AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

"The one poor word" in Middlemarch.

Studies in English Literature, 1500-1900

| September 22, 2004 | Purdy, Dwight H. | COPYRIGHT 2004 Rice University. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

George Eliot's synthesis of sympathy and irony in Middlemarch (1871-72) and the impressive unity of the novel's details--of metaphors, motifs, images, and allusions--have been at the center of George Eliot criticism for many years. Granted, one does not even need deconstruction to sense imperfections in that unity, as Barbara Hardy argued long ago in examining the inadequacies of Will Ladislaw. (1) George Eliot's ethic of sympathy also raises questions about her realism. (2) Nonetheless, extremely minute details vibrate in tremolo for the attentive reader, especially when one keeps in mind that synthesis of sympathy and irony. (3) This essay will treat one very small detail indeed, a single monosyllabic adjective, an adjective that in Middlemarch distributes sympathy and irony in roughly equal portions.

The adjective, as my title implies, is the humble "poor," used as a term of commiseration and thus often followed hard by a proper noun. Excluding all other meanings of the term such as "low," "inadequate," or "impoverished," I make out 145 instances of the commiserating "poor" in Middlemarch. Its chief recipients, as one would expect, are Dorothea, Rosamond, Lydgate, and Casaubon, with Rosamond (perhaps surprisingly) leading them all, a disposition that I hope to show tells us something about how and why George Eliot mixes irony with sympathy. Rosamond gets the adjective 26 times, Dorothea 22, Casaubon 12, and Lydgate 9. But other instances, especially the first two that set the theme, are worth attending.

With wonderful portentousness for Middlemarch, the OED, to exemplify the commiserating sense of "poor," cites Sir Humphrey Davy with whom the genial Arthur Brooke dined years ago, accompanied by William Wordsworth, as we learn in the first paragraph of the second chapter. (4) In this sense, the term means "so circumstanced so as to excite one's compassion or pity," and the OED adds that "In many parts of England" the word regularly refers to "the dead of whom one knew." (5)

The adjective is one of George Eliot's verbal tics. Laurence Lerner, writing about her Felix Holt: The Radical (1866), notes one instance of the rhetorical impact of "poor." To show the unevenness of that novel, he contrasts two brief passages from one chapter concerning Mrs. Transome: the first concerns her relationship with her maid of forty years, Denner; the second deals with the heroine, Esther. The first, spare and direct, Lerner prefers to the second, heavily adjectival, especially the offensive "poor": Esther "kissed [Mrs. Transome's] poor quivering lips and eyelids." The adjective, Lerner says, "is a direct assault on the reader." (6) Even here I suspect the adjective has more meanings than the indictment suggests, as it does throughout George Eliot's fiction. For instance, in chapter 13 of "Janet's Repentance," the final story in Scenes of Clerical Life (1858), the adjective is applied to Janet Dempster three times, as the narrator prepares for the climax when her alcoholic husband Mr. Dempster forces her out of the house at midnight. It suggests not only the narrator's compassion and pity but also Janet's state as one among the living dead, a condition created by her abusive husband and her own alcoholism. "Poor Janet" lives "in leaden stupor." (7) The word appears prominently in Adam Bede (1859) as the plot moves toward Hetty Sorrel's suffering. Particularly notable is an instance in which George Eliot weds "sympathy" to the adjective. The narrator tells us that sympathy comes from suffering, such suffering as Adam Bede's in his blasted love for Hetty and his respect for Arthur Donnithorne: "Let us rather be thankful that our sorrow lives in us as an indestructible force, only changing its form, as forces do, and passing from pain into sympathy--the one poor word which includes all our best insight and our best love." (8) Here George Eliot invests "poor" with ennobling irony, related to but transcending the depreciatory sense of the word. To be "poor" in this way is to be rich with feeling, and, as Adam learns, "'feeling's a sort o' knowledge.'" (9) "Poor" passes into metaphor as it does in The Mill on the Floss.

Although The Mill on the Floss (1860) uses the adjective fewer times than Middlemarch (only 45). George Eliot's second novel embeds several senses of the word into the plot, the consequences of Mr. Tulliver's failed lawsuit and Tom's eventual repayment of the debt. At one point, just as Tom sets out to restore the family's money and respectability, the narrator juxtaposes the metaphorical and denotative meanings in a single paragraph. At sixteen, "Poor Tom was not without hopes to take refuge in," reflecting that "[b]oth Mr Glegg and Mr Deane ... had been very poor once." Tom resolves to imitate his Uncle Deane because "[i]t was intolerable to think of being poor and looked down upon all one's life." (10) George Eliot balances sympathy and judgment here. Young Tom, whatever his faults, deserves our respect for his determination to set things right, yet at the same time he is "poor" in the sense that he acts always in accordance with the worshipful materialism of the "emmet-like Dodsons and Tullivers." (11) No one in the novel is more the victim of that value than Mrs. Tulliver, and perhaps to drive the moral home, she gets the adjective 8 times, equally distributed between the narrator and other characters. (12) For that same reason, the word identifies Tulliver's sister, the desperately impoverished and perfectly named Gritty. (13) Maggie, of course, leads all the rest with 16 instances, though in her case, unlike Tom's, the word often seems a rhetorical reflex action rather than a necessity derived from the plot or the nature of the narrator's analysis. The very last instance is such a case, coming just before brother and sister go down into the raging Floss: "Tom rowed with untired vigour, and with a different speed from poor Maggie's." (14) "Poor Tom" would be more to the point, since his "vigour," so the text implies, sends them to their doom. (15) Granted that reading, "Poor Tom" would neatly address the gender bias foregrounded in the earlier parts of the novel. Indeed, Maggie is anything but "poor" at this moment, if we are to believe her dearest wish to be reunited with the beloved Tom. "Poor Maggie" seems a symptom of the notoriously vexed ending of this novel.

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
HOSPITAL BACK IN GOOD HEALTH; George Eliot goes from one of worst to among best.
Newspaper article from: Coventry Evening Telegraph (England) August 15, 2009 700+ words
...the hospital trust." George Eliot Hospital could win the...further questions as to why George Eliot's bid for Foundation...hospital's historically poor mortality rates were...status would have earned George Eliot more control overs its...
Charles Grant, a literary mediator: With three unpublished letters to George...
Magazine article from: The Modern Language Review Trainer, James April 1, 1999 700+ words
...in this world are those Two poor Volumes; scattered fragments...claim for the literary merits of George Eliot: 'George Eliot is in my opinion the greatest...of Thackeray the position of George Eliot as the greatest English novelist...
Identifying the Remains: George Eliot's Death in the London Religious...
Magazine article from: The Modern Language Review Wright, Terry R. July 1, 2008 700+ words
Identifying the Remains: George Eliot's Death in the London Religious...of the contemporary responses to George Eliot's death offers a fascinating snapshot...reporting her as the daughter of a poor clergyman adopted early in life by...
Truth so difficult: George Eliot and Georg Buchner, a shared time.
Magazine article from: The Modern Language Review Stern, Sheila January 1, 2001 700+ words
...Chapter 17 of Adam Bede (1), George Eliot makes a strong appeal for what...in this essay is to suggest that George Eliot may have come across Buchner...practical benefactor of the grindingly poor mountain parish in Alsace, where...
Works of George Eliot: Middlemarch: Chapters 36 - 47
Reference information from: Monarch Notes Eliot, George January 1, 1963 700+ words
...Thirty-Seven Comment: In the beginning of this chapter, George Eliot discusses the political situation of the era. George IV is...alone, she has the opportunity to think of the family's poor treatment of Will's grandmother. She was cut off from the...
Works of George Eliot: Introduction
Reference information from: Monarch Notes Eliot, George January 1, 1963 700+ words
...and social crises. These years, the years of maturity for George Eliot (1819-1880), and the period of the narrative in Middlemarch...Reform Bill of 1832 failed to extend the franchise to the poorer classes; this fact, and a widespread discontent with economic...
The web of necessity: George Eliot's theory of ideology.(Characters in...
Magazine article from: Texas Studies in Literature and Language Gindele, Karen C. September 22, 2000 700+ words
...fitfully illuminated life. (Middlemarch, 200) Metaphors: Poor Mr Casaubon had imagined that his long studious bachelorhood...this challenge, first coming from Pater in 1867, whether George Eliot got it directly from him or from the wider concerns of their...
Eliot's Adam Bede.(George Eliot)
Magazine article from: The Explicator Phillips, Emily June 22, 2004 700+ words
...marriage (just not to him) to mend her broken heart. Yet George Eliot deliberately presents childbearing and child rearing as a negative...up this pessimistic view of matronhood, claiming that the "poor draggletails o' wives you see, like bits o' gauze ribbin...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA