AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

International migration and the growth of households in Sydney: a comment.

People and Place

| April 01, 2004 | Curnow, Jill | COPYRIGHT 2004 Monash University, Centre for Population and Urban Research. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

The previous issue of People and Place contains a paper by Peter McDonald and Jeromey Temple which analyses house-hold formation in NSW under various assumptions regarding Annual Net Migration (ANM). (1) The declared purpose of the paper is to 'draw conclusions from the results of some recent housing demand projections that we have completed'. (2) To this end a newly-developed model called Ozhouse is applied to regional housing demand projections from the year 2001 to 2031. Five alternative Scenarios or Series are postulated with varying rates of international and internal migration in and out of NSW in general and of Sydney in particular.

The lowest rate of international migration considered in the paper is zero net. This is outlined as Series 4 and unsurprisingly yields the lowest rate of population increase and household formation of the five alternative scenarios, particularly in Sydney (Figures 3 and 5). The results in these Figures indicate that international immigration is a major cause of housing demand in Sydney, but this is not the conclusion drawn in this paper.

The paper describes the Series 4 zero net migration series as 'a hypothetical counter-factual'. (3) The results of the Series are largely sidelined or disregarded by the authors. The purpose of the present comment is to question four assertions made in the paper and suggest that an alternative concluding remark would fit the authors' data extremely well.

Table 1 in the paper outlines annual net migration, international and internal combined, for Sydney and the balance of NSW, in 2001 and 2030, according to the five migration scenarios. It shows that under Series 4 Sydney would have an annual loss of about 12,000 people while the balance of NSW would grow by about 20,000 per annum. Thus zero net migration would reduce pressure on Sydney while providing a population boost to the regions, a result that many would regard as highly desirable. However McDonald and Temple exclude Series 4 from consideration on the grounds that it is 'very hypothetical'. (4) This is a curious argument since all projections are based on hypothetical assumptions, and no explanation is offered as to why this assumption is more hypothetical than any other.

McDonald and Temple claim that 'on present trends, the imbalance between projected numbers of aged people and workers in coastal areas of NSW is unsustainable'. (5) This statement is not substantiated and appears to be based on a general fear of an ageing society, a fear which has often been shown to be exaggerated. (6)

The population pyramid for Series 4 (Figure 3) shows a drop in numbers at younger age groups by the year 2031, so that 'the numbers entering the young adult ages would shrink even more rapidly after 2030'. (7) The authors describe this situation as 'a very unlikely and very undesirable outcome', (8) without substantiating either viewpoint. Given the present political climate the result may be unlikely in Australia but it already pertains in other countries such as Japan and Spain, both of which nations have had low fertility rates for some years, so the result is presumably not impossible in Australia. The authors' claim that the result is undesirable may reflect their own views, but a demographic outcome which could lead to a reduction in population size has many arguments in its favour. Indeed, it is often claimed that a fall in numbers is imperative if future generations are to enjoy a comfortable standard of living.

Figures 6 and 7 graph the growth in Sydney of households with persons aged 60+ and indicate that this rate of growth varies little with the different immigration scenarios. The authors comment that 'the ageing of the population is driving much of Sydney's future household growth'. (9) ...

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Sydney's Century: A History. (JAS Review of Books). (book review)
Magazine article from: Journal of Australian Studies Collins, Jock December 1, 2001 700+ words
Peter Spearritt, Sydney's Century: A History, University of New South Wales Press, Sydney, 2000, 319 pp, hb $79.95. In the past...and Australian history. At the same time the Sydney Olympic Games put Sydney in the international...
Sydney prices fall as other Australian cities gain ground Home values in the...
Newspaper article from: South China Morning Post February 22, 2006 700+ words
...Morning Post) Byline: Lachlan Colquhoun in Sydney Real estate agents are talking it up and...showing strong auction clearance rates in Sydney, Melbourne and Adelaide. But this has...the state of the Australian market. The Sydney market, for example, has historically...
SYDNEY GAS BOARD REJECTS BID OF QUEENSLAND GAS.
News wire article from: AsiaPulse News April 18, 2006 700+ words
...April 18 Asia Pulse - Takeover target Sydney Gas Ltd (ASX:SGL) today released its...opportunistic and highly conditional. The Sydney Gas board has unanimously recommended...offer of one its shares for every two Sydney Gas shares. In its target's statement...
Sydney.(high tech hotels services)
Magazine article from: PC Magazine Rhey, Erik November 7, 2006 700+ words
WHILE YOU'RE IN TOWN Sydney is a truly world-class city in the...On the must-do list is the amazing Sydney Aquarium, where you can get up close...and saltwater crocs. The stunning Sydney Opera House is great too; you've...
Sydney at the millennium.(recent demographic history of largest metropolitan...
Magazine article from: People and Place Parr, Angelique Culpin, Alison April 1, 2005 700+ words
Sydney continues to dominate Australia's urban...the new millennium. This paper reviews Sydney's recent demographic history to explain...Housing. For the purposes of this paper, Sydney refers to the Sydney Statistical Division...
Sydney Olympic Village Becomes Largest MICROS-Fidelio Front Office Installation...
Press release article from: PR Newswire September 14, 2000 700+ words
...hospitality industry, announced that the Sydney Olympic Village has become the latest...Fidelio. The total number of rooms for the Sydney Olympic Village amounts to 13,748 with...Brian Dumka, Village Systems Manager, Sydney Organizing Committee for the Olympic Games...
Splendiferous Sydney.
News wire article from: Asia Africa Intelligence Wire May 22, 2003 700+ words
...TAEMSAMRAN It can be love at first sight. If you land in Sydney and take a stroll around the city you can't help falling...Five days there, I found five different ways to admire Sydney. Sydney is a city that boasts the world's most beautiful bay...
Sydney Impone su marca.(De Viaje)
Newspaper article from: Reforma (México D.F., México) September 3, 2000 700+ words
Byline: Alicia Boy Sydney 2000 Semilla de la Australia moderna Sydney, es la metrpoli ms grande de Oceana; una ciudad llena...Olimpiadas del 2000,conzcala disfrutndola plenamente Sydney es la puerta de entrada al continente australiano...
Sydney to Hobart the race history 1945-2000.
Magazine article from: Offshore Yachting December 1, 2001 700+ words
...Australia's most famous ocean race, the annual Sydney to Hobart. Now in its 57th year, the Sydney to Hobart ranks in world status with the Fastnet...Zealand Endeavour (named Tasmania for the 50th Sydney to Hobart in 1994), Ragamuffin, Morning...
Camino a Sydney/ Breves.(Deportes)
Newspaper article from: Reforma (México D.F., México) September 12, 2000 700+ words
COMITE OLIMPICO Anuncian reformas SYDNEY.- El Comit Olmpico Internacional reestructurar luego de Sydney 2000 no slo el programa deportivo de los...Asamblea de este organismo, reunida en Sydney, que antes de fin de ao se decidir la posible...
For more facts and information, see all results

Source: HighBeam Research, International migration and the growth of households in Sydney: a...

©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA