AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.
Create a link to this page
Copy and paste this link tag into your Web page or blog:
Non-compete agreements with step-down provisions: will courts in "blue-pencil" states enforce them?
Both parties should be encouraged to talk to an attorney before signing an employment contract containing a covenant not to compete. If the covenant has a step-down provision providing alternative time and area restrictions, a cautious attorney's advice must be equivocal. Under current law in many states, a court may cross out overbroad, unreasonable provisions in the agreement, while keeping in place less onerous provisions. There is no definitive test to determine which provisions are enforceable. Indeed, a court could find the entire covenant void. Public policy favors definite contract obligations.
This article discusses the use of non-compete step-down provisions in the employer/employee context. A federal district court in Arizona recently upheld the enforceability of a "carefully crafted" step-down provision. (1)
What Do Step-Down Provisions Look Like?
A hypothetical step-down provision might provide:
1. NONCOMPETITION. For the TIME PERIOD set forth in paragraph 2, Employee shall not, directly or indirectly, own, manage, operate, participate in or finance any business venture that competes with the Company within the AREA, set forth in paragraph 3.
2. TIME PERIOD. TIME PERIOD for purposes of paragraph 1 shall mean the period beginning as of the date of Employee's employment with the Company and ending on the date of death of the employee; provided, however, that if a court determines that such period is unenforceable, TIME PERIOD shall end five (5) years after the date of termination; provided, however, that if a court determines that such period is unenforceable, TIME PERIOD shall end six (6) months after the date of termination.
3. AREA. AREA for purposes of paragraph 1 shall mean: the planet Earth; provided, however, if a court determines such a geographic scope is unenforceable, AREA shall mean the United States; provided, however, if a court determines such a geographic scope is unenforceable, AREA shall mean the City of Tucson. (2)
- Use of non-solicitation, non-compete agreements.(Book review)
- Newspaper article from: Hospice Management Advisor May 1, 2006 700+ words
...providers have also utilized non-compete agreements. These agreements may, for example...geographic area for a specified period of time. Or they may prohibit...recognize that the terms of non-compete agreements must be reasonable. What is reasonable...
- LegalEase: Use of non-solicitation, non-compete agreements.
- Newspaper article from: Hospital Home Health April 1, 2006 700+ words
...providers have also utilized non-compete agreements. These agreements may, for example...geographic area for a specified period of time. Or they may prohibit...recognize that the terms of non-compete agreements must be reasonable. What is reasonable...
- Non-Compete Agreements Need A Local Focus, Even For Global Employers.
- News wire article from: Mondaq Business Briefing December 12, 2007 700+ words
...relationship. Employers often rely on non-compete agreements to protect their interests and prevent...governing the enforceability of non-compete agreements differ-often drastically- from...evaluating the validity of non-compete agreements, the way those factors are analyzed...
- Non-compete agreements are not ironclad.
- Newspaper article from: San Antonio Express-News (San Antonio, TX) November 21, 2005 700+ words
...competition by making employees sign non-compete agreements. But, as one recent Texas court...viewed as acceptable in court. Non-compete agreements limit an employee from using one...49 percent of employers use non-compete agreements, according to a 2005 survey by the...
- As non-compete agreements spread, resistance builds.
- Newspaper article from: Chicago Tribune (Chicago, IL) July 25, 2004 700+ words
...dim view of non-compete agreements that restrict labor...widespread non-compete agreements have become. The...did business for a period of three years after...found that non-compete agreements are legitimate business...
- Litigation over non-compete agreements on the rise.
- Newspaper article from: Lawyers USA Hsieh, Sylvia June 12, 2009 700+ words
...employers and former employees over non-compete agreements and other forms of restrictive covenants...dramatically stepped up their use of non-compete agreements to limit what a departing employee...practice groups dedicated to non-compete agreements. "Ten years ago this was only a...
- Non-compete agreements required with more jobs.(Brief Article)
- Magazine article from: St. Louis Business Journal KORNBLUM, RACHAEL July 24, 2000 700+ words
Non-compete agreements once were found mainly in contracts...being asked to sign, non-compete agreements. The concern is that-they...person doesn't think (non-compete agreements) are enforceable, so they...
- Non-compete agreements have no place in healthcare.(Controversies in Nephrology...
- Magazine article from: Nephrology Nursing Journal Rabetoy, Gary September 1, 2005 700+ words
...that do not involve unnecessary non-compete agreements. Non-Compete Agreements Are Discouraged The AMA's Council of...Judicial Affairs officially discourages non-compete agreements. The American Bar Association's code...
- AN ALTERNATIVE TO NON-COMPETE AGREEMENTS.
- Magazine article from: Orlando Business Journal Shipley, C. Gene September 29, 2000 700+ words
...employees didn't violate their Non-Compete Agreements. In reality, your defecting superstars...faced with claims for breach of non-compete agreements. The current statute, Section 542...requirements for enforcing non-compete agreements: (1) the contract must be a signed...
- Covenant not to compete agreements: are they a necessary evil?(Controversies in...
- Magazine article from: Nephrology Nursing Journal Foster, Mary Rau September 1, 2005 700+ words
...have used non-compete agreements as a tool to...a specified period of time (i...Benefits From Non-Compete Agreements and What Are...Impact Does Non-Compete Agreements Have Upon Staff...some lengthy period of time, the...