AccessMyLibrary provides FREE access to over 30 million articles from top publications available through your library.

Mary Ann Frese Witt. The Search for Modern Tragedy: Aesthetic Fascism in Italy and France.(Book Review)

Comparative Drama

| September 22, 2002 | Hinden, Michael | COPYRIGHT 2002 www.wmich.edu/compdr. This material is published under license from the publisher through the Gale Group, Farmington Hills, Michigan.  All inquiries regarding rights should be directed to the Gale Group. (Hide copyright information)Copyright

Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2001. Pp. xii + 259. $45.00.

The dust jacket informs us that in this study, Mary Ann Frese Witt "explores the work of a group of European writers and artists who came to fascism by way of aesthetics." That is a fair description, but it might be said of this group that their art was as regrettable as their political destination. Today, who has patience for the work of Gabriele D'Annunzio and his fanatic followers, or Thierry Maulnier, Robert Brasillach, Drieu La Rochelle, and Henry de Montherlant in France? Of course, Witt does, but then she is a very patient critic. Some of her readings, perhaps, are longer than might be warranted by the plays. However, her meticulous and valuable intellectual history of Italy and France between the wars amply justifies this effort. For readers who may not be familiar with the writings of the fascist literati, this is an important study. At least two of the playwrights covered--Luigi Pirandello and Jean Anouilh--have claims on our attention, and Witt provides shrewd insights into their work by reconstituting the political and aesthetic debates out of which their art emerged.

Witt uses the term "aesthetic fascism" to delineate the nexus of ideas that shaped the dramaturgy of these figures--a term more nuanced than "fascist aesthetics," which carries the implication of party propaganda. The playwrights under consideration varied in their political commitments, but all were drawn to a movement in the arts inspired by reactionary thinkers, among them the early interpreters of Nietzsche. A key figure in this study is Gabriele D'Annunzio (1863-1938), who hailed the rise of Mussolini but drew mainly on his reading of Nietzsche for his dramatic credo. (That he misread Nietzsche is an important point not treated by Witt.) D'Annunzio was deaf to Nietzsche's irony, and turning his subtle aphorisms into briefs for fascist drama, he glorified the will to power (as domination), the superman (as a political type), irrationality (as a critique of modernity), Dionysian spectacle (as a means to sway the masses), transcendence of good and evil (as a platform for self-aggrandizement), and nostalgia for the classical world (as a call to arms for the new Rome). It is little wonder that D'Annunzio's plays resemble second-rate Italian opera scaled for grand outdoor productions. Indeed, such productions occurred, and Mussolini admired them. Today these inflated plays (at least in English translation) are barely readable; they are stilted, bombastic, narcissistic, and declamatory. Witt labors to bring six of them to life through detailed examination: The Dead City, Fedra, Iorio's Daughter, The Ship, Glory, and Beyond Love. But the work resists reanimation, even at the hands of a skilled critic.

Witt makes a case for D'Annunzio as "the primary figure responsible for attempting to apply Nietzsche's ideas in The Birth of Tragedy to the actual creation of modern tragedy" (33). But a stronger case can be made, I think, for Eugene O'Neill, who read Nietzsche with better understanding and with better result. (In the 1920s O'Neill modeled his most successful plays on The Birth of Tragedy.) According to Nietzsche, the tragic hero embodies the collective identity of the community, symbolized by the god Dionysus, but distorts that identity, impelled by the principle of individuation, symbolized by the god Apollo. The hero who has violated unity by self-assertion must pay a penalty, and the tragic conflict is resolved only when his mask of individuation is destroyed. To serve its political aims, the dogma of aesthetic fascism turned Nietzsche inside out. D'Annunzio romanticizes the hero's individuation, invests him with power to bend the community to his will, and, in the event of his failure, finds the community unworthy of his sacrifice. That may have been Mussolini's understanding of the tragic, but it was not Nietzsche's.

Pirandello set a different course in drama, yet he joined the Fascist Party in Italy--a step D'Annunzio never took. According to the author, his ...

Related articles from newspapers, magazines, journals, and more
Annunzio will push thrifts to provide more home loans
Newspaper article from: Chicago Sun-Times Jerome Idaszak April 10, 1989 700+ words
...loan industry observers, Rep. Frank Annunzio (D-Ill.) said he will push hard...required to commit for residential housing. Annunzio, chairman of the House Banking subcommittee...of sharply rising interest rates. But Annunzio told the Chicago Sun-Times that he...
Gabriele d'Annunzio tra Italia e Inghilterra.(Book review)
Magazine article from: The Modern Language Review Lindon, John April 1, 2006 700+ words
Gabriele d'Annunzio tra Italia e Inghilterra. By JOHN WOODHOUSE...admirable 1998 biography Gabriele d'Annunzio, Defiant Archangel, reviewed in MLR...opening survey of 'La fortuna di d'Annunzio in Inghilterra' (pp. 7-24) leads...
D'Annunzio and Alma-Tadema: between pre-raphaelitism and aestheticism.
Magazine article from: The Modern Language Review Pieri, Giuliana April 1, 2001 700+ words
...century Italian art, Gabriele D'Annunzio (1863-1938) stands out as a central figure. D'Annunzio went through a distinct Pre-Raphaelite...both derived from and reacted to D'Annunzio's; he introduced the Italian painter...
Gabriele D'Annunzio: Defiant Archangel.(Review)
Magazine article from: The Modern Language Review Mcwillia, G.H. April 1, 1999 700+ words
Gabriele D'Annunzio: Defiant Archangel. By JOHN WOODHOUSE...deceitful, and despicable than Gabriele D'Annunzio? Possibly there was, though it is...between the two being that unlike D'Annunzio, Cepperello was as fond of women as...
'Il gran Pan non e morto': the vitality of D'Annunzio's irrepressible...
Magazine article from: The Modern Language Review Woodhouse, J.R. October 1, 2002 700+ words
...the critical fortunes of Gabriele D'Annunzio stood at such a high point as during...hundreds of letters exchanged between D'Annunzio and his mistress-housekeeper, Luisa...of the cache of manuscripts that D'Annunzio managed to rescue from his creditors...
Annunzio questions bank-sales benefits. (Frank Annunzio)
Magazine article from: National Underwriter Property & Casualty-Risk & Benefits Management Brostoff, Steven March 5, 1990 700+ words
Annunzio Questions Bank-Sales Benefits WASHINGTON...deal for consumers," said Rep. Frank Annunzio, D-Ill., chairman of the House Banking...allowed into the insurance business. Rep. Annunzio, who spoke at a Chicago meeting of the...
Annunzio blasts bank/ins. ties; sets Merchant National hearing. (Frank Annunzio)
Magazine article from: National Underwriter Life & Health-Financial Services Edition Brostoff, Steven February 26, 1990 700+ words
Annunzio Blasts Bank/Ins. Ties; Sets Merchant...deal for consumers," said Rep. Frank Annunzio, D-Ill., chairman of the House Banking...allowed into the insurance business. Rep. Annunzio, who spoke at a Chicago meeting of the...
D'Annunzio, Fiume & fascism: Robert Pearce examines the career of Mussolini's...
Magazine article from: History Review Pearce, Robert September 1, 2009 700+ words
...adventurer. Soon the name Gabriele d'Annunzio was on everyone's lips. As a celebrated...aviator and self-styled superman--d'Annunzio was no stranger to publicity. Indeed...peacemakers of Versailles (dubbed by d'Annunzio 'three old idiots'), who insisted...
For more facts and information, see all results
©2009 Gale, a part of Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.
About us | FAQs | Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms and conditions
Other Gale sites: Encyclopedia.com | HighBeam Research | Acquire Content | Books & Authors | Goliath | MovieRetriever | Smart QandA