AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Capturing China in globalization: the dialectic of autonomy and dependency in Zhang Yimou's cinema.(Critical essay)

Texas Studies in Literature and Language

| September 22, 2007 | Li, David Leiwei | COPYRIGHT 2007 University of Texas at Austin (University of Texas Press). This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

In 1992 Zhang Yimou, doubtless China's best-known film director both domestically and abroad, released The Story of Qiu Ju (Qiuju da guansi), a dramatic feature about a peasant woman seeking justice for her injured husband. (1) Qiu Ju signals several significant departures from earlier works that bear Zhang's auteurist signature. The extravagant display of exotic colors and customs and the exuberant celebration of the repressed spirit yearning its rightful release that characterize Red Sorghum (Hong gaoliang, 1987), Ju Dou (1990), and Raise the Red Lantern (Dahong denglong gaogaogua, 1991) are remarkably absent in Qiu Ju. In their stead is a drab documentary look, which is both a deliberate withdrawal of a previous gaze at the mythical Chinese past and an insistent turn toward a contemporary China caught in the sharp relief of the rural and the urban. The film's break in Zhang's oeuvre appears even more striking given the retrospective vantage point we now occupy: the waning of a romantic overtone and the commitment to realism in Qiu Ju continue with such representative later films as To Live (Houzhe, 1994), a family saga of suffering and endurance, and Not One Less (1999), the tale of an adolescent girl fighting for public education. What could account for this sudden shift of aesthetics and ideology marked by The Story of Qiu Ju? What would such a critical account of textual rupture tell us both of Zhang's artistic practice and its social relevance against China's recent rise in world geopolitical economy and the world's domination by global capitalism? (2)

It is instructive to recall that the formal fissure in Zhang Yimou's cinematic corpus roughly parallels a watershed event in Chinese history, the 1989 Tiananmen Square massacre, when popular demand for democracy was quelled in cold blood. The first film to appear three years after the crackdown, Qiu Ju's quest of retribution for the wrongful wounding of her husband by the village party chief unmistakably functions as a somber political allegory of governance and justice. But this is no mere national allegory. The Chinese state's monopoly of violence, instead of being viewed as indigenous despotism or communist barbarity, must be apprehended along the end of the Cold War, China's opening to the world, as well as global capital's emerging reign over nation-states. The earth-shattering carnage in "the square of heavenly peace" (Tiananmen Square) appears an atrocious case of traumatic and truncated development that only ensures the smooth march of transnational corporations and China's entry into the world market. In this context, the film's allegorical ambivalence--the fact that The Story of Qiu Ju concludes without any clear narrative resolution as to which party is right--is telling of Zhang's own ambivalence about China's transition from socialism to capitalism and its changing conditions of ethical judgment. The confusion of justice that the director addresses, in other words, mediates a series of value competitions in the wake of global capitalism. The film's repetitive and insistent shuttling between the agrarian and industrializing modes of life spatializes the rivalry between "saving face" in a face-to-face village and the faceless abstraction of property rights in the global village. It also suggests a temporal conflict between the pledging of allegiance to an ascriptive, rooted, and territorially bounded form of sociality and the privileging of an acquisitive, mobile, and unencumbered form of individuality.

In this manner, Qiu Ju encapsulates both the tension central to the globalization of capital and culture and the creative contradiction within Zhang's extensive corpus. If the racy story of forbidden love and its transgression in the pre-Qiu Ju period corresponds with China's unprecedented opening up in the 1980s, with its ubiquitous "high culture fever" and "emancipation of the mind" (J. Wang), symptomatic texts of the post-Qiu Ju period engage the 1990s China when the culture of capitalism has more or less infiltrated its physical and psychic landscape. An aesthetic of self-possessive and affective individualism preoccupies the earlier period: the opposition to the totalitarian socialist state finds its metaphor in the revolt against tyrannical landlords while the appropriation of their women comes to justify the natural rise of capitalist enterprise. In contrast, a gloomy mise-en-scene and gritty texture tend to dominate the later productions, which question whether the free market is tantamount to a free society and whether the weak and the vulnerable can be logically written off the scale of justice. (3)

By seizing this critical disjuncture while reading his Red Sorghum and Happy Times (Xinfu shiguang, 2000) as exemplary text of each period, I will juxtapose Zhang's cinema with China's developmental trajectory to highlight that the director's dilemma about his nation's opening to global capitalism is very much the dilemma of our time. The liberalization of the Chinese economy and the revolution of Reagan and Thatcher are not just historical coincidences in different parts of the planet. Rather, they are expressive of an ascending cross-border consensus of culture after the end of the Cold War and the near disappearance of alternative political economies. If the persuasive power of this neoliberal common sense rests on its radical promise of individual sovereignty and ruthless denial of social necessity, the value of Zhang lies in his earnest and often ambivalent mediation of this cultural logic, sometimes through affirmation and assimilation while other times through questioning and opposition. Zhang's cinema is a clairvoyant capture of globalization in all its contradictions, and it is toward the auteur's split framing of liberty and community against a rapidly changing China that we now turn our critical eye.

1

Typical of the 5th Generation of film directors, Zhang's debut shares the intellectual tension of the mid-1980s China as it opens up to global capital. On the one hand, the movement expresses itself as a renewed desire for an enlightenment modernity reviving the May 4th legacy and its iconoclastic assault on precapitalist Chinese tradition. On the other hand, such passion for modernity is wedded to a national "search for roots," seeking to excavate some hitherto suppressed Chinese Zeitgeist (Lu, 1997, 107-08). This double movement of cultural reflection and national articulation against the landlocked past and toward an oceanic future is achieved in cinema through a salient stylization. (4) The spectacular capture of quaint color and landscape functions as much as the 5th Generation's inoffensive disavowal of communist rule and socialist realism as its deliberate pitch of aesthetic distinction to the international film market (X. Zhang, 1997, 205-06). For Dai Jinhua, "the novel film language" betrays "a biography of a generation's spiritual exile" (16). For Rey Chow, it is an instance of "primitive passion" at the moment of a "cultural crisis": when the traditional begins to converge with the modern, yet fails to achieve signification, a fantasy of common origin arises. The primitive as a figure for this "irretrievable common/place" thus becomes necessarily the "fabrication of a pre that occurs in the time of the post" (Chow, 22; original emphasis). Zhang Yimou's mythical agrarian, it seems, is an ethnographic self-invention that figures an Eastern tradition against a Western modernity.

But Zhang's 1980s is not an era of nineteenth-century colonialism. The founding of the People's Republic of China at once rejects capitalist modernity and carves a divergent path of socialist modernity. For Zhang to evoke the primitive is to negotiate a cultural crisis not of classical colonialism but contemporary neocolonialism under global capital. By emptying the immediate past of macabre socialism and harking back to a precapitalist China, Zhang's primitive reimagines a blank slate so that a current embrace of capitalism could be potentially conceived as teleological progress rather than historical regression. A story of "primitive passion," Red Sorghum is perhaps best appreciated in this context as a narration of "primitive accumulation." It is a film that ingeniously subsumes the pursuit of material interests in the tropes of sexual passion, at once mystifying the naked operation of power and mythologizing the legitimacy of possession. By transfiguring the historical difference between socialist and capitalist political economies into a timeless romantic rivalry, Red Sorghum becomes a successful article of imagistic and ideological persuasion that eventually valorizes a type of hero and favors a type of subjectivity supportive of capitalistic system.

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Becoming a part of life: an interview with Zhang Yimou. (Interview)
Magazine article from: Cineaste Sklar, Robert January 1, 1993 700+ words
...Beijing massacres. Zhang Yimou had been able to make...Chinese film authorities. Zhang Yimou's most recent film, The Story of Qiu Ju (1992), is thus also...he made The Story of Qiu Ju, Zhang Yimou's two previously banned...
Zhang Yimou: Busca la humano.(Primera Fila)
Newspaper article from: Reforma (México D.F., México) January 7, 2000 700+ words
...Sin embargo, el chino Zhang Yimou apenas muestra algn aprecio...guerra con la censura, Zhang Yimou se ha vuelto clebre con...91), La historia de Qiu Ju (92), Vivir (94...enero. Sobre esa cinta Zhang Yimou conversa va telefnica...
Zhang Yimou to Receive Art Directors Guild's Outstanding Contributions to...
Press release article from: Business Wire January 6, 2005 700+ words
LOS ANGELES -- Chinese filmmaker Zhang Yimou, director of this year's highly acclaimed "House of Flying...the 45th Venice International Film Festival for "The Story of Qiu Ju" (1992), the Grand Jury Prize at the 47th Cannes International...
Decade after last collaboration, Gong Li says director Zhang Yimou more polite.
News wire article from: The America's Intelligence Wire March 13, 2006 700+ words
...Byline: MIN LEE When Gong Li first worked with director Zhang Yimou, she was a little-known mainland Chinese actress. Now she...Raise the Red Lantern," "To Live," and "The Story of Qiu Ju," but the two haven't worked together since "Shanghai...
News Feature: SWORD SAGA: ULTIMATE AIM OF ANG LEE & ZHANG YIMOU.
News wire article from: Asia Africa Intelligence Wire February 9, 2003 700+ words
...Jakarta, Feb 9 (ANTARA) - They will be both 19 years old. Zhang Yimou in November and Ang Lee in October. Both are acclaimed filmmakers...Dou (1990), Raise the Red Lantern (1992), The Story of Qiu Ju (1992) and The Road Home (1999 in which he cast Zhang Ziyi...
Art directors decorate 'House' helmer Zhang.(Art Directors Guild presents award...
Magazine article from: Daily Variety McNary, Dave January 7, 2005 700+ words
HOLLYWOOD -- Chinese filmmaker Zhang Yimou ("House of Flying Daggers") has been tapped to receive the...the Berlin Film Festival. Other credits include "The Story of Qiu Ju," "Not One Less," "Happy Times," "The Road Home...
House' finds a home: Sony Pictures Classics reteams with Zhang.(Cannes Film...
Magazine article from: Daily Variety Rooney, David Dunkley, Cathy May 18, 2004 700+ words
...Sony Pictures Classics has picked up North American rights to Zhang Yimou's epic adventure "House of Flying Daggers." Set during...Bernard said. SPC previously released Zhang's "The Story of Qiu Ju," "Shanghai Triad," "Not One Less," "The Road Home...
The Story of Qiu Ju.
Magazine article from: Cineaste Sklar, Robert January 1, 1993 700+ words
...Chinese filmmaker Zhang Yimou faced the challenge...entirely. The Story of Qiu Ju is his audacious...child policy." Qiu Ju is portrayed by...in three earlier Zhang Yimou films, and her...peasant woman. What Qiu Ju wants, she says...cinematographer ...
Spielberg's offices play down reports of collaboration with Zhang Yimou.
News wire article from: The America's Intelligence Wire August 22, 2006 700+ words
...collaboration with famed Chinese director Zhang Yimou on a screen version of the classic Chinese...was quoted as saying last Monday that Zhang Yimou and Spielberg have expressed an interest...would be "Journey to the West." "Zhang Yimou and Spielberg are good friends...
Zhang Yimou says Gong Li, Zhang Ziyi both passionate about acting.
News wire article from: The America's Intelligence Wire November 19, 2006 700+ words
...with early in their careers, director Zhang Yimou said they were passionate about acting...Red Sorghum." Zhang Ziyi appeared in Zhang Yimou's "The Road Home," released in...Vice" and Zhang in "Rush Hour 2." Zhang Yimou recently reunited with Gong on "Curse...
For more facts and information, see all results

Source: HighBeam Research, Capturing China in globalization: the dialectic of autonomy and...

©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA