AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

"The last to see them alive": panopticism, The supervisory gaze, and catharsis in Capote's In Cold Blood.

Studies in the Novel

| December 22, 2005 | Hickman, Trenton | COPYRIGHT 2005 University of North Texas. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

George Plimpton's Truman Capote (1997), a self-proclaimed "oral biography," revisits Capote's In Cold Blood and the author's often flamboyant interaction with the individuals from whom he gleaned the details necessary for his famous "nonfiction novel." One of the more vivid anecdotes in Plimpton's book comes from Harold Nye, a Kansas Bureau of Investigation officer whom Capote interviewed, who recounts a night on the town with the author:

    My wife is a very strict individual,  straight as an arrow. One time    in Kansas City, Truman asked us if we  wanted to go out for the    evening. Sure, you don't turn him down.  First, we get a cab, and    just off the main street ... he pays a  hundred bucks to get us into    a place above a gallery to watch  what's going on in a lesbian bar.    Now, here is what it was: they  were eating, tables, dancing,    probably a hundred people in there,  female couples doing their    thing. This was horrible to my wife. She  tried to turn away from    it, but she didn't say anything to  Truman. We leave and he takes us    over to a male gay bar. We sit down  and order a drink, and it    isn't three minutes until some of  these young bucks nail him,    talking to him, playing with his ears,  just right in front of my    wife. But how the hell do you say anything  to a man as famous as    Truman Capote that you don't like what  he's doing. We finally  

tried to excuse ourselves and leave. But Truman gets us to go on to the Jewel Box, a little theatre, and, you know, I expect there must have been thirty female impersonators in there ... and they're damn good. I mean, they looked as good as any beautiful babes in New York. But at the end of these little skits they revealed that

they were males. Now, to take this lady-and Truman knew what kind

of lady she was, because he had been to my house-and subject her to this ... Well, his stock went down from sixty per cent down to about ten. (170-71) (1)

Most striking in this passage is the way in which Nye's account reveals the degree to which Capote values watching others witness a series of spectacles that he has specifically orchestrated for their shock. The jaw-dropping of the Kansans (who, despite averted eyes, gather a large amount of detail from the experience) provides a certain pleasure for Capote, and I contend that his choreography of this incident reflects a similar strategy in In Cold Blood. In the novel, Capote stages his story as he staged an evening for his Kansas guests, containing his characters within specific boundaries not only determined by the "history" of the actual Holcomb murders but by Capote's own desires for drama and scandal. Once contained in a novelistic structure reminiscent of Foucault's reiteration of Bentham's panopticon, Capote's characters are forced into a spectacle that offers readers of the book vicarious participation in the slaughter of an entire family from Kansas. In Capote's view, this strategy offers not only an angle into the criminal mind but a catharsis for an audience that can vent its own destructive energies through interaction with his novel rather than through violent action in the community. Understanding Capote's narrative strategy also identifies what may well be Capote's real contribution to the "nonfiction novel": the panopticon as template for fictionalizing nonfiction events in a novel.

Panopticism in Capote's In Cold Blood

When critical assessments of In Cold Blood appeared in 1966, reviews of the work varied widely. Whether these reviews were positive or negative, however, most failed to perceive Capote's spectacle as anything but what New York Times writer Conrad Knickerbocker called "a total evocation of reality" (37), debating instead the text's proper genre. Nor were initial reviewers unduly troubled by Capote's lingering, supervisory presence; indeed, Knickerbocker asserted, "[n]ot the least of the book's merits is that it manages a major moral judgment without the author's appearance once on stage" (37). Eliot Fremont-Smith felt that Capote's transmission of the story was equally "real" and transparent in its structure and motives:

    Part of  Capote's equipment is his carefully trained memory: he    took no  notes while interviewing, and nothing was taped; instead,    he  listened, and thereby won extraordinarily candid accounts. When  "In Cold Blood" was published last fall in four installments  in The    New Yorker, it was preceded by an "Editor's Note:  All quotations in    this article are taken either from official records  or from    conversations, transcribed verbatim, between the author and  the    principals." (Transcribed verbatim in his head, that is.)  (23) 

Part of the reason critics accepted that Capote had merely recorded and represented "the facts" was Capote's own tireless promotion of the novel's merits in this regard. One reviewer suspected that Capote himself might have choreographed the outpouring of positive assessments:

    The Svengali primarily responsible for this publishing  phenomenon    is a short, blond, rather flamboyant former employee of  The New    Yorker magazine. His name is Truman Capote.... This is not to  say    that Mr. Capote went around saying: "Be on the lookout, I am  writing a great book." He didn't. But his discussions of the  material that was to become the book had the effect of pebbles  

falling in a pool. ...
Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
That double meaning of "In Cold Blood".(Capote)(Movie review)
Magazine article from: The Gay & Lesbian Review Worldwide Capozzola, Christopher March 1, 2006 700+ words
...fiction novel" In Cold Blood, Truman Capote tried to see the world...stories that became In Cold Blood. Capote forged a bond of vulnerability...chronicler. In one scene, Capote reads an early draft of In Cold Blood to a rapt Manhattan audience...
Hoffman transforms to play `In Cold Blood' author Capote.
News wire article from: The America's Intelligence Wire September 30, 2005 700+ words
...crime classic "In Cold Blood." Hoffman wondered...in the title role of "Capote," impersonating the...most agonizing period of Capote's life, as he spent...years researching "In Cold Blood," a nonfiction novel...farm family in Kansas. Capote, previously known best...
Remembering Truman Capote and the making of `In Cold Blood'.
News wire article from: Kansas City Star September 30, 2005 700+ words
...Actually, the film "Capote" is one of two new...about the time Truman Capote spent in western Kansas...researching his book "In Cold Blood." It stars Philip...facts movie). Capote, in fact, called "In Cold Blood" a "nonfiction novel...
More human than Truman: infamous reassembles the gay love story between the...
Magazine article from: The Advocate (The national gay & lesbian newsmagazine) Cho, Alexander October 24, 2006 700+ words
...What happened to Truman Capote after In Cold Blood? If you look at his...titled A Visit With Truman Capote and now known as With...documentary was made just as In Cold Blood was beginning to take the world by storm. Capote is at his home on New...
Capote redux: Second film examines "In Cold Blood".
News wire article from: Seattle Times (Seattle, WA) Macdonald, Moira October 8, 2006 700+ words
...for another Capote movie: "Capote," written by Dan Futterman...dealing with the period of Capote's life in which he wrote "In Cold Blood," about the murder of a Kansas family and its aftermath. "Capote," directed by Bennett Miller...
Capote redux: another film examines `In Cold Blood'.
News wire article from: Seattle Times (Seattle, WA) Macdonald, Moira October 12, 2006 700+ words
...for another Capote movie: "Capote," written by Dan Futterman...dealing with the period of Capote's life in which he wrote "In Cold Blood," about the murder of a Kansas family and its aftermath. "Capote," directed by Bennett Miller...
A chilling 'Capote,' caught in cold blood.(FEATURES)(WEEKEND)
Newspaper article from: The Christian Science Monitor September 30, 2005 700+ words
...astonishing new movie "Capote," the diminutive...in progress, "In Cold Blood," and intones...betrayals that accompany Capote's ache for literary...necessary to create "In Cold Blood." This is why "Capote" is such an unsettlingly...
Capote, Truman. In Cold Blood.(CDs and cassettes)(Brief article)(Audiobook...
Magazine article from: Library Journal Adams, Michael October 15, 2006 700+ words
Capote, Truman. In Cold Blood. 9 cassettes. unabridged...3092-0. $99. CRIME Capote's account of brutal...subjects, thanks to the film Capote, adds a layer of irony...become commonplace, In Cold Blood has not lost its power...
Sales of In Cold Blood Increase as Capote biopic is released.(Truman...
Newspaper article from: M2 Best Books October 27, 2005 700+ words
...US movie theatres of a biopic detailing Truman Capote's writing of his novel In Cold Blood are already having a positive impact on sales...based on Gerald Clarke's 1986 biography of Capote. This is also seeing an increase in sales...
Capote, Truman. In cold blood.(Brief article)(Audiobook review)
Magazine article from: Kliatt Levitov, Francine July 1, 2006 700+ words
CAPOTE, Truman. In cold blood. Read by Scott Brick. 12 cds. 14...new standard for true crime writing. Capote managed to gain not only the cooperation...lives of one of its finest families. Capote neither excuses the murderers nor judges...
For more facts and information, see all results

Source: HighBeam Research, "The last to see them alive": panopticism, The supervisory gaze, and...

©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA