AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Making career theories more culturally sensitive: implications for counseling.(Articles)

Career Development Quarterly

| September 01, 2007 | Young, Richard A.; Marshall, Sheila K.; Valach, Ladislav | COPYRIGHT 2007 National Career Development Association. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

The primary question addressed in this article is whether and how career theories can be more culturally sensitive without losing value as conceptual explanations or their usefulness for counselors. Contextual action theory is identified as a means to develop culturally sensitive explanations. Six steps are proposed and illustrated, including using the naive observations and subjective reports and recognizing ongoing processes. The use of these steps in counseling is also addressed.

**********

Counselors are faced with how to deal with clients' culturally based career issues within the defined space of particular social representations, daily practices, political ideologies, and legal systems. Many career theories have developed either without explicit attention to these particular spaces and contexts or by presuming that theories developed in one context are applicable to other contexts. Nevertheless, career theories have been applied in a variety of contexts. The primary question addressed in this article is whether career theories and explanations can be more culturally sensitive in order to reflect specific contexts. To address this question, we begin by describing a specific cultural context and issue, that is, the family as a locus of career development for Aboriginal youth in Canada who reside in cities (Marshall, Young, & Brokenleg, 2003). Later, we use it as a case illustration in developing culturally sensitive career theories.

Many Aboriginal youth (self-identified First Nations, Inuit, or Metis) who live in Canadian cities face particularly difficult situations represented by a high dropout rate among students, unemployment (Statistics Canada, 2002, 2003), family poverty (Statistics Canada, 2002), substance abuse, involvement with the justice system (Clatworthy & Mendelson, 1999), and other problems of urban youth generally. Many of these young people and their families contend with the effects of the residential school system in Canada (Assembly of First Nations, 1994; Bull, 1991; Haig Brown, 1988; Royal Commission on Aboriginal People, 1996). Among other practices, residential schools over several generations separated children from their parents and separated parents from the school (Haig Brown, 1988; Royal Commission on Aboriginal People, 1996). Compounded by a degree of embedded racism and physical and sexual abuse, the effect of the residential school system for many Aboriginal people in the current generation is a "disconnect" between parenting, schooling, and the process of becoming adults for young people (Kirkness & Bowman, 1992; Royal Commission on Aboriginal People, 1996). Although not all Aboriginal people attended residential schools and some experienced these schools positively, this disconnect has been further exacerbated for some Aboriginal children and youth attending schools that do not hold interest for them (Statistics Canada, 2003).

Although these issues do not reflect the cultural strengths of this community, they are issues faced by Aboriginal peoples in Canada and stand as an example of many localized, culturally specific concerns that challenge counselors. Can career development theories assist us as counselors in understanding and addressing these types of particular problems? If career theories and the interventions that flow from them are to be meaningful and used by counselors, they have to be able to reflect the complexity and specificity of cultural environments.

The broader issue of whether career theories can be more culturally sensitive arises in the context of increased cultural contact between peoples, the rise of multiculturalism within national groups, the growth of globalization as an economic and political force, and dissatisfaction with approaches to career development that do not explicitly address culture. In responding to the challenges counselors and researchers face in making career theories more culturally sensitive, we introduce the contextual explanation of career (Young, Valach, & Collin, 2002) as culturally responsive and propose six steps that emerge from this approach that can serve to make explanations and theories about career more culturally sensitive and relevant. Finally, we illustrate how these steps can be used in addressing the case described at the beginning of this article and suggest how counselors might apply these steps in their own counseling.

One might ask why career theories are important at all and whether they can be culturally sensitive. Under ideal conditions, they serve as a kind of organizing template for counselors. They are helpful because they reduce a complex range of behaviors to usable explanations, constructs, relationships, and, to some extent, predictions. In reality, however, the career theories that are used by counselors are often an amalgam of more formal theories and practical everyday explanations born from the application of personal experience-generated knowledge to the problems of clients' lives. These explanations are rooted in everyday thinking and reflect the daily lives of their clients. Some of these explanations are probably culturally sensitive, but few are culturally explicit. These tacit or "theories-at-hand" are heuristic explanations that are localized and particular and, to that extent, are useful to counselors. At the same time, however, counselors and clients may not have ready access to the explanations that guide their action, may be constrained by explanations that do not work well when translated to action, or may not be responsive in different cultural contexts. Nevertheless, understanding theory as a heuristic that both counselors and laypeople use in their everyday lives is a starting point for moving toward more culturally sensitive theories at the formal level. It is also important in reducing the theory--practice gap.

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
CULTURALLY SENSITIVE DVMT STRATEGIES CAN PROMOTE HUMAN RIGHTS.
News wire article from: AsiaPulse News November 18, 2008 700+ words
...individuals. The report endorses culturally sensitive approaches to development and to...are everybodys work, and being culturally sensitive and understanding the context is...Executive Director of UNFPA. Culturally sensitive approaches call for cultural fluencyfamiliarity...
Culturally sensitive instructional practices for African-American learners with...
Magazine article from: Exceptional Children Franklin, Mary E. October 1, 1992 700+ words
...six theoretical assumptions about culturally sensitive instructional practices. Second...relationship between affective, culturally sensitive instructional practices and high...assumptions undergird recommendations for culturally sensitive instructional practices. Assumption...
Using read-alouds with culturally sensitive children's books: a strategy that...
Magazine article from: Reading Improvement Morgan, Hani March 22, 2009 700+ words
...Gollnick and Chinn, 2006). Culturally sensitive children's books can also aid...use of read-alouds along with culturally sensitive children's books. This article...Children's Books Today, many culturally sensitive children's books are available...
Indigenous peoples and the MDGs: inclusive and culturally sensitive...
Magazine article from: UN Chronicle March 1, 2008 700+ words
...MDGs. Human rights-based and culturally sensitive approach. If the MDG targets are...peoples on the MDGs also requires a culturally sensitive approach, based on respect for...importance of a rights-based and culturally sensitive approach has been repeatedly emphasized...
Business should be culturally sensitive.
News wire article from: Asia Africa Intelligence Wire June 13, 2003 700+ words
...Dine laments, don't understand what it is to be culturally sensitive. They look for toolkits comprising 'do's and don...learn to do the right things, but that's not being culturally sensitive," he says. The right mannerisms don't make a person...
K-State Researchers Investigate Hispanic Health To Better Promote Culturally...
Press release article from: M2 Presswire January 29, 2009 700+ words
...Researchers Investigate Hispanic Health To Better Promote Culturally Sensitive Health Programs(C)1994-2009 M2 COMMUNICATIONS LTD...culture of the community. "Tailoring programs to be culturally sensitive is a more effective strategy instead of taking a program...
BIA tribal schools and the No Child Left Behind Act: an argument for a more...
Magazine article from: Journal of Gender, Race and Justice Lindeen, Jonathan M. December 22, 2005 700+ words
...American schoolchildren. (5) That danger calls for a culturally-sensitive implementation of NCLB in two interrelated ways: through...takes their unique circumstances into account. A more culturally-sensitive curriculum would provide a better starting point to set...
Culturally sensitive time for Disney.
Newspaper article from: South China Morning Post January 14, 2006 700+ words
...completely new. Ms Lam said the theme park, which opened four months ago, had been trying to reach out with a culturally sensitive message that it cares about Chinese holiday traditions. Special celebrations will include eye-dotting ceremonies...
Culturally sensitive dementia caregiving models and clinical practice.
Magazine article from: Adultspan Journal Daire, Andrew P. Mitcham-Smith, Michelle March 22, 2006 700+ words
...the caregivers' and care recipients' physical, mental, and emotional health. This article presents 3 key culturally sensitive caregiver models along with clinical interventions relevant far mental health counseling professionals...
Culturally sensitive counseling for Asian Americans/Pacific Islanders.(mental...
Magazine article from: Journal of Instructional Psychology Schoen, Alexis Ann September 1, 2005 700+ words
...of considerations for counselors dealing with Asian American/ Pacific Islander clients. In order to provide culturally sensitive counseling, counselors need to know and respect the traditional values of the particular ethnic group. Beyond...
For more facts and information, see all results

Source: HighBeam Research, Making career theories more culturally sensitive: implications for...

©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA