AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

The (im)possibilities of clinical democracy.

Health Sociology Review

| December 01, 2006 | Long, Debbie; Forsyth, Rowena; Iedema, Rick; Carroll, Katherine | COPYRIGHT 2006 eContent Management Pty Ltd. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

ABSTRACT

In this article, we argue that homogenising discussions of medical dominance on the meta-level of professions do not fully capture the complexity that characterises current clinical care in multidisciplinary health care teams. We illustrate this through an empirical study of a multidisciplinary team attempting to enact their work in a clinically democratic way. The challenges that arose in putting this into practice highlight the depth and complexity of enculturated medical dominance in Australian hospital practice. Our study shows that effective facilitation of clinician reflexivity has the potential to challenge and change deeply embedded structures and behaviours.

KEY WORDS

Medical dominance, clinical democracy, sociology, hospital ethnography, multidisciplinary clinical team, reflexivity

Introduction

The idea that all health care professionals--medical, nursing and allied health--could be respected for their specific area of professional expertise and have equal voice in care-management decisions according to that expertise, remains, for most health care workers, an impossible dream. Medical dominance, as relevant in Australia in 2006 as it was when first described by Willis (1983) over two decades ago, works against multi-vocality in decision making within multidisciplinary clinical teams. The challenges to implementing clinically democratic modes of decision making appear to be no less complex and multifaceted now than they were twenty years ago.

Willis' original medical dominance thesis (1983, 1989) belongs to a body of work that regards the medical profession as mobilising selected means to restrict and exclude other professions from gaining legitimacy in the field of health care (Freidson 1970; Illich 1976; Larson 1977). Willis' historical analysis of medicine's professional relationship with neighbouring professions highlighted three specific modes of domination: subordination, which ensures other professionals conduct their work under direct control from doctors; limitation, which restricts other professionals' access to important institutions; and exclusion, in which formal licensing processes deny official legitimacy. Since the book's appearance in 1983, analyses of medicine and its relationships with other professions and the state have appeared that have illustrated tendencies away from medical dominance, including proletarianisation (McKinlay and Stoekle 1988; White 2000), deprofessionalisation (Haug 1973), and a loss of public trust (Daniel 1994). More recently still, shifts in interprofessional boundaries (Freidson 1994), arising from the contemporary 'climate of workforce change' (Nancarrow and Borthwick 2005:914), have been interpreted as important challenges to medicine's original means of control (Nancarrow and Borthwick 2005).

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Collaborative health care teams in Canada and the USA: confronting the...
Magazine article from: Health Sociology Review Bourgeault, Ivy Lynn Mulvale, Gillian December 1, 2006 700+ words
...Sociology, collaborative health care teams, medical dominance, structural embeddedness, primary care, mental health care, Canada, United States...the US. Collaborative health care teams and medical dominance There are numerous definitions...
Medical dominance in a changing world: the UK case.
Magazine article from: Health Sociology Review Allsop, Judith December 1, 2006 700+ words
...Division of Labour in Australian Health Care (1983) makes the case for medical dominance in the health care division of labour but also...in the past, underpinned medical dominance. From 1948 until the health care reforms of the 1990s, doctors...
Introduction: taking stock of medical dominance.
Magazine article from: Health Sociology Review Willis, Evan December 1, 2006 700+ words
...of other health care professionals. KEY WORDS Medical dominance, sociology...the book, Medical Dominance (1983...Labour in Health Care. Supervised...of other health care professionals...age' of medical dominance arguably...
Disciplining the medical profession? Implications of patient choice for medical...
Magazine article from: Health Sociology Review Dent, Mike December 1, 2006 700+ words
...implications for the medical dominance of physicians...choice central to health care organisation...Regulation of Health Care Professions...Commission for Health Care Excellence...choice' for medical dominance, the paper...
Medical dominance then and now: critical reflections.
Magazine article from: Health Sociology Review Coburn, David December 1, 2006 700+ words
...central because health care was the focus...salience of medical dominance within sociology...s notion of medical dominance and/or criticized...professional power and medical dominance. If medicine...and related health care occupations...
Birth and the `reflexive consumer': trust, risk and medical dominance in...
Magazine article from: Journal of Sociology Zadoroznyj, Maria August 1, 2001 700+ words
...For some decades now, the so-called `consumer' movement in health care has grown in Australia and overseas and become increasingly significant in a range of areas of health care provision including obstetrics (Bastian, 1991; Consumers...
"Men's bodies, men's selves": men's health self-help books and the promotion of...
Magazine article from: International Journal of Men's Health Singleton, Andrew January 1, 2003 700+ words
...of limited use for health-care strategies aimed at...self-help books, health-care strategies, individualism...in the face of male medical dominance. Beginning in the...been established by health-care providers. At this...
Beyond decline: consumerism, managerialism and the need for a new medical...
Magazine article from: Health Sociology Review Tousijn, Willem December 1, 2006 700+ words
...ABSTRACT In the health care occupational...professionalism and medical dominance. This article...internal to the health care system, such...managerialism, medical dominance, professionalism...employment in the health care sector during...
Emerging from the shadow of medicine: allied health as a 'profession community'...
Magazine article from: Health Sociology Review Boyce, Rosalie December 1, 2006 700+ words
...inevitable consequence of medical dominance and calls for a re...health professions, medical dominance, subculture, hospital...International trends in health care reform show that industrialised...restructure the nature of health care. A major focus of...
Critical Perspectives on Health, 2d ed.(Book review)
Magazine article from: Health Sociology Review Gau, Meei-Ling April 1, 2006 700+ words
...position of doctors in health care systems, outlining...services, such as medical dominance and perceptions of...society and within the health care system, and discusses...issues of gender and medical dominance as well as important...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA