AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

On the use of medical records for characterizing brain lesions.(Report)

Journal of Medical Speech - Language Pathology

| December 01, 2007 | Blake, Margaret Lehman; Baumgaertner, Annette | COPYRIGHT 2007 Delmar Learning. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

In studies of neurogenic communication disorders, medical records commonly are used to characterize brain lesions, to make decisions regarding participant inclusion, and to draw general conclusions regarding brain-behavior relationships. The validity of using existing medical records has not been directly evaluated. The purpose of this article is to draw attention to the potential problems with relying exclusively on medical records to characterize neurological lesions. Examples from a study of language in adults with right hemisphere brain damage are used to highlight discrepancies between imaging reports taken from existing medical records and structural images obtained at the time of the study. The discussion of factors that may contribute to discrepancies between the imaging reports includes the scanning method and protocol used, interrater reliability for reading neuroradiologic images, the effect of time, and neurological changes associated with normal aging.

**********

The search for the nature of brain-behavior relationships has been ongoing for nearly two centuries but is still an active search. The description of these relationships can be as broad as comparing right versus left hemisphere functions or as specific as isolating a region of a particular gyrus responsible for specific language functions. The advent of widely used imaging technology has both enhanced our ability to pinpoint such relationships and spawned new questions and problems.

Studies of neurogenic communication disorders frequently rely on reports from participants' medical records to identify site and/or size of lesion. Decisions regarding participant inclusion and group classification are made on the basis of these reports, along with conclusions regarding brain-behavior relationships. In typical studies of neurogenic language disorders, the screening process for potential participants involves a review of medical records. Participants included in a study are those whose medical records provide evidence of a lesion in the hemisphere, lobe, or structure of interest. Many times this information is from a computed tomography (CT) or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan that was obtained within a few hours or days postonset of stroke. In some cases the radiology imaging report is not available, and information is obtained from a neurologist's summary of the CT/MRI scan(s). Some studies include participants who exhibit physical or behavioral signs of unilateral stroke (e.g., hemiparesis) even in the presence of a negative brain scan. Participants may be classified as having anterior versus posterior lesions (in relation to the central sulcus) based on the initial CT/MRI reports. In combination with behavioral data obtained from experimental language tasks or diagnostic tools, conclusions about localization of function may be made from those classifications.

While use of medical records is common in the screening process, the validity of this practice has not been directly addressed. This article draws attention to the potential problems with relying exclusively on medical records to characterize neurological lesions and make assumptions about brain-behavior relationships. Examples are provided from a study of individuals with right hemisphere stroke.

Data for the current discussion were obtained from 12 participants who were recruited for a study of language disorders associated with right hemisphere brain damage. They were included in the study after a review of medical records for each person indicated lesion(s) restricted to the right hemisphere (reports were based on CT and/or structural MRI scans). All participants were at least 1 year postonset of stroke. As part of the research study, a structural MRI scan was completed. Comparisons between the imaging reports from medical records and the recent MRI (see Table 1) indicate more, or more extensive, lesions in each of the 12 participants. Based on the criteria for the original language study (lesions due to stroke restricted to the right hemisphere), 6 of these 12 individuals (Participants 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, & 11) were subsequently excluded. Had the MRIs not been completed, language data from all 12 participants would have been analyzed as a group, thus potentially distorting the conclusions regarding right hemisphere language function.

There are various factors that may contribute to the discrepancies between the imaging reports, including the scanning method and protocol used, interrater reliability for reading CT/MRI scans, the effect of time, and neurological changes associated with normal aging. Each of these factors will be discussed. The focus of the ensuing discussion will be on neurological lesions due to stroke.

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Right Hemisphere(TM) Chooses NetSales to Provide Complete E-commerce Services...
Press release article from: PR Newswire August 26, 1999 700+ words
...NetSales, Inc., today announced that Right Hemisphere(TM) has chosen the company to provide...solution to enable online sales of Right Hemisphere's Deep Paint (TM), an authentic...online storefront for Deep Paint at Right Hemisphere's web site, http://www.righthemisphere...
Right Hemisphere Announces Official Development Plans for Intel Itanium...
Press release article from: Business Wire September 6, 2000 700+ words
...BUSINESS WIRE)--Sept. 6, 2000 Right Hemisphere(R) announces their intention...Lead Developer IA-64 Program, Right Hemisphere. "Intel works together with companies such as Right Hemisphere to bring industry-leading 3D...
Right Hemisphere Provides 3D Courseware Media Software for F-35 Joint Strike...
Press release article from: Business Wire April 12, 2004 700+ words
...BUSINESS WIRE)--April 12, 2004 Right Hemisphere Software Creates Engaging, Animated...35 JSF Aircraft Training Courseware Right Hemisphere(R), a leading provider of visual...understanding and immediate application. Right Hemisphere software will also give Northrop Grumman...
Right Hemisphere Unveils Viewpoint Media Integrator -VMI- At Game Developer...
Press release article from: Business Wire March 21, 2002 700+ words
...innovative graphics software, and Right Hemisphere, a leader in 3D graphics workflow...integrated part of the newest release of Right Hemisphere's format translation package Deep...assets. To view the specifications of Right Hemisphere's Deep Exploration, check out...
Right Hemisphere Unveils CATIA V5 Support for its Deep Server and Deep...
Press release article from: Business Wire April 26, 2004 700+ words
...Interactive Electronic Technical Manuals Right Hemisphere(R), a leading provider of visual...catpart and .catproduct formats. Right Hemisphere's new "CATIA Module" quickly transforms...quality marketing visualizations. Right Hemisphere's CATIA Module is available immediately...
PNY Technologies and Right Hemisphere Offer Free Trial Software for Publishing...
Press release article from: Business Wire July 26, 2004 700+ words
...Purchase PNY Technologies, Inc. and Right Hemisphere announced today that all current generation...equipped with free trial versions of Right Hemisphere's Deep Exploration(TM), Deep...Quadro by PNY Technologies hardware and Right Hemisphere software will be available in August...
Right Hemisphere Technology Used in Oscar-winning Film; Right Hemisphere Works...
Press release article from: PR Newswire April 29, 2002 700+ words
...AUCKLAND, New Zealand -- Right Hemisphere announced today that the award...visual effects category. Right Hemisphere worked with the artists at...Officer, Weta Digital, Ltd. "Right Hemisphere was pleased to be involved...
XyEnterprise and Right Hemisphere Partner to Serve CAD Graphics and Content...
Press release article from: Business Wire September 4, 2003 700+ words
...enterprise publishing solutions, and Right Hemisphere, the leading provider of Visual Information...management and workflow software and Right Hemisphere's Deep Server VIS technology. The...XyEnterprise. "Our partnership with Right Hemisphere combines the strengths of two best...
Right Hemisphere Launches Deep Publish for Microsoft Office Users.
Press release article from: Business Wire November 11, 2003 700+ words
...Microsoft Office Applications with Ease Right Hemisphere(R), a leading provider of Visual...Company in Fort Worth, Texas. "Right Hemisphere's Deep Publish software bridges...processes are simplified. And the free Right Hemisphere Deep View means we can send those...
Right Hemisphere to Deliver Interoperability Solutions Built on PTC's Granite...
Press release article from: PR Newswire February 26, 2002 700+ words
LOS ANGELES -- Right Hemisphere, a leader in 3D translation...product development software. Right Hemisphere has licensed Granite technology...PTC. "With partners like Right Hemisphere, PTC demonstrates its commitment...
For more facts and information, see all results

Source: HighBeam Research, On the use of medical records for characterizing brain...

©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA