AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Medical dominance in a changing world: the UK case.

Health Sociology Review

| December 01, 2006 | Allsop, Judith | COPYRIGHT 2006 eContent Management Pty Ltd. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

ABSTRACT

This paper examines the governance of the medical profession in the U.K. As in many other countries, external and internal pressures have brought a shift in relations between the state and medicine. The context in which doctors practise has undergone radical change. In common with many countries, the U.K. has turned to competitive markets, and state-sponsored regulatory measures to boost performance. As a consequence, state domination of the health policy agenda has increased replacing a corporatist politics and doctors' individual clinical autonomy has been reduced. Moreover, the existing system of self-governance is in question. It is argued that, nevertheless, there is evidence of different forms of accommodation. The medical profession continues to control a valued knowledge base, retains its social standing and is able to reap economic rewards. A more plural form of medical leadership may emerge better suited to assuring quality in patient care.

KEY WORDS

Sociology, medical dominance, regulation of doctors, medical governance, quality assurance, poor performance

Introduction

Willis' book Medical Dominance: The Division of Labour in Australian Health Care (1983) makes the case for medical dominance in the health care division of labour but also suggests that medical dominance is dependent on a historical process of production and reproduction and is subject to contestation and limitation. This paper explores two areas of contestation in the British national health service (NHS) in order to assess the ways in which recent policy has limited medical dominance: namely, the governance of medical work within the national health service and current proposals to reform the institutions of medical self-governance. (1) In relation to the former, over the last fifteen years there has been a significant shift in state/professional relations with new forms of bureaucratic control over doctors within the NHS. The Department of Health and local level managers as representatives of state interests, now curtail clinical autonomy in decision making in the pursuit of cost containment. These developments have been theorized in different ways and there is disagreement about the extent to which changes reflect a decline of medical dominance or simply a different form of accommodation between an increasingly regulatory state and the medical profession (for example, Hunter 2006; Moran 2002; McKinlay and Arches 2002).

Second, there are now proposals out for consultation that will, if implemented, change significantly the system of professional self-governance through the General Medical Council (GMC), currently an elected, membership body, and traditionally, a professional preserve. Over the past decade, criticisms of the GMC and the pressure for reform from government and the public have gathered pace in the face of a series of more or less well-publicized cases of poor performance by doctors and a failure of the GMC to reform itself. The proposals (DH 2006) recommend an appointed rather than an elected Council, the assessment of all doctors periodically for formal revalidation and an independent tribunal for the final stage of the disciplinary process. The paper concentrates on the build up to these proposals as they were released after the paper was submitted. If implemented as they stand, and there is likely to be a period of intense political lobbying by the profession, these changes will mark a symbolic shift in medical dominance as it has been traditionally perceived.

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
"Men's bodies, men's selves": men's health self-help books and the promotion of...
Magazine article from: International Journal of Men's Health Singleton, Andrew January 1, 2003 700+ words
...of limited use for health-care strategies aimed at...self-help books, health-care strategies, individualism...in the face of male medical dominance. Beginning in the...been established by health-care providers. At this...
Health Care Injects $18.3 Billion Annually into Middle Tennessee Economy;...
Press release article from: Business Wire February 15, 2006 700+ words
...NASHVILLE, Tenn. -- Nashville's health care industry has a total economic impact...154,800 jobs can be attributed to health care, 22 percent of the region's non...study released today by the Nashville Health Care Council (NHCC). Over the past 10...
Health Care Innovation Can Make Us Far Healthier Says Institute for Alternative...
Newspaper article from: U.S. Newswire July 24, 1995 700+ words
...July 24 /U.S. Newswire/ -- Will health care reform stifle or help health care innovation? Can health enhancing innovations...There is great uncertainty about the future of health care innovation -- those important activities...
Health care for all: a Catholic perspective.
Magazine article from: Commonweal Hehir, J. Bryan May 7, 1993 700+ words
...administration's Task Force on National Health Care is scheduled to submit its report to the...of a new phase of the national debate on health care. The U.S. argument about health care reaches back to the early 1970s, but the...
Health care may not be the worst of GM worries.
Newspaper article from: Detroit Free Press (Detroit, Michigan) (via Knight-Ridder/Tribune Business News) April 30, 2005 700+ words
Apr. 30--Health care, health care, health care. For a company in the business of making and selling cars and trucks -- more of them than any other automaker in the world -- General Motors Corp. spends a lot of time talking about rising...
Health care 'gangbusters' seek reform. (health care reform)
Magazine article from: National Underwriter Property & Casualty-Risk & Benefits Management Fisher, Mary Jane December 28, 1992 700+ words
WASHINGTON - Change is coming in health care delivery, insurance coverage and the...it may happen in 1993, according to health care policy analysts, legislators and observers...the words of one industry lobbyist, health care reformers are going to be going like...
Health care resource prioritization and rationing: why is it so difficult?
Magazine article from: Social Research Brock, Dan W. March 22, 2007 700+ words
THE PRIORITIZATION OF HEALTH CARE RESOURCES AND RATIONING IS A paradigm...idea of prioritizing and rationing health care resources so troubling and controversial...ambivalent and inconsistent about health care rationing. On the one hand many...
Health Care In New Jersey Ranked Among The Nation's Worst.
Press release article from: Business Wire January 14, 2003 700+ words
...Ranking in 2000, Costs Continue to Rise New Jersey Health Care Quality Institute Launches Campaign -- Goal of Improving Health Care Delivery Ranking by 2005 The quality of New Jersey's health care delivery system continues to rank among the worst...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA