AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Society in self, self in society: survival in The Wings of the Dove.

Texas Studies in Literature and Language

| March 22, 2005 | Wakana, Maya Higashi | COPYRIGHT 2005 University of Texas at Austin (University of Texas Press). This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

In the past, criticisms lauding or condemning Milly Theale, Kate Croy, Merton Densher, and Maud Lowder, or any combination of these characters in James's The Wings of the Dove (1902), generally assume that if one or several of these characters is or are the victimized, the others are the victimizers. The most common of interpretations claiming Milly's "innocence," for example, condemn Kate, Densher, and Maud Lowder of duplicity and mercenary intent, describing them, for example, as "admirable villains" (Syndy McMillen Conger).

However, Susan Mizruchi, who sees Milly "cultivat[ing]" (234) her illness, Julie Olin-Ammentorp, who sees Milly's final bequest to Densher as "profoundly manipulative" (50), and Sharon Cameron, who contends that Milly "performs the novel's ultimate manipulation" (124), are among those who detect definite signs of intent on Milly's part and complicate, if not reverse, the view that Milly is merely the unconsciously innocent victim.

Adeline R. Tintner's framing of James's text as his "very free redoing" (125) of Milton's twin epics casts Kate in the role of seductress who contributes to the fall and education of Densher. Milton Kornfeld (346) and Leo Bersani (142-43) essentially agree with this general position when they refer to Densher as redeemed villain. In this way, demonizing Kate resurrects Densher, who, more often than not, is then cast in the role of hero.

Sallie Sears, however, labels Densher "a prig" (93), and Brenda Austin-Smith insightfully detects the language employed by Aunt Maud and Densher in Volume Two as contributing to the gradual "reification" of Milly, only to dehumanize and discredit her as legitimate player, consequently demonizing Kate as well. As Kristin King notes in agreement, making Milly ethereal and transcendent conveniently gives Densher "a symbol for his own salvation" (1). These critical positions questioning Densher serve to devillainize Kate.

Furthering Kate's resurrection in her own right is Lee Clark Mitchell who contends that "judged by consequences along," Kate "clearly does enrich others' experience" so that "deceit appears less a tool of self-interest than a mode of artful generosity, and disapproval of Kate soon seems far less appropriate than praise" (188). Incidentally, Millicent Bell--who calls Kate a "naturalist and pragmatist" (Meaning, 291)--and Douglas Paschall, see two heroines instead of one. Paschall senses that Kate and Milly are engaged in complicit maneuvers of achieving their respective ends, while Doran Larson reads the text as "Kate and Milly do[ing] things with Densher," so that the "moral economies for Densher operate within such a fixed-sum schema" (101). As can be seen, devillainizing or neutralizing Kate in combining her intent with that of Milly renders Densher's logic somewhat meager.

In this way, criticisms of The Wings have essentially been engaged in trying to identify the victim(s) and the victimizer(s), to apportion and assign responsibility and/or blame for the final outcome as depicted at the end of James's text: Milly is dead, Densher is evidently tormented, and Kate has suffered a "loss"--although neither the attitude in which Milly dies nor the validity of Densher's ongoing torment is agreed upon any more than is the specific nature of Kate's loss. In short, the scene of critical debate over The Wings is highly contradictory and unresolved.

"The only reason for the existence of a novel is that it does attempt to represent life," writes James ("The Art of Fiction," 46). As much an observer of the social scene and the behavior of individuals in it as an observer of the workings of the human mind, James, I believe, identified and illustrated those social forces identified by social psychologists that exert a powerful influence over human perception and behavior. In James's works as in real life, such forces are as much to blame for outcomes, if not more so, as human agents and their respective intents. Following this line of argument, this paper will incorporate a social psychological point of view. It aims to illustrate how the centers of consciousness in The Wings exist simultaneously on two levels of being, namely that of the "external," physical, and social world of front-stage public gatherings, backstage "private" conversations, face-to-face interaction rituals, and face-destroying moments of embarrassment, whose effects on human behavior sociologist Erving Goffman has amply elaborated on; and that of a phenomenological "internal" world of being where the self is constantly engaged in trying not only to make sense of itself but also to survive as an autonomous being in the aforementioned social, physical, and "external" world. Put differently, in the social world of The Wings, the world out there and the self within are not so much separate as they are organically connected, overlapping one another in reflexive ways, society and its "gaze" (1) comprising an essential aspect of the self, and the social self being a "real" entity of an "external" reality. Society is as much in self as self is in society, with both parts of the whole affecting and being affected by the other aspect of felt life.

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Milly Lamb - a fine anger. (political activist)
Magazine article from: Canadian Dimension Austin-Smith, Brenda March 1, 1992 700+ words
...a fully political life. Politics, for Milly, is not a collection of attitudes or stances...en route to a demonstration. Rather, Milly's politics have corners and stairs...established authorities and powers. But Milly is the last person to dismiss cavalierly...
Milly remembered with tears and laughter.
News wire article from: Europe Intelligence Wire October 9, 2002 700+ words
...WAS not just with tears that the life of Milly Dowler, the murdered Surrey schoolgirl...service was simply entitled "Remembering Milly", the name by which they all knew Amanda...playful and, above all, caring. "Milly seemed to have touched so many people in...
Milly's father tells of family's loss.
News wire article from: Europe Intelligence Wire October 9, 2002 700+ words
...moving tribute to Amanda - also known as Milly - at Guildford Cathedral. Mr Dowler...mourners: "We're so grateful that Milly was able to pack so much into her 13 years and bring so much happiness. "Milly, we know your memory will live on...
In the sunlight of the cathedral, Milly's spirit shone throughthe.
News wire article from: Europe Intelligence Wire October 9, 2002 700+ words
...reports NO ONE could quite say goodbye yet. Milly Dowler's remains were still in the hands...described as 'the forces of darkness'. Milly's father told the congregation that he...everyone knew they were now only memories. Milly Dowler had started to walk home from school...
Goodbye my dear sis Milly.
News wire article from: Europe Intelligence Wire October 9, 2002 700+ words
...feelings, grief and draining sadness of Milly Dowler's family finally erupted in a...s memorial service for their murdered Milly, her parents and sister had battened down...all too much for them. As if symbolic of Milly's soaring spirit, they released bunches...
WE MISS MILLY.
News wire article from: Europe Intelligence Wire October 9, 2002 700+ words
...daughter was snatched from him. Yesterday Milly Dowler's father Bob tried to answer just...had spoken - more than six months ago - Milly had assured him she was on her way home...the most difficult speech of his life. "Milly was many things to many people," he said...
Memorial service for Milly is time for tears and love.
News wire article from: Europe Intelligence Wire October 9, 2002 700+ words
...moving tribute to Amanda - also known as Milly - at Guildford Cathedral. Mr Dowler told...mourners: ''We're so grateful that Milly was able to pack so much into her 13 years and bring so much happiness. ''Milly, we know your memory will live on. What...
Prayers for Milly, `taken by sheer force of human evil'.
News wire article from: Europe Intelligence Wire September 23, 2002 700+ words
...Byline: ROBERT WESTHEAD MURDERED schoolgirl Milly Dowler was taken ``by the sheer force...the family home - after the discovery of Milly's remains in woodland 25 miles away in...sad. No one can hurt her now, darling Milly.'' But they vowed, ``We will not...
Milly police probe links with student's murder.
News wire article from: Europe Intelligence Wire March 15, 2005 700+ words
...Detectives hunting the killer of schoolgirl Milly Dowler are liaising with the police team...DETECTIVES hunting the killer of schoolgirl Milly Dowler are liaising with the police team...details of a major breakthrough in the Milly Dowler investigation and appealed for help...
Milly witness saw girl led across field by two men.
News wire article from: Europe Intelligence Wire October 16, 2002 700+ words
...two men may have been 13-year-old Milly Dowler minutes before she was murdered...Heath Wood, near Fleet, Hants, where Milly's body was found almost a month ago. The last confirmed sighting of Milly was at 4.08pm on March 21 as she walked...
For more facts and information, see all results

Source: HighBeam Research, Society in self, self in society: survival in The Wings of the Dove.

©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA