AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Who could be against "adequate" school funding?

National Review

| February 09, 2004 | Hanushek, Eric A. | COPYRIGHT 2004 National Review, Inc. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

Many states are currently locked in court battles in which they are being sued to provide "adequate" funding for their schools. These adequacy suits, which have spilled over into legislatures, represent yet another example of a situation where words and slogans do not match reality.

For three decades state school funding has been driven by a series of court cases concerned with fiscal equity. These cases have a common argument: the individual state constitutions require a greater parity in spending between rich and poor school districts than is typically observed under mixed state and local funding.

But the supporters of the lawsuits were dismayed by the end results. In fact, some state legislatures that were required by the courts to equalize spending across districts did not come up to the highest-spending districts but instead kept the overall level constant. The proponents of these suits were unhappy because their desire had been to pry more school spending out of the states.

In reaction to this apparently unfortunate outcome, a new kind of lawsuit and argument developed--the need for adequate spending. Under this new legal strategy, a system could be equalized but could still be inadequate to provide an appropriate education. For example, one group claimed that New York State was not providing the constitutionally required adequate spending to New York City, even though New York City schools were spending more than the average being spent in forty-two states.

For the proponents of greater school spending, adopting the word "adequate" was a great coup, similar to adopting the word "equity" many years before. Surely we all want both equitable and adequate spending.

The crucial ingredient to these arguments is an implicit presumption that ...

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Comptroller sees $7.5 billion of bond sales by New York, New York City,...
Magazine article from: The Bond Buyer Gasparino, Charles April 7, 1993 700+ words
...its bonding authorities, and New York City of about $4.52 billion. The...Other large offerings planned by New York City include an $800 million general...GO bond offering in June. The New York City Water Finance Authority, meanwhile...
USA. New York. New York City. 2001. Photographer Bruce DAVIDSON. Photographed...
Picture from: Magnum Photos Bruce Davidson January 1, 1900 700+ words
...01-01-1900 USA. New York. New York City. 2001. Photographer Bruce DAVIDSON...states of america new york state new york city usa continent us nyc american...and book covers usa. new york. new york city. 2001. photographer ...
USA.New York. New York City. Opening night of East of Eden. Fleur Cowles (left)...
Picture from: Magnum Photos Eve Arnold January 1, 1950 700+ words
...01-01-1950 USA.New York. New York City. Opening night of East of Eden...projection Media New York State New York City Cinema Auditorium Entertainment...entertainment) USA.New York. New York City. Opening night of East of ...
USA. New York. New York City. Christopher Isherwood and W.H. Auden. 1952....
Picture from: Magnum Photos Eve Arnold January 1, 1952 700+ words
...01-01-1952 USA. New York. New York City. Christopher Isherwood and W...America Nationality New York State New York City Profession Artistic profession...Famous person USA. New York. New York City. Christopher Isherwood ...
USA. New York. New York City. Viewers with Gicometti's statue, Museum of Modern...
Picture from: Magnum Photos Eve Arnold January 1, 1960 700+ words
...01-01-1960 USA. New York. New York City. Viewers with Gicometti's statue...Manhattan Museum New York State New York City Continent Museum (name of) Culture...Y.C. MOMA USA. New York. New York City. Viewers with ...
USA. New York. New York City. Owner of 711 Bar. 1950. (LON42916)
Picture from: Magnum Photos Eve Arnold January 1, 1950 700+ words
...01-01-1950 USA. New York. New York City. Owner of 711 Bar. 1950. Keywords...States of America New York State New York City Catering Trade & services...NYC N.Y.C. USA. New York. New York City. Owner of 711 Bar. 1950. ...
USA. New York. New York City. Edward STEICHEN, director of photography at The...
Picture from: Magnum Photos Eve Arnold January 1, 1959 700+ words
...01-01-1959 USA. New York. New York City. Edward STEICHEN, director of...Museum Nationality New York State New York City Optical instrument Photographer...Old man MOMA USA. New York. New York City. Edward STEICHEN, ...
USA. New York. New York City. Museum of Modern Art. 1960. (LON40236)
Picture from: Magnum Photos Eve Arnold January 1, 1960 700+ words
...01-01-1960 USA. New York. New York City. Museum of Modern Art. 1960...Manhattan Museum New York State New York City Continent Museum (name of) Culture...Y.C. MOMA USA. New York. New York City. Museum of Modern Art. 1960...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA