AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Emile Zola, the Cochonnerie of naturalist literature, and the Judensau.

Jewish Social Studies

| September 22, 2006 | Balakirsky-Katz, Maya | COPYRIGHT 2006 Indiana University Press. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

Abstract

Scholars often identify pig images of Emile Zola during the Dreyfus Affair as an overt anti-Jewish motif meant to discredit the Dreyfusard cause. I will trace how Zola was identified as a Jewish cultural infiltrator throughout his controversial literary career, not just in the aftermath of J'Accuse. Medieval symbols of antisemitism, specifically those related to the motif of the Judensau (Jew-pig), had been recruited into the service of anti-naturalism as early as 1868, and three decades later these same symbols were merely reappropriated to represent Zola's Dreyfusism. I will consider the medieval, antisemitic pictorial sources that are drawn upon for the massive visual degradation of Zola, first as naturalist author of novelistic obscenities in the 1880s and then as a treacherous Christian supporter of Alfred Dreyfus.

Keywords: Judensau, Emile Zola, Dreyfusard

**********

In the popular narrative of the Dreyfus Affair, Emile Zola (1840-1902) plays the French hero. Convinced that the Jewish army captain Alfred Dreyfus had been wrongly convicted of spying for the Germans, Zola pens the unprecedented J'Accuse (January 13, 1898), condemning the French government and military of a willful miscarriage of justice. The front-page publication of J'Accuse propels Zola into a leadership role in the pro-Dreyfus camp, or, as they come to be known, the Dreyfusard intellectuals. Zola's audacious article ultimately gave Dreyfus a second chance, and it ensured that Zola would be remembered not only as an art critic and writer but also as an "engaged intellectual," an activist whose ammunition was his celebrity status and public approval. As was so often the case with the men and women who banded together to proclaim the injustice of the Dreyfus case, Zola's reputation became a subject of public scrutiny and debate.

The interest in Zola's article for intellectual history is that it roused a collective spirit by assuming the right of a cultural figure to assert himself as an arbiter of national morality. The day after the publication of J'Accuse, signatures were already being collected in support of Zola's position. With this petition, branded the "Manifesto of the Intellectuals," the signatories began to count their strength in numbers. (1) In his memoirs, the passionate Dreyfusard and first Jewish prime minister of France, Leon Blum, mused that the formation of the Dreyfusards was the most historically significant of all the events of the affair. (2) Indeed, it is J'Accuse that France chooses to remember of the Dreyfus Affair. On the centennials of Dreyfus's first court martial and the publication of J'Accuse, France celebrated with articles, books, exhibits, sculptures, and memorial events that hailed Zola's letter as more intrinsically "French" than the system that had accused Dreyfus. (3) A large-format reproduction of J'Accuse was hung on the pillars of the National Assembly illuminated by blue, red, and white spotlights. In a speech delivered on the centennial of J'Accuse, President Jacques Chirac echoed Anatole France's famous eulogy of Zola: "Zola's text rests in our collective memory as 'a moment in the conscience of humanity.'" (4)

Scholars have been drawn to Zola's Dreyfusism in light of this twentieth-century historiography that has interpreted his defense of the Jewish army captain as the birth of the modern French intellectual. (5) Historians have pointed out that the notion of the "intellectuel" as opposed to Voltaire's "philosophe" or Victor Hugo's "lettre" is commonly "taken in the sense of the Dreyfus Affair" to such an extent that some scholars assert that the French term "intellectuel" cannot be used in any other context. (6) This account, which claims that the Dreyfus Affair produced the unique social category of the modern French intellectual, explains why the intellectual Left has been saddled with a pronounced Jewish identity. Certainly, the evidence of popular caricature at the turn of the century, which imagined both Jews and intellectuals as connected to profiteering, passivity, homosexuality, deviance, and disease, supports this view. In siding with a presumed Jewish traitor, the public defender would invariably be "Semitized." Indeed, following the publication of Zola's article, hundreds of school-boy ruffians did make the connection, shouting through the streets: "Death to Zola! Death to the Jews!" While intuitive, this explanation does not account for any earlier links between "Jew" and "intellectual," or the historical tenacity of this association. The equation of the Dreyfusard intellectual with "Jew" overindulges a singular political campaign and ignores the cultural dialogue that made the intellectual an oppositional figure well before the dramatic debut of a lone Jewish officer accused of espionage. (7)

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
The Dreyfus Affair: 'J'accuse' and Other Writings.
Magazine article from: The Historian Kale, Steven June 22, 1998 700+ words
...208. $32.50.) Emile Zola's involvement in the Dreyfus Affair began one-hundred years...Each successive degree of Zola's involvement in the Dreyfus Affair" (xiii). As presented here, Zola's most famous open letter...
Oscar Wilde and the Dreyfus affair.(Irish poet and dramatist role in freeing a...
Magazine article from: Victorian Studies Maguire, J. Robert September 22, 1997 700+ words
...accused of taking part on that side of the Dreyfus affair which was not popular in England [i...contact with both Oscar Wilde and Emile Zola in Paris at the high tide of the Dreyfus affair. A week after Zola's death at the end of September 1902...
The Dreyfus affair: one hundred years on.(Book review)
Magazine article from: Quadrant Anderson, Patricia July 1, 2006 700+ words
"BRAVO ZOLA", the eighteen-year...exemplary new publication The Dreyfus Affair must rank as the single...Aurore, which printed Zola's "J'Accuse!" Such...thwarted. The roots of the Dreyfus affair lay deep. Just as Germany...
France and the Dreyfus Affair: A Documentary History.(Review)
Magazine article from: Teaching History: A Journal of Methods Summers, Jerry L. March 22, 2000 700+ words
Michael Burns. France and the Dreyfus Affair: A Documentary History. New York...s documentary history of the Dreyfus affair provokes rumination about the anti...affaire Dreyfus, including Emile Zola, whose J'Accuse revealed the...
The Use of Abuse: The Polemics of the Dreyfus Affair and Its Aftermath.
Magazine article from: Journal of European Studies Cahm, Eric September 1, 1993 700+ words
...domain of written polemic. Even Zola's prose was in the end invaded...techniques of polemic during the Dreyfus Affair is therefore not so much a...and - on the other side - Zola, Peguy, and Laurent Tailhade...individual writers cover only Zola, Leon Bloy and Peguy: and...
French Intellectuals and Politics from the Dreyfus Affair To the...
Magazine article from: Reference & Research Book News November 1, 2005 700+ words
...French intellectuals and politics from the Dreyfus Affair to the Occupation. Drake, David. Palgrave...analysis of the public conflict between Emile Zola and Maurice Barres over the Dreyfus Affair. Other topics include the anti-war stance...
French Cultural Politics and Music: From the Dreyfus Affair to the First World...
Magazine article from: The Journal of Interdisciplinary History Berenson, Edward September 22, 2000 700+ words
French Cultural Politics and Music: From the Dreyfus Affair to the First World War. By Jane F. Fulcher (New York...support for the "Dreyfusard" music of Charpentier and Emile Zola's collaborator Alfred Bruneau and helped legitimize the...
Dreyfus Affair and the Crisis in French Masculinity.(Book review)
Magazine article from: Journal of Social History Quinlan, Sean M. June 22, 2008 700+ words
Dreyfus Affair and the Crisis in French Masculinity...xii plus 300 pp. $46.95). The Dreyfus Affair stands as one of those inaugural events...startling context, showing that the Dreyfus Affair encapsulated, in stunning ways...
Batter up.(Peter Lefcourt's book 'The Dreyfus Affair' may become a feature...
Magazine article from: The Advocate (The national gay & lesbian newsmagazine) Vaillancourt, Daniel August 18, 1998 700+ words
...s 1992 gay baseball romance, The Dreyfus Affair, is still selling like hotcakes...author Peter Lefcourt, referring to The Dreyfus Affair, his bitter sweet tale about two gay...summer's Dr. Dolittle--read The Dreyfus Affair and liked it so much, she persuaded...
The Dreyfus Affair: Honour and Politics in the Belle Epoch. (Reviews).
Magazine article from: Teaching History: A Journal of Methods Lowrie, Walter September 22, 2001 700+ words
Martin P. Johnson. The Dreyfus Affair: Honour and Politics in the...even a century later, the Dreyfus Affair continues to intrigue scholars...than a textbook summary. The Dreyfus Affair admirably meets the need for...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA