AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Bioethics and the Constitution.

The Public Interest

| June 22, 2004 | Schaub, Diana | COPYRIGHT 2004 The National Affairs, Inc. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

WHEN I mentioned the topic of my essay to a man well-versed in these matters, he suggested that I respond to the question of the relation between bioethics and the Constitution as Justice Antonin Scalia might. As Supreme Court watchers know, Scalia is famous for his scathing dissents in which he chastises his fellow judges for sounding off on any and all subjects without any constitutional warrant for doing so. Scalia's complaint is that judges regularly issue opinions untethered from the text of the Constitution, despite their clear obligation to remain tied to the document. One of my favorite of Scalia's tongue-lashings comes from Hodgson v. Minnesota, an abortion case from 1990, in which Scalia declared:

 
   One will search in vain the document we are supposed to be construing 
   for text that provides the basis for the argument over these 
   distinctions.... The tools for this job are not to be found in the 
   lawyer's--and hence not in the judge's--workbox. I continue to 
   dissent from this enterprise of devising an Abortion Code, and from 
   the illusion that we have authority to do so. 

If I take my cue from Scalia, the most straightforward answer I could give would be that we can't know how to think about bioethics and the Constitution since there is nothing there to think about. The Constitution is silent on such matters, whether it be the most dramatic, but still unrealized, biotech possibilities like human cloning or increasingly routine options like in vitro fertilization (IVF), embryo screening, and drugs to alter mood, enhance performance, and prolong life.

The silence of the Constitution is not a fault, nor a cause for distress. When the Constitution is silent, it simply means that the matter is one for the current generation to address. We will, of course, do so through the political structures established by the Constitution. Accordingly, the silence of the Constitution might best be understood as an invitation to practice self-government as the Founders understood it. Their great achievement was to draft a fundamental charter that leaves each generation largely free to direct its own affairs.

This is a tremendously important constitutional lesson. There is a marked tendency among Americans to venerate the Constitution and to turn to it for answers. At the very least, we scour the Constitution for evidence in support of the answers we happen to favor. These habits speak well of us, inasmuch as they demonstrate filial piety. However, we should remember that the Constitution is not like the Bible: It does not offer a moral code, rules for living, or even maxims of government. The Constitution never sought to provide answers for the dilemmas of future generations. After all, those dilemmas were quite literally unimaginable at the time. What it did do, though, was establish a framework to work through those dilemmas. In the words of political scientist Herbert Storing, "The substance [of the Constitution] is a design of government with powers to act and a structure arranged to make it act wisely and responsibly. It is in that design ... that the security of American civil and political liberty lies."

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
SCALIA SAYS HE'S FOR `DEAD CONSTITUTION' PROTESTERS RALLY OUTSIDE...
Newspaper article from: The Capital Times (Madison, WI) Nathans, Aaron Elbow, Steven March 16, 2001 700+ words
...originalist view of the Constitution, Scalia would have supported...document." "A dead Constitution -- that's what I'm selling," Scalia said to laughter...decency" to the Constitution, Scalia maintained, "Evolving...
SCALIA DECRIES CONSTITUTION THAT'S MALLEABLE THE CONSERVATIVE SUPREME COURT...
Newspaper article from: Wisconsin State Journal (Madison, WI) Segall, Cary March 16, 2001 700+ words
...way of interpreting the Constitution. Scalia told about 475 people...rooted in the words of the Constitution and intent of the framers...example, the conservative Scalia said he finds in the Constitution no right to die, no right...
Rehnquist, Avoiding Controversy, Addresses ABA on Constitution;Scalia Warns of...
Newspaper article from: The Washington Post Al Kamen February 16, 1987 700+ words
...speech hailing the Constitution's bicentennial...powers to interpret the Constitution to protect individual...Court Justice Antonin Scalia told the ABA that the...make certain that the Constitution would not become a...as chief justice. Scalia, in his first speech...
Constitution safe with Scalia
Newspaper article from: Chicago Sun-Times Norman Podhoretz June 28, 1986 700+ words
...issues not covered by the Constitution, become irrelevant. Scalia has decided against...decided in favor of the Constitution. That is why everyone...government enshrined in the Constitution should applaud Scalia's nomination.
Tribe and scalia on the constitution: A Third View.(US Supreme Court Justice...
Magazine article from: World and I Kapla, Morton A. April 1, 1999 700+ words
...the Court misread the Constitution. A relatively recent...by Justice Antonin Scalia and includes critical...determine what the Constitution means and, hence...of the text of the Constitution. It is by showing...positions of Justice Scalia and Professor Tribe...
Scalia and the Constitution.(LETTERS)
Newspaper article from: The Washington Times March 2, 2006 700+ words
...Justice Antonin Scalia's immoderate...breathing Constitution makes a good...of Justice Scalia's comments regarding the Constitution as a "living...by Justice Scalia's comments...interpretations of the Constitution made in the...
Scalia says Constitution recognizes no right to die But with case pending,...
Newspaper article from: The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel October 29, 1996 700+ words
...right to die," Scalia said Oct. 18 at...suicide" when the Constitution was drafted, he...before the court." Scalia said courts should...exist when the Constitution was drafted...suicide issue, Scalia told students at...right to die in the Constitution.
SCALIA PRAISES AND SUSPENDS CONSTITUTION.(Editorial)(Editorial)
Newspaper article from: The Post-Standard (Syracuse, NY) April 10, 2004 700+ words
...Justice Antonin Scalia provided an ironic...what makes our Constitution so special...persuade you that our Constitution is something extraordinary...was the arrogance Scalia displayed when...or agreement, Scalia and his marshals...to suspend the Constitution.
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA