AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Conspicuous consumption: white abolitionism and English women's protest writing in the 1790s.

ELH

| June 22, 1994 | Coleman, Deirdre | COPYRIGHT 1994 Johns Hopkins University Press. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

In this paper I wish to examine two overlapping areas of middle-class polemic from the 1790s: white abolitionism and English women's protest writing. A certain polarization has crept into recent discussions of abolitionism, with

some critics arguing that a relatively benign "cultural racism" in the eighteenth century came to be supplanted by a more aggressive biological racism.(1) Patrick Brantlinger, for instance, characterizes late eighteenth-century abolitionist writing as more "positive" and "open-minded" about Africa and Africans than the racist and evolutionary accounts that were to follow in the wake of Victorian social science; in his view, the Victorians must bear responsibility for inventing the myth of Africa as the Dark Continent.(2) But while abolitionism may have taken its roots in philanthropy and a new-found enthusiasm for the universal rights of man, the many tracts it spawned contradict such a clear-cut distinction between the earlier and later periods. In its luridness and violence, late eighteenth-century anti-slavery rhetoric points directly, for instance, to the systematic colonization of Africa; it is also rich in the sorts of phobias and bogeys more commonly associated with the later nineteenth century, such as miscegenation, cannibalism, and an essentialist stereotyping of sex and race, such as the perception of white woman's sexuality as a form of degenerate black sexuality.

The close association of woman in this earlier period with slavery, luxury, sexual license, and violent cruelty intersects problematically with the second area of oppositional rhetoric I wish to examine: women's protest writing. In seeking to capitalize upon fashionable anti-slavery rhetoric for their own political objectives, women only increased the general murkiness of abolitionist rhetoric, an effect most evident in their employment of the emotive but cliched analogy between their own disenfranchised lot and the plight of enslaved Africans. While these late eighteenth century women both anticipate and confirm Frederick Douglass's claim, in mid nineteenth-century America, that "the cause of the slave has been peculiarly woman's cause," their writings also reveal clearly why any political link between white women and black people was doomed to be a bitter misalliance.(3) As bell hooks has argued, in an essay on the history of racism and feminism in America, the analogy between white women and blacks is a deeply conservative one, concerned to uphold and maintain the racial hierarchy that grants white women a higher status than black people.(4)

My first text is a lecture Coleridge delivered in Bristol in 1795, advertised in the Bristol Mercury as "A Lecture on the Slave Trade, and the duties that result from its continuance."(5) Although the fight for abolition of the trade had not yet been decisively lost, the impetus had slowed markedly from the heyday of protest in the period 1789-1792. That heyday is probably best illustrated by the immense popularity and circulation of Wedgwood's design of the manacled and supplicating slave, doubly captured by chains and by discourse, with the ventriloquized Christian motto floating above his head: "Am I not a man and a brother". Janus-faced, the motto stands curiously open to a positive or negative response, a reflection perhaps of the white racist spectre that often underlies sentimental ideals of equality between white and black: the spectre of too close a blood kinship, the term "brother" reading literally rather than figuratively in a nightmare confusion of the races through interracial sexy Nevertheless, thousands of seals and cameos with this design were sold or given away gratis; women wore it as pins in their hair, men sported the design on rings, on shirt-pins, or coat-buttons.

The waning of enthusiasm in the mid 1790s was principally caused by the reactionary climate of suspicion and fear generated by the Pitt government. By the time Coleridge made his somewhat belated contribution, abolitionism had begun to lose its respectability, and in some quarters, was even associated with jacobinism. In a daring jest at the end of his lecture, Coleridge flirts with that association between anti-slavery and revolutionism by enjoying, rhetorically, the dangers of the pro-slavers' too easy identification of England's labouring poor with the West Indian slaves. Although he does not mention the recent and bloody revolts on Santo Domingo and other West Indian islands, they clearly form the back-drop to his joking:

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Carribean Sanctuary: West Indian antiques and island elegance enliven the St....
Magazine article from: House Beautiful Micucci, Dana July 1, 2003 700+ words
...connoisseur, collector, and dealer in West Indian antiques and fine art, succumbed to...showcase for Connors's collection of West Indian antiques. "I bought most of these...mahogany and thibet, and the whimsical West Indian interpretation of English, French...
West Indian Carnival 2003: one of U.S's biggest parades attracts millions to...
Magazine article from: Ebony Williams, Margaret September 1, 2003 700+ words
...States. Most of the celebrants in the West Indian American Day Carnival are West Indians...Introduced in Harlem in 1947, the West Indian Day carnival idea shifted with the shifting...joyous opportunity for West Indians and West Indian descendants from America and the islands...
`Negro' was a misnomer, `West Indian' still is
Newspaper article from: New York Amsterdam News Yusef Salaam August 20, 1994 700+ words
...1994 `Negro' was a misnomer, `West Indian' still is. When the editor got on...not an Indian, not a so-called West Indian. Of course, Noel knows that he is...him to get away from calling himself West Indian. All of his education, his childhood...
Flycell Launches Landmark Music Initiative by Reaching Unique Agreement with...
Press release article from: Business Wire August 21, 2007 700+ words
...Music and Text Products Available to West Indian Girl Fans NEW YORK & LOS ANGELES...and Los Angeles-based rock outfit West Indian Girl that provides for the unique promotion of West Indian Girl's sophomore album 4th &...
The Shaping of the West Indian Church, 1492-1962.
Magazine article from: Church History Saillant, John June 1, 2001 700+ words
The Shaping of the West Indian Church, 1492-1962. By Arthur...Christian impulse has driven the West Indian Church from the earliest European...the mid-twentieth century. "West Indian" means, it is important to note...
Black Identities: West Indian Immigrant Dreams and American Realities.(Review)...
Social Forces ZHOU, MIN June 1, 2001 700+ words
...tells an extraordinary story of how West Indian immigrants and their children find themselves...answers three important questions: How West Indian immigrants find their way in America...the Caribbean region. She argues that West Indian immigrants arrive in the U.S. "with...
A Transnational Sense of "Home": Twentieth-Century West Indian Immigration and...
Magazine article from: Afro - Americans in New York Life and History Lightfoot, Natasha July 1, 2009 700+ words
...institutions has been extremely valuable to West Indian settlement in New York City. Such institutions...identity built from encounters with West Indian migrants from different islands...given moments within the narrative of West Indian immigrants' progress in New York City...
Latest VC Winner to Remember West Indian War Heroes.
Press release article from: PR Newswire Europe May 16, 2006 700+ words
...It is estimated that over 10,000 West Indian men and women served throughout the...contribution and sacrifices made by the West Indian Community. On 21 May 2006, the achievements of all West Indian service personnel during the two world...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA