching experience. (4) What is interesting is that Canadian scholars, ever seeking ways to isolate Canadian distinctiveness, have used the early cattle industry to exemplify significant cultural differences between the two countries. Not surprisingly, the Americans take a larger more continental view.

The discussion in this paper focuses on American and Canadian cattlemen themselves, rather than on other components of the industry. Both are impacted appreciably by the volatility endemic in any agribusiness, or as one Canadian source quoted in 1938, "a slice of cow is worth 5 cents in the cow, 14 cents in the hands of the packer, and $2.40 in a restaurant that specializes in atmosphere." (5) This means that ranchers often have a very different perspective than meat packers, stockyard and feedlot operators, commission agents, butchers, retailers, or even the consumers who buy the packaged cuts in supermarkets.

Cattlemen must contend with uncontrollable environmental factors. For example, 90 per cent herd losses occurred on the Great Plains in the winter of 1886-87, while similar statistics were given for Alberta in the winter of 1906-07. Cattle producers must also measure the likelihood of profit against feeding costs, which in turn are linked to unpredictable grain supplies and prices. The cattlemen's sense of powerlessness is paradoxically reflected in their efforts to control the price they receive for their live animals. Historically, they mistrusted rail grading, not so much because it was often incongruent with the appearance of the live animal, but because it was done in the packing houses away from the rancher's scrutiny. They also rejected attempts to regulate marketing practices on the grounds that they knew only the best time to buy and sell. Finally, they have had to contend with incompatible government agendas. In this context, American cattlemen have been better placed than their Canadian counterparts.

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Festering friendship: the closed border between Canada and the United States,...
Magazine article from: The National Provisioner Young, Barbara May 1, 2005 700+ words
...relationship between Canada and the United States. The trade embargo between...The global impact on the United States in the wake of the discovery...competing head-to-head with American cattlemen for expansion in a fairly static...
United States Immigration Alert.
News wire article from: Mondaq Business Briefing April 1, 2009 700+ words
...five years for multiple trips to the United States. Visa waiver passport holders cannot enter the United States without such an approval notice...certain countries who are visiting the United States for business or pleasure purposes...
United States Uranium Mining Industry Analysis and Forecasts to 2015.
Press release article from: M2 Presswire July 8, 2009 700+ words
...2009-Research and Markets: United States Uranium Mining Industry Analysis...researchandmarkets.com/research/70b97f/united_states_uran) has announced the addition of GlobalData 's new report "United States Uranium Mining Industry Analysis...
United States Virgin Islands Quarter Launched in St. Thomas
Newspaper article from: U.S. Newswire October 9, 2009 700+ words
...EDITORS Contact: Carolyn Fields of the United States Mint, +1-202-354- 7222 WASHINGTON...quarter-dollar coin honoring the United States Virgin Islands was officially launched...in Charlotte Amalie, St. Thomas, United States Virgin Islands. United States Mint...
United States Nuclear Power Market Analysis and Forecasts to 2015.
Press release article from: M2 Presswire February 27, 2009 700+ words
...2009-Research and Markets: United States Nuclear Power Market Analysis...researchandmarkets.com/research/1b60fb/united_states_nucl) has announced the addition of GlobalData 's new report "United States Nuclear Power Market Analysis...
United States Uranium Mining Industry Analysis and Forecasts to 2015.(Report)
Newspaper article from: Mining & Minerals July 24, 2009 700+ words
...com/research/02711c/united_states_uran) has announced the...GlobalData's new report "United States Uranium Mining Industry Analysis...2015" to their offering. United States Uranium Mining Industry Analysis...
United States Country Profile.
Press release article from: M2 Presswire February 18, 2003 700+ words
...February 2003-Research and Markets: United States Country Profile(C)1994-2003 M2...indispensable reference guide to the United States, putting key facts and figures, political...Indicators LIST OF TABLES Table 1: United States GDP, 1991-2001 (1995=100) Table...
United States Wound Care Management Investment Opportunities, Analysis and...
Press release article from: M2 Presswire July 14, 2009 700+ words
...July 2009-Research and Markets: United States Wound Care Management Investment Opportunities...researchandmarkets.com/research/09937d/united_states_woun) has announced the addition of Global Markets Direct's new report "United States Wound Care Management Investment Opportunities...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA